What's new

American Corporations Moved 1.5 Million Jobs to India and China

RiazHaq

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Oct 31, 2009
Messages
6,611
Reaction score
70
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
American corporations created 453,000 jobs in India, a whopping 642% increase in a decade that saw the same corporations cut 846,000 jobs at home.

Overall, US multinational corporations added 1.5 million workers to their payrolls in Asia and the Pacific region from 1999 to 2009, and 477,500 workers in Latin America, according to US Commerce Dept data as reported by the Wall Street Journal.

From 1999 to 2009, the multinational companies also reduced capital-investment spending in the U.S. at an annual rate of 0.2% and increased it at a 4.0% annual rate abroad. This occurred in spite of huge Bush era tax cuts for the rich.

Bulk of the increase in overseas investment and hiring by U.S. multinationals has been in the service sector where most of the American middle class jobs have been lost. Among U.S. multinational firms in manufacturing, about 60% of employment is still in the U.S. But the manufacturers cut their U.S. payrolls by 2.1 million in the 2000s and added 230,000 workers overseas.

While the U.S. multinational manufacturers employ 6.9 million workers in the U.S. and 4.6 million abroad as of 2009, the trend clearly indicates the balance shifting in favor of overseas jobs at the expense of jobs in America.

The irony of it is that the vast majority of average citizens of nations like India where jobs have been created by American corporations have not benefited either. After the decade of job creation by US multi-nationals, India still remains home to the world's largest population of poor, hungry and illiterates. Bulk of the benefits of globalization have gone to a few dozen powerful Indian oligarchs in "the world's largest democracy".

Looking at this jobs data, it's clear to me that the foolish and short-sighted actions of the American MNCs are undermining the very system that has nurtured and enriched them by creating middle class American consumers and voters whose jobs they are killing.

It's the middle class America that has supported the system of American democracy and free markets; destroying middle class America by taking their jobs overseas will only lead to rising instability that will threaten the very foundations of this system....the growing "Occupy" movement across major American cities and university campuses is only the tip of the iceberg of rising discontent.

It's time to save democracy and capitalism from the American capitalists!

http://www.riazhaq.com/2011/11/us-firms-add-jobs-in-india-china-cut-at.html
 
.
The Hindu : Business News : Indian firms saved 2,500 U.S. jobs: CII survey

India-based companies with United States operations actually saved, through their acquisition of U.S. firms, 2,585 jobs from being eliminated during the global economic downturn, a new survey by the Confederation of Indian Industry (CII) has found. Further, the survey suggested that 35 top Indian companies in the U.S. employ over 60,000 people across 40 states and over 80 per cent of these are local hires.

The survey’s results show progress made even since U.S. President Barack Obama’s November 2010 visit to India, which saw the inking of trade and commercial deals exceeding $14.9 billion in value with $9.5 billion in U.S. exports leading to the creation of an estimated 53,670 U.S. jobs.

Nice try:rofl:
 
. .
Looking at this jobs data, it's clear to me that the foolish and short-sighted actions of the American MNCs are undermining the very system that has nurtured and enriched them by creating middle class American consumers and voters whose jobs they are killing.

Multinationals have no loyalties. If the American middle class shrinks, they will simply find consumers elsewhere.
 
.
Multinationals have no loyalties. If the American middle class shrinks, they will simply find consumers elsewhere.

That's true, although the pace of such change and the preferences of consumers in other nations are questionable. And if the process shakes up the foundations of the US system the rest of the world is copying, then there could be yet another global financial crisis spelling doom for US style capitalism and democracy.

Haq's Musings: Will American Capitalism Survive?
 
.
The irony of it is that the vast majority of average citizens of nations like India where jobs have been created by American corporations have not benefited either. After the decade of job creation by US multi-nationals, India still remains home to the world's largest population of poor, hungry and illiterates. Bulk of the benefits of globalization have gone to a few dozen powerful Indian oligarchs in "the world's largest democracy".

Haq's Musings: US Firms Add Jobs in India & China, Cut at Home

What this has to do with Job Creation in India?

---------- Post added at 11:41 PM ---------- Previous post was at 11:39 PM ----------

Multinationals have no loyalties. If the American middle class shrinks, they will simply find consumers elsewhere.

If they don't find consumers, then the Multi nationals in question would cease to exist
 
.
Let me get this straight.American democracy and capitalism essentially implies that American firms should be given a free hand at selling their overpriced garbage in Asia but to create jobs in the region amounts to corporate blasphemy?Right on old man,lay off the Prozac!!!
 
.
That's true, although the pace of such change and the preferences of consumers in other nations are questionable. And if the process shakes up the foundations of the US system the rest of the world is copying, then there could be yet another global financial crisis spelling doom for US style capitalism and democracy.

Haq's Musings: Will American Capitalism Survive?

Adaptability is a requirement for successful businesses anyway. Successful, adaptable, MNCs will survive sans borders. One could cynically argue that this is their long term plan anyway: exchange 200 million rich American consumers for 2.5 billion middle income consumers.
 
. .
Adaptability is a requirement for successful businesses anyway. Successful, adaptable, MNCs will survive sans borders. One could cynically argue that this is their long term plan anyway: exchange 200 million rich American consumers for 2.5 billion middle income consumers.

Adaptability only works as long as there is a stable global financial system to underpin it. The job losses in the US leading to the destruction of the US middle class will likely upend it and unleash a new wave of instability around the world.
 
.
American corporations created 453,000 jobs in India, a whopping 642% increase in a decade that saw the same corporations cut 846,000 jobs at home.

Overall, US multinational corporations added 1.5 million workers to their payrolls in Asia and the Pacific region from 1999 to 2009, and 477,500 workers in Latin America, according to US Commerce Dept data as reported by the Wall Street Journal.

From 1999 to 2009, the multinational companies also reduced capital-investment spending in the U.S. at an annual rate of 0.2% and increased it at a 4.0% annual rate abroad. This occurred in spite of huge Bush era tax cuts for the rich.

Bulk of the increase in overseas investment and hiring by U.S. multinationals has been in the service sector where most of the American middle class jobs have been lost. Among U.S. multinational firms in manufacturing, about 60% of employment is still in the U.S. But the manufacturers cut their U.S. payrolls by 2.1 million in the 2000s and added 230,000 workers overseas.

While the U.S. multinational manufacturers employ 6.9 million workers in the U.S. and 4.6 million abroad as of 2009, the trend clearly indicates the balance shifting in favor of overseas jobs at the expense of jobs in America.

The irony of it is that the vast majority of average citizens of nations like India where jobs have been created by American corporations have not benefited either. After the decade of job creation by US multi-nationals, India still remains home to the world's largest population of poor, hungry and illiterates. Bulk of the benefits of globalization have gone to a few dozen powerful Indian oligarchs in "the world's largest democracy".

Looking at this jobs data, it's clear to me that the foolish and short-sighted actions of the American MNCs are undermining the very system that has nurtured and enriched them by creating middle class American consumers and voters whose jobs they are killing.

It's the middle class America that has supported the system of American democracy and free markets; destroying middle class America by taking their jobs overseas will only lead to rising instability that will threaten the very foundations of this system....the growing "Occupy" movement across major American cities and university campuses is only the tip of the iceberg of rising discontent.

It's time to save democracy and capitalism from the American capitalists!

Haq's Musings: US Firms Add Jobs in India & China, Cut at Home


Hey buddy, that is what Laissez-faire is all about, no? Free trade, non interference, total absence of governmental control, profit making being the only deciding factor. Ayn Rand would be ecstatic. The Wall Street loves Laissez-faire and it is the Wall Street and corporate America that decides government policy in the US, so why do they complain now?
 
.
Hey buddy, that is what Laissez-faire is all about, no? Free trade, non interference, total absence of governmental control, profit making being the only deciding factor. Ayn Rand would be ecstatic. The Wall Street loves Laissez-faire and it is the Wall Street and corporate America that decides government policy in the US, so why do they complain now?

It's not Adam Smith's Laissez-faire that built America into a highly prosperous and the strongest nation in the world. It was the result of Keynesian economics as implemented by FDR's New Deal and LBJ's Great Society programs.

Haq's Musings: Will American Capitalism Survive?
 
.
It's not Adam Smith's Laissez-faire that built America into a highly prosperous and the strongest nation in the world. It was the result of Keynesian economics as implemented by FDR's New Deal and LBJ's Great Society programs.

Haq's Musings: Will American Capitalism Survive?

Buddy, that was the post war era when the US capitalised on severe shortages and deficiencies rampant in Europe and Asia which the US as one of the principle victors of the WW, had a large hand in creating. US industry went into top gear to meet these deficiencies and the money flowing in made the US corporations rich and America great. A part of this money was channeled back into the devastated Europe (Marshall Plan) and Japan to aid in the recovery so that they could buy more US products and make Americans richer. Whether you like it or not, for the US, it has been Laissez-faire all the way. If the government has ever intervened, it did so on behalf of the corporations. It is Laissez-faire that exports US jobs to Mexico, China, India, Philippines etc. Adam Smith or John Keynes, the American middle class has never made US policy. I am not saying it is a bad thing, it is just the way they do things. It works for them.
 
.
This shift of capital and some jobs from the USA to places such as India, China, Taiwan and Vietnam is a necessary consequence of free trade. It contributes a great deal to the improvement of the standard of living of those Asian nations. It also means that the displaced workers in the USA will either come up with goods and services to offer at a lower price for quality, or see their own standard of living decline. Alternatively, the USA could embark on new forms of protectionism, as is desired by USA labor unions and the "occupy Wall Street" movement. This would take the form of "worker rights" rules, environmental rules and, especially, "global warming" imposed constraints. Asian nations need to develop a more internal, consumer oriented model for economic growth, rather than relying so heavily on mercantilism and exports to the USA and Europe if they want to insulate themselves from the coming political and trade barrier pressures arising from the displaced American and European middle class workers. And, Asian economies need to resist the global warming alarmists.
 
.
Adaptability only works as long as there is a stable global financial system to underpin it. The job losses in the US leading to the destruction of the US middle class will likely upend it and unleash a new wave of instability around the world.

Even if the worst case scenario happens, it won't last for 1000 years. Eventually, there will be a new world order and the MNCs will have positioned themselves favorably by distributing their assets and risks.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom