What's new

Am I Pak Army Chief? Gen Singh on age row

Zarvan

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Apr 28, 2011
Messages
54,470
Reaction score
87
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
New Delhi: The age row involving Army Chief General VK Singh appears to be growing and taking a dramatic turn.

If reports are to be believed, General Singh has told the Defence Secretary, according to highly-placed sources, that he believes he is being treated in a manner as if he was the Army Chief of Pakistan.

The Army Chief said this to the Defence Secretary Shashi Kant Sharma, sources said, over a week before Defence Minister AK Antony last month turned down his statutory complaint on his date of birth controversy.



As per a report in a leading daily, Sharma had met General Singh on December 21 last year and wanted to know from him what his future plans are on the age row.

According to sources, the Army Chief told the Defence Secretary that he was fighting for the issue for honour and not for an extra year in office

Army records differently mention General Singh’s birth dates as May 10, 1950 and 1951. If the Defence Ministry accepts May 10, 1951 as his date of birth as contended by the Army Chief, he would then be entitled to an extra year in office before he retires.

The government is worried that General Singh may move court over the issue, even though he has been advised by many, including Finance Minister Pranab Mukherjee, against doing so.

The government is believed to be working hard to ensure the matter is settled out of court in order to avoid a division in the Army.

The Congress has already expressed concern over reports that the Army Chief may seek legal redressal on the age row.

"Armed forces are an institution, which are held high in esteem not only by the political establishment but by various sections of society.

"What is happening is definitely a matter of concern. But I would not like to go into it. Those who are charged with the responsibility or are dealing with the issue should arrive at some kind of appropriate solution," party spokesperson Manish Tewari said.

The Army Chief has also got support from former Punjab chief minister and current Congress state chief, Captain Amarinder Singh.

Singh has written a letter Antony, dated December 17, saying the controversy was affecting the Army’s morale. “We have over eight lakh ex-servicemen in Punjab, where this issue remains an active topic, as it is, I am sure, amongst ex-servicemen in other states as well. Needless to say, General VK Singh continues to get support of the vast majority,” Singh said in the letter.
 
. .
LOLs, I remember an incident about Pakistan navy, that my father told me about. Once a junior naval officer enquired about the age of a very senior officer who replied, "Son, I was wearing uniform when you were still in liquid form".
 
.
LOLs, I remember an incident about Pakistan navy, that my father told me about. Once a junior naval officer enquired about the age of a very senior officer who replied, "Son, I was wearing uniform when you were still in liquid form".

Nearly every Sailor has gone through life, with that line. First hearing it and then saying it. So did we. :)
 
.
LOLs, I remember an incident about Pakistan navy, that my father told me about. Once a junior naval officer enquired about the age of a very senior officer who replied, "Son, I was wearing uniform when you were still in liquid form".

The same was said about Hina Rabbani Khar & SM Krishna that he was a politician long before even the parents of Ms. Khar met eachother.:P
 
. .
lol.....jyada kush na ho
batoh batoh mein usne tumhare army chief ki insult kar dali:lol:

batoon batoon may usnay tumharay hesaab say insult ke hey hamaray walay isko fakhar samjtay hain kay sadi koi toooor way... lalu panjoo nahi waan asi lolzzzzz
 
.
lol.....jyada kush na ho
batoh batoh mein usne tumhare army chief ki insult kar dali:lol:

Chalo iski b sun lo ... :lol:

Us ne kaha hai bhai mjhay to ap aisay treat kr rahay ho jaisay mein enemy (Pakistan) ka general hun...meaning that is he frustrated about the way he is being treated by India :agree:

is may hmaray general ki bisti kaisay ho gayi? :devil:
 
.
Chalo iski b sun lo ... :lol:

Us ne kaha hai bhai mjhay to ap aisay treat kr rahay ho jaisay mein enemy (Pakistan) ka general hun...meaning that is he frustrated about the way he is being treated by India :agree:

is may hmaray general ki bisti kaisay ho gayi? :devil:

BHISTI AISI HO GAYI..........KI SINGH KO TRUST NAHI KIYA JA RAHA HAI,,,,,AUR WO KAH RAHA HAI KI MUJHE PAK CHIEF KI TARAH TREAT MAT KARO..................now tell me kid who was insulted "THE SINGH" OR "THA KAYANI"??????????????:lol:
 
.
The govt is being an idiot.. One of the 17 places in the records has his DoB as 1950 against the actual date of 1951 and they are doing all this tamasha instead of fixing the clerical error.. Morons..
 
.
Every country has its own kind of government system, Mr. Singh should learn how to live in strangest secular government. It means forget about status of COAS in Pakistan.
 
.
The govt is being an idiot.. One of the 17 places in the records has his DoB as 1950 against the actual date of 1951 and they are doing all this tamasha instead of fixing the clerical error.. Morons..

Difficult case. The AG's view is not something any government can ignore. It also affects the line of succession if Gen. V.K. Singh gets another year in office. Clerical error is not the problem (it was mentioned wrongly in V.K. Singh's application itself), the duration of time that it remained uncorrected is.
 
.
If reports are to be believed, General Singh has told the Defence Secretary, according to highly-placed sources, that he believes he is being treated in a manner as if he was the Army Chief of Pakistan.

So the whole thread is based on "My Chaccha in MoD said so".

Care mention your highly placed source.
 
.
Every country has its own kind of government system, Mr. Singh should learn how to live in strangest secular government. It means forget about status of COAS in Pakistan.

Who said he wanted the status of your Army Chief? AUz has got it nearly right in post #8. Only 'for India' 'read the present dispensation' There is no need to say any more on this. The Chief will do what he has to do to get justice.
 
.
Every country has its own kind of government system, Mr. Singh should learn how to live in strangest secular government. It means forget about status of COAS in Pakistan.

I dont think he is referring to the Pakistani COAS as a flattering status.. more like an abuse if i read it right..

---------- Post added at 01:05 PM ---------- Previous post was at 01:04 PM ----------

Difficult case. The AG's view is not something any government can ignore. It also affects the line of succession if Gen. V.K. Singh gets another year in office. Clerical error is not the problem (it was mentioned wrongly in V.K. Singh's application itself), the duration of time that it remained uncorrected is.

The onus of the error is on the govt/defense ministry and not the general really..
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom