Bismillah to be dropped from (Bangladesh) Constitution

[Spring Onion]

Back to topic. How many .....ullahs have been introduced in BD constitution post 1972? I am aware of inshallah, Bismillah, mashallah onlee.

they dont need to introduce its part of daily speaking and is not confined to 72 or 47 .

 

[BoseDK]

they dont need to introduce its part of daily speaking and is not confined to 72 or 47 .

I am talking about the stuff below. That means bismilla was not present in previous versions.

The parliamentary special committee on constitutional amendment has recommended restoring the preamble of the 1972 constitution, meaning that "Bismillah-Ar-Rahman-Ar-Rahim" will be dropped from the section, reports bdnews24.com.

You are an idiot, you don't have to prove that to anyone. Read some books first of all.

Astaghfirullah!! WHat kind of language are you indulging in birather?

 

[PlanetWarrior]

Today Bangladeshis are more Muslims then before. And there is nothing of betrayal . Neither there is anything to be jealous of.

if at all one should be jealous of its should be both bharatis and Pakistanis in terms of literacy rate which BD has much higher than yours and ours too.

Last but not the least: Learn to post like civilized human instead of BS slang

You truly should heed your own advice. And please stop referring to us as "Bhartis". You may refer to us as Bharitiyas since I notice that you do seem to choke on typing out the name India which is the official name of our country. I am certain that you find it offensive when you are reffered to as a "" so stop the cross border insults and post like a decent human being. It is rumoured that you profess to be a journo even though I find that difficult to believe.

As our country has a sizeable amount of Muslim and Christian citizens (not forgetting Sikh and Jain whom you often class as "Hindus" when it suits you), please stop referring to our country as a "Hindu nation" etc as you so often do. It is an insult to our Muslim , Christian and other minorities to be called "Hindus" as I am certain that it will be an insult for a Hindu to be called a Muslim or Christian etc. Despite the mods continously deleting your rubbish posts you seem to get some form of glee in continuing with your banter.

Finally, it really is of no concern to Indians whether Bangladesh drops Bismillah or any other term in their constitution. We are however entitled to discuss the topic in a forum where such discussion is welcome without having an idiotic hijacking troll bring in side or irrelevant issues such as the significance of a swastika etc. If Hinduism places you in such awe and inspires you to the extent that you have so evidently become obsessed with it, go find a Hindu pundit and convert yourself. Otherwise just STFU about it !

 

[TopCat]

To me personally, this effect on the constitution hold no value whatsoever. The only reason Awami League is even considering doing this is to instigate several divisions of the islamist parties. We have much more issues to worry about now.

No it will hold a lot of value. Interpretation of laws will be different under a secular constitution. I mean same law with different interpretation.

 

[TopCat]

I rather want Bismillah to be translated in Bengali and leave that as is so that it can be readable to all the religion in the country. There are atheist but dont know wht to say to them, may be they could just ignore the line. LOL

 

[integra]

-------------------------------------------------

 

[Spring Onion]

You truly should heed your own advice. And please stop referring to us as "Bhartis". You may refer to us as Bharitiyas since I notice that you do seem to choke on typing out the name India which is the official name of our country. I am certain that you find it offensive when you are reffered to as a "" so stop the cross border insults and post like a decent human being. It is rumoured that you profess to be a journo even though I find that difficult to believe.

off topic redundant crying. so never mind.

As our country has a sizeable amount of Muslim and Christian citizens (not forgetting Sikh and Jain whom you often class as "Hindus" when it suits you), please stop referring to our country as a "Hindu nation" etc as you so often do. It is an insult to our Muslim , Christian and other minorities to be called "Hindus" as I am certain that it will be an insult for a Hindu to be called a Muslim or Christian etc. Despite the mods continously deleting your rubbish posts you seem to get some form of glee in continuing with your banter.

point out in this thread where did i call entire India as Hindu nation. surely Muslims are different than Hindus.

Finally, it really is of no concern to Indians whether Bangladesh drops Bismillah or any other term in their constitution.

More than Bangladeshis its bharati members who had been posting BS on this internal matter of BD.

We are however entitled to discuss the topic in a forum where such discussion is welcome without having an idiotic hijacking troll bring in side or irrelevant issues such as the significance of a swastika etc. If Hinduism places you in such awe and inspires you to the extent that you have so evidently become obsessed with it, go find a Hindu pundit and convert yourself. Otherwise just STFU about it !

Whenever its a discussion on BD or any such topic bharatis come and hijack the thread by bringing in Pakistan unnecessarily

2. you should STFU instead of asking me to do.

3. i was asking AL for putting swastika not you. what is your issue with that in the first place? is swastika your property or what?

