Border killing very shameful: Bangladesh FM

[VikingRaider]

Bangladeshi cow smugglers deserve the honour of being shot by BOF-made bullets rather than being dragged around in foreign land.

As I said, a criminal who crosses into foreign land is at their mercy.

Brother @Al-Ansar, if someone want to shoot a theif for stealing 1 dozen egg, and if they are at their mercy because they went to steal in a foreign land, then there is nothing I can say! I thought we are living in a modern world where there are laws and regulations. Well if I am wrong and we are still living in a savage age, then I also strongly recommend BGB to shoot Indian fishermen at sight instead of arresting them. We also should not show mercy when they are in our area. So we can successfully turn this region into a hell!


Ps: @Axomiya_lora and other Indian fellas, I know you fully agree with me too, since only this procedure can create balance! You will agree because you know that Bangladesh can't afford direct enmity with India, atleast not yet. Well in future if we can strengthen our army and can give India the proper answer for its border killing, I hope you will no longer be pleased for this balance theory!
Every big country who intended to be super power wants a militarily weak neighbor with docile foreign policy. But later when situation changed they no longer remain such agreeable!

 

[sohail.ishaque]

Do you have comprehension issues? The Bangladeshi smugglers getting shot get shot in Indian territory.
As I said, a criminal who crosses into foreign land is at their mercy.
As for prosecution: do you have any clue about border management? Get off your couch and go talk to your border guards.
It is impossible for BGB to abandon posts and chase down so many smugglers (often heavily armed).

Some of you have Indian chips on your shoulders which shut your brains down whenever you hear the word "India".
Believe whatever you want.

Go explain your couch theories on your beloved smugglers to the families of these BGB men. Maybe your hugs and kisses to smugglers would have prevented these incidents.

Benapole ‘gunfight’: Injured BGB man dies at CMH
https://www.thedailystar.net/country/news/benapole-gunfight-injured-bgb-man-dies-cmh-1778626

Smugglers injure BGB member
https://www.thedailystar.net/news/smugglers-injure-bgb-member

U shud had given this lecture to ur FM who felt ashamed because his country men had been killed by anyother country. And u shud recommend some kind of medal for Indian jawans killing ur people. More bangaldeshi people killer should be awarded higher. That way they'll try harder to kill ur people and get appreciation from both sides of the line.

 

[Destranator]

U shud had given this lecture to ur FM who felt ashamed because his country men had been killed by anyother country. And u shud recommend some kind of medal for Indian jawans killing ur people. More bangaldeshi people killer should be awarded higher. That way they'll try harder to kill ur people and get appreciation from both sides of the line.

Again, more emotional diatribe from you with no factual counter-arguments to my posts. Done talking to you.

Brother @Al-Ansar, if someone want to shoot a theif for stealing 1 dozen egg, and if they are at their mercy because they went to steal in a foreign land, then there is nothing I can say! I thought we are living in a modern world where there are laws and regulations. Well if I am wrong and we are still living in a savage age, then I also strongly recommend BGB to shoot Indian fishermen at sight instead of arresting them. We also should not show mercy when they are in our area. So we can successfully turn this region into a hell!

Brother I think I have explained the economic, health and bio-security risks posed by smuggling which is a bit more serious than bringing in stolen eggs.
We have tried arresting and prosecuting smugglers for the last 47 years. Has that stopped them or have things gotten worse over the years? Have Indian fishermen stopped invading BD?

Do you really think there are no alternative, legal work opportunities available for smugglers in this day and age? These are not honest men looking for a living; They are hardened criminals with no regard for the health and wellbeing of Bangladeshis.

Illicit drugs are ruining lives in BD. Diseased Indian cattle can wipe out all farms in an entire district. You have to look at the bigger picture.

As I said, South Asians are not civilised enough to understand the consequences of their actions. Start shooting and see how smuggling stops overnight.

 

[bluesky]

Do you really think there are no alternative, legal work opportunities available for smugglers in this day and age? These are not honest men looking for a living; They are hardened criminals with no regard for the health and wellbeing of Bangladeshis.

But, killing the criminals by gunfire is no answer as well. BSF kills a smuggler not to protect India but when he fails to pay the promised bribes.

 

[Destranator]

But, killing the criminals by gunfire is no answer as well. BSF kills a smuggler not to protect India but when he fails to pay the promised bribes.

What India does to them is irrelevant as it is our security at stake. The only way smuggling would stop is when BGB starts shooting. The risk would outweigh the benefit for smugglers making it financially unfeasible for them to sell smuggled goods in BD.

 

[UKBengali]

But, killing the criminals by gunfire is no answer as well. BSF kills a smuggler not to protect India but when he fails to pay the promised bribes.

Simple logic why smuggling keeps happening despite the fact that BSF has shoot on site policy.
It is because nothing happens to most smugglers as they pay the bribes to the BSF.

What India does to them is irrelevant as it is our security at stake. The only way smuggling would stop is when BGB starts shooting. The risk would outweigh the benefit for smugglers making it financially unfeasible for them to sell smuggled goods in BD.

You think BD is that uncivilised that it would shoot and kill smugglers?

We are not savages like Myanmar and India but a civilised country.

 

[Destranator]

You think BD is that uncivilised that it would shoot and kill smugglers?

We are not savages like Myanmar and India but a civilised country.

The smugglers are uncivilsed enough to not care about the damage they are doing to the country. The no-shooting policy has not worked for 47 years, it is not going to start working now. There is no feasible solution in BD other than shooting. Shooting eliminated many gangs during Operation Cleanheart. It will work here too.

 

[UKBengali]

The smugglers are uncivilsed enough to not care about the damage they are doing to the country. The no-shooting policy has not worked for 47 years, it is not going to start working now. There is no feasible solution in BD other than shooting. Shooting eliminated many gangs during Operation Cleanheart. It will work here too.

BD needs to find a non-lethal method to stop the smuggling. That i can fully support.

Most of the problems come from the fact that BSF is totally corrupt and takes bribes from the smugglers.

BD has a lawless sh*thole next door which is not helping.

 

[VikingRaider]

Do you really think there are no alternative, legal work opportunities available for smugglers in this day and age?

Nah bro, I don't think so. Indeed they are criminals and they should be punished! I only don't want them shoot to kill! They can be shoot at leg instead of head! After shooting at leg they will be forced to surrender. And they they can be easily arrested and then will be taken to custody and face the trial in court. And then court can give them punishment according to law!

And yes with rest of the part of your post I agree.

Start shooting and see how smuggling stops overnight.

Exactly! Then BGB should be doing so to for Indian fishermen too. If BGB also can do so ( shoot to kill) , as BSF is doing, I wont even have to complain about this. If BSF shoot onesided then I feel that India is just doing to show their power against us and we are just doing flag meeting! This is the major issue for me tbh!

If both side can be treated equally I will assume that they ( cow smugglers) are same level dangerous and harmful people like our drug dealers who were cross fired by our law enforcement!

BSF kills a smuggler not to protect India but when he fails to pay the promised bribes.

I also think so brother. If BSF of BGB find anyone who is smuggling women and children they should be shot dead instantly if they are not going to stop by shooting at leg.

But for the other case if they really need to stop, I think shooting at leg( if necessary) is enough. Then they can face trial. Mob justice by another country's border security raises many questions, since India always show it's dadagiri and Bangladesh do flag meetings in return!

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Do you have comprehension issues? The Bangladeshi smugglers getting shot get shot in Indian territory.
As I said, a criminal who crosses into foreign land is at their mercy.
As for prosecution: do you have any clue about border management? Get off your couch and go talk to your border guards.
It is impossible for BGB to abandon posts and chase down so many smugglers (often heavily armed).

Some of you have Indian chips on your shoulders which shut your brains down whenever you hear the word "India".
Believe whatever you want.

Go explain your couch theories on your beloved smugglers to the families of these BGB men. Maybe your hugs and kisses to smugglers would have prevented these incidents.

Benapole ‘gunfight’: Injured BGB man dies at CMH
https://www.thedailystar.net/country/news/benapole-gunfight-injured-bgb-man-dies-cmh-1778626

Smugglers injure BGB member
https://www.thedailystar.net/news/smugglers-injure-bgb-member

This whole argument smells like shutkhi.

Why do you want India or any foreign nation executing your criminals (without trial - but let's leave that technicality to one side for now and just think about the principle)?

Surely bd should have the maturity to deal with its own criminals if they are so clearly criminals as defined by you?

On topic, what odd language used by bd leaders. Summary killing by border guards of unarmed suspects is merely "shameful". It's a crime itself is what it is. Like when Hasina says certain discriminatory laws in India are "unnecessary".

 

[bluesky]

BD needs to find a non-lethal method to stop the smuggling. That i can fully support.

Most of the problems come from the fact that BSF is totally corrupt and takes bribes from the smugglers.

BD has a lawless sh*thole next door which is not helping.

It can be as @Atlas proposed. His premise is the way we treat the Indians when captured in our water. Our Coast Guard or BGB do not fire. They catch them and the govt returns them with warnings after flag meetings.

BSF drunkards can do the same. However, the question remains if BGB catches the BD smugglers and the govt sets them free who will then pay handsomely to the corrupt BGB bastards? BGB demands an exorbitant price for allowing smuggling. Sometimes, some BD smugglers cheat the BSF by not paying and as a result, they are shot dead.

Note one point, so far no one has been injured, all are killed. Why? Because BGB intentionally kills them as a punishment for not paying.

 

[UKBengali]

It can be as @Atlas proposed. His premise is the way we treat the Indians when captured in our water. Our Coast Guard or BGB do not fire. They catch them and the govt returns with warnings after flag meetings.

BSF drunkards can do the same. However, the question remains if BGB catches the BD smugglers and the govt sets them free who will then pay handsomely to the corrupt BGB bastards? BGB demands an exorbitant price for allowing smuggling. Sometimes, some BD smugglers cheat the BSF by not paying and as a result, they are shot dead.

Note one point, so far no one has been injured, all are killed. Why? Because BGB intentionally kills them as a punishment for not paying.

BSF are totally corrupt like the rest of the Indian military.

Good to see BGB upholding the ethical standards of the BD military.

BD will keep behaving in a civilised manner despite what India and Myanmar does.