After Ladkah, possible Intrusion of Chinese troops in Arunachal Pradesh : Indian media

[Mamluk]

Entire article is based on Tapir Gaos claims.
Army has already busted his false claims on China incursion last year:
https://www.indiatoday.in/india/sto...ops-arunachal-pradesh-army-1595528-2019-09-04

Plus the road and helipad whose pic he has posted has been geo loacted and can be seen to exist in exact same shape and size in Google Earth sat pics from 2008 which means they are 12+ yrs old

 

[Naofumi]

Find out how the designation of the Dalai Lama first came about. Find out who the Panchen Lama was.

They came after the Yuan's fall, Yuan's captured Tibet in 1240 and first Lama appeared in 1415 and Lama didn't became a central figure until

Find out what the Bureau did, in reality, not through surmise based on (Ye Gods!) a Wikipedia description.

I did tried to find out better sources but I didn't get better ones. Wiki presumably cites Wylie, Turnell V. (1977) "The First Mongol Conquest of Tibet Reinterpreted," Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies of which I didn't get direct access to see the actual quote though.

check what the Dzungarian Empire was, where it was, what happened to it, and who live in that region now;

They were of the Ming and some of the Qing timeline, didn't they? I didn't argued much on post-Dzungar above too..

Qing period Tibet seems to be much more autonomous though.

check how one religion got substituted by another through Imperial design, and read about how the dynasty in question conducted a systematic genocide that makes Hitler's excesses look like a children's tea party.

It's a little deeper than you might imagine, and that the Chinese would like you to think.

Joe, I think there has been a misunderstanding here; I was arguing for post-Mongol conquest era - circa late 1200s to the rise if Mings (and establishment of Western Mongols - Oirat Dzungars)..
On topic, I had read about Dzungar genocide in the past though it has little to do with the control of Tibet...

 

[Joe Shearer]

They came after the Yuan's fall, Yuan's captured Tibet in 1240 and first Lama appeared in 1415 and Lama didn't became a central figure until

The Yuan didn't capture Tibet, they extracted tribute. The rule in Tibet was that of secular kings until the Dzungarians.

I did tried to find out better sources but I didn't get better ones. Wiki presumably cites Wylie, Turnell V. (1977) "The First Mongol Conquest of Tibet Reinterpreted," Harvard Journal of Asiatic Studies of which I didn't get direct access to see the actual quote though.

Difficult to get good sources in India, dead easy abroad.

They were of the Ming and some of the Qing timeline, didn't they? I didn't argued much on post-Dzungar above too..

My original check list suggested to you carries the seeds of the position on Tibet I would like to see adopted.

Joe, I think there has been a misunderstanding here; I was arguing for post-Mongol conquest era - circa late 1200s to the rise if Mings (and establishment of Western Mongols - Oirat Dzungars)..
On topic, I had read about Dzungar genocide in the past though it has little to do with the control of Tibet...

We can discuss this on a later thread you should open, but not until I've given PanzerKiel a full narrative for all conflicts. I will be happy to explain at that time, in that place.

 

[FOOLS_NIGHTMARE]

Chinese PLA patrolling in Arunachal, time for action on the border: BJP MP Tapir Gao
New Delhi: BJP MP from Arunachal East, Tapir Gao, has claimed that China’s People’s Liberation Army (PLA) has been regularly patrolling inside Arunachal Pradesh, posing a great threat to India.

Gao said it is time for action on the border for the integrity and security of the country. “The Chinese are still active along the international border and the government of India should be ready for any kind of eventualities not only in Arunachal Pradesh but even in Sikkim, Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand,” Gao told ThePrint Wednesday.
Gao also expressed concern over Monday’s Galwan Valley incident, which resulted in at least 20 deaths on the Indian side, including the commanding officer of the 16 Bihar unit.


The MP said he had been raising the issue of PLA patrols in Arunachal Pradesh in Parliament too. “They have been patrolling inside Arunachal Pradesh daily. Last year, the Chinese army had intruded into Arunachal Pradesh’s Anjaw district too. This is a cause of concern for the security of the country,” he added.
China’s claim on Arunachal
China has claimed Arunachal Pradesh as part of its territory for decades, refusing to recognise what New Delhi has repeated asserted is an “integral and inalienable part” of India.


The BJP MP said after 1962, China had indulged in its “expansion policy”, and had established infrastructure and roads by occupying many areas.

“In 2017, China constructed a road inside the Indian territory in the Upper Siang district. It was later blocked by the Indian Army. Over a period of time since 1962, China has been following its policy of expanding its territory and has occupied a number of areas and even today they continue to patrol in several others,” Gao claimed.


In September last year too, Gao had raised issues related to Chinese intrusions, claiming that the PLA entered Arunachal Pradesh’s remote Anjaw district and constructed a bridge over a stream.
https://theprint.in/defence/chinese...action-on-the-border-bjp-mp-tapir-gao/443248/

 

[rott]

Haha they thought our army was in the Western sector and moved all their troops there. Actually, our main thrust is in the Eastern sector and chicken's neck!

Don't they have satellites in this age?

Stay on the topic or get ready for a kick.

We want to give Indians a space to give their opinions.. Their own forums are full of abuse etc that's why they become members of PDF.. We want to give them chances until they just carryon their bharatrakshak mentality here too.. So let me give him warnings first..

Not all the Indian members are on PDF are bad though.

PDF is the best. I've been to Bharatrakshak before. Full of delusional and abuses in that forum. I left after the first day.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1273755453776891907

 

[Feng Leng]

https://www.business-standard.com/a...ty-near-arunachal-pradesh-120063000061_1.html

The two sectors that are seeing the most PLA activity are Tawang and Walong - both of which bore the brunt of the Chinese offensive in 1962.

In the Eastern sector, PLA will not advance just a few kilometers. We will advance all the way to Assam.

 

[kankan326]

Good move. China was always in disadvantaged position in the last standoffs because it was alway India who picked the right place for it to provoke China.

 

[Type59]

Strench thinnly indian troops

 

[Pakistani Fighter]

Any update about today's Talks?

 

[I S I]

Any update about today's Talks?

Surrender modi: what talks?

 

[Ali_Baba]

Modi was meant to do a new conference today, i guess with a followup on the LAC issue. If Modis offer to China was not good enough in the talks, then there wasn't much to say to anyone else...

 

[SuperStar20]

Damn, everyday 10 threads boosting about same kungflu shit. Getting boring.

 

[Dalit]

When will Pakistan do the same? Put the rapists under pressure.

 

[Ahmet Pasha]

NorthEastern communist states belong to China anyway.
They look like Chinese. Speak like Chinese.

See @beijingwalker I'm not always against you guys.

But when you talk like a broken CCP propoganda record all the time. That kinda gets on my nerves.

Cheers.

https://www.business-standard.com/a...ty-near-arunachal-pradesh-120063000061_1.html

The two sectors that are seeing the most PLA activity are Tawang and Walong - both of which bore the brunt of the Chinese offensive in 1962.

In the Eastern sector, PLA will not advance just a few kilometers. We will advance all the way to Assam.

 

[rott]

NorthEastern communist states belong to China anyway.
They look like Chinese. Speak like Chinese.

Which northeastern communist states? Do you mean North East India? If so, they don't speak the same language. They don't eat the same food. They are mostly more related to Burma, Bhutan, etc.
They eat food with their hands and don't use chopsticks.

But when you talk like a broken CCP propoganda record all the time.

LOL, he does that sometimes, even I joke around with him.