Right when Baloch start asking for their Legitimate rights people termed them as "Naraaz Baloch" when FATA people ask to leave them alone and let them lives by their Tribal rules and dont even accept Pakistani laws they still remain Patriotic but when Karachiite as whole ask for something they become Enemy of Pakistan and Traitors and what not (despite all those allegations were refuted by same people in the past) what would you consider that Mindset....I dont believe that would fall into "Circular mindset". You have been to Karachi you are also aware of Karachi Problem as well and our Law enforcement attitude towards solving them Do you find any such example in other Provinces?I will term this Circular Mindset (like circular debt) where everyone is aggressor and aggrieved at the same time, FATA, KPK, Baluchistan, Punjab everyone has their grievances and fingers pointed at others. The only difference is people of Karachi are educated they can make the difference but they insist on being part of problem not the solution. Ask youth of Karachi how many of them are willing to serve Pakistan Army? Police? Civil services, most of them you would find are looking for immigration. So I don't see and end to this problem without a drastic change in attitude of Pakistanis.
Karachi Circular Railway was a true blessing, I would commute my two hours journey in just 20 minutes. Then again railway as a whole is a loss making entity and burden on our national treasury. As far as BRT are concerned transporters of Karachi are a strong cartel they won't let anybody survive otherwise I remember traveling in nice green buses which are sitting now somewhere in junkyards.
Indeed Pakistan Railway is loss making entity but Public Private Partnership can make it work K Electric is such an example also PTCL and about Transport Cartels then they are not Totaly uncontrollable if Govt is Willing to put their efforts into it since we dont expect Provincial Govt to do that but even federal Govt. has not shown any Interest in this issue is mind boggling because it is Federal Govt which COLLECTS revenues not Provincial Govt. and Karachiite despite of all its Problem still has $78 Billion GDP out of close to $245 Billion of whole Pakistan.
MQM did provide a platform to mediocre Pakistanis to participate in National politics and raise their voices, it has its discipline and some good people too but again the bad side of it over weighs the potential it holds to make positive contribution. Rest PTI, PPP, PMLN, ANP etc all are useless and thrive for their self interests only.
Most those Bad side is more of Fragment of our minds. When any crime inside Karachi happened People outside Karachi Automatically Associate it with MQM Despite their are so many other Criminal elements which are known throughout for their Notoriety. When those same MQM so called Criminal Elements are given Authority in the Govt. they also made an Example.of Good Governance as well. What would you consider that??For your Info MQM also have Accountability as well and which is lot better then other Parties in Pakistan but most of the time they are not consulted by Law enforcement Authority and this is actual reason for all the Backlash happened after their members get Extra Judicially Killed(I think That is Illegal BTW) So what do you expect them to do?Sit their until every single one of them are Kidnapped and Killed by Authorities? They have been Accused for so long without any Actual evidence and Ethnic and regional Biased against them are also strong by rest of Pakistan so in this situation what do you even expect???