 

[desioptimist]

I rather want Bismillah to be translated in Bengali and leave that as is so that it can be readable to all the religion in the country. There are atheist but dont know wht to say to them, may be they could just ignore the line. LOL

Nobody is denying that bangladeshi is predominantly a muslim country. But the law should be secular, as it is in most democracies.
Nobody is suggesting that ministers suddenly stop being muslims.
As to atheists in bangladesh, I have read some articles from bangladeshi atheists, but dont remember where.
This one is in bengali, I cant read it.
Mukto-mona (???????? ) : A Secular site for Bengali humanists & freethinkers

 

[Spring Onion]

I rather want Bismillah to be translated in Bengali and leave that as is so that it can be readable to all the religion in the country. There are atheist but dont know wht to say to them, may be they could just ignore the line. LOL

yes that could be also done .

on the other hand its amusing that how removing it makes one secular specially when US constitution has many biblical phrases does it mean US is not a secular country ?

According to reports and study 34% of all political quotes in the US constitution came from the Bible.

 

[PlanetWarrior]

off topic redundant crying. so never mind.





point out in this thread where did i call entire India as Hindu nation. surely Muslims are different than Hindus.





More than Bangladeshis its bharati members who had been posting BS on this internal matter of BD.



Whenever its a discussion on BD or any such topic bharatis come and hijack the thread by bringing in Pakistan unnecessarily

2. you should STFU instead of asking me to do.

3. i was asking AL for putting swastika not you. what is your issue with that in the first place? is swastika your property or what?

Well if you P-A-K-I regard insulting us as "off topic and redundant" then there really is no point in entertaining your ignorance and lack of intelligence now is there. (It is a rhetorical question so don't bother replying) .

You commence your trolling and then take offence when responded to accordingly.

Yeah swastika is the property of the Dharmas as the Kabah is your property. Now let's not go into that here...as I mentioned earlier..if Hinduism inspires uyou to the extent that you have become obsessed with it, go find a guru.

Indians are allowed to post on this forum. If you have a problem with that then take it up with the mods. Until then stop embarassing yourself with the drivel which you post here (what could be worse than a fool disclosing her id on an internet forum and then making a joke of herself !)

And tell the moron applauding you to stop being a circus monkey

 

[desioptimist]

yes that could be also done .

on the other hand its amusing that how removing it makes one secular specially when US constitution has many biblical phrases does it mean US is not a secular country ?

According to reports and study 34% of all political quotes in the US constitution came from the Bible.

I dont think if a phrase is part of language, but used in cultural context, anybody will oppose it much. Many people use "crusade", "god", "jesus christ" as expressions.
I have seen british muslims using "jesus christ" , to show surprise, anger etc.

Can you give the link where american constitution mentions a specific religion or reference to it.

 

[Spring Onion]

Well if you P-A-K-I regard insulting us as "off topic and redundant" then there really is no point in entertaining your ignorance and lack of intelligence now is there. (It is a rhetorical question so don't bother replying) .

Bharati is not slur whereas PAK.I is slur as much as the word BHIN.DI thats why both are banned on this forum.

if you want to use the slur for us we can use the slur for you. Period

Yeah swastika is the property of the Dharmas as the Kabah is your property.

Your other native indian was saying swastika has nothing to with religion. so first you should come up with one uniformed information if its a religious symbol or not.

Now let's not go into that here...as I mentioned earlier..if Hinduism inspires uyou to the extent that you have become obsessed with it, go find a guru.

None of your business. Period

Indians are allowed to post on this forum. If you have a problem with that then take it up with the mods.

and when was the last time i have any issue with bharatis on this forum?

Until then stop embarassing yourself with the drivel which you post here (what could be worse than a fool disclosing her id on an internet forum and then making a joke of herself !)

lolzz so you are threatening me . you are free to come up with worst threat to me i really damn care

And tell the moron applauding you to stop being a circus monkey

if you can not post anything substantial then keep your abusive language to yourself.

BTW if i called it a monkey circus you would have felt offended religiously so stop such BS

 

[AZADPAKISTAN2009]

A nation with 99% muslims and 1% minority the name should stay and they should also add , Mohammad was the last messenger of god in there too

Well I do not see any issue with the slur as stated in earlier post , Pak means pure ... means one who is pure
sure in england that might be a slur but form linguistic point of view means one who is pure.

But is a dish and I love that is the problem so even that is a bad slur

 

[Al-zakir]

I rather want Bismillah to be translated in Bengali and leave that as is so that it can be readable to all the religion in the country. There are atheist but dont know wht to say to them, may be they could just ignore the line. LOL

The Arabic name "Abdul Rehman" mean "Doyal Das" in Bangla so why don't Muslim name their kids as "doyal das" instead of "Abdul Rehman"?

Something must be preserve but Banglai minded Bangali like you won't understand where to draw a line. It's not wise to hurt the sentiment of overwhelm majority Muslim to please negligible Hindu community. Their contribution is nothing whether we are talking about creation of Pakistan or Bangladesh.

 

[TopCat]

yes that could be also done .

on the other hand its amusing that how removing it makes one secular specially when US constitution has many biblical phrases does it mean US is not a secular country ?

According to reports and study 34% of all political quotes in the US constitution came from the Bible.

Every religious symbol in US state machineries still bears a lot of controversy and there are numerous rules from supreme court against them.