What's new

A Natural Example of how to win a Battle against bigger Enemy.

at the time of French invasion, their tanks were inferior compared to allies.

Yep.

Their Generals were afraid of an attack in the flank, the Allies were so stunned by the speed of the attack that only a half hearted push was made, and that too was brushed aside by the Germans. A determined attack by the British would have halted their advance, split their forces and they would have lost.

Yes good post.
 
.
Please watch this video about how to defense against bigger enemy through aggressive Surprise.
A big lesson for us in current situation.
if only mebtis has twitter he would be fighting the war fiercely on twitter. @mentisforpeace yeh display your bravely mentis wars are won and post on internet while your sisters are being raped!
 
.
Spot on and this is a fact of history. It was literally superior tactics that won the day. In open battle they would have had it.
They won due to superior tactics but they lost due to their utter arrogance towards non-Nazis.. like disregarding the nature and opening the front with USSR.
 
Last edited:
.
.
If Pakistan ever hopes to achieve victory against that scum which is hindustan. Then most Pakistanis need a reality check .... Can you all stop yourselves from watch nasty, vile, filthy bollywood, indian cable-tv and dancing/listening to indian music? Can you? Really, seriously, Can you??

A society or nation is built on a specific set of values and rules. What values and rules does Pakistan really have? When most of us shamelessly lap-up indian music, movies and tv serials like a bunch of pigs. Disgraceful and utterly disgusting display of JAHILIYYAT is what our countrymen do every day.

And then we have the audacity to call for war against india on Kashmir?

Tell me where was your damn Kashmiriyyat when dancing like a bunch of depraved jackasses to indian music on your weddings? Where is your Kashmiriyyat go to the movie theaters and watch indian movies like a bunch of prostitutes? Where has your Kashmiriyyat been all this time, while going to concerts of indian musicians or flocking at the airports to see indian celebrities?

Y'all want to fight a war to liberate Kashmir ....then first liberate your Imaan, you ungrateful and pathetic excuses for Muslims.

Kashmir Baneyga Pakistan, Jab Pakistan Baneyga Musalmaan.
 
. .
Yes, unfortunately, the minds and basic common sense of some Pakistanis may be clouded by obvious propaganda.

Fortunately, it's largely limited to a specific defeatist type, and they are best ignored. In fact, if anything, it might even help as a form of reverse projection.
 
. .
If Pakistan ever hopes to achieve victory against that scum which is hindustan. Then most Pakistanis need a reality check .... Can you all stop yourselves from watch nasty, vile, filthy bollywood, indian cable-tv and dancing/listening to indian music? Can you? Really, seriously, Can you??

A society or nation is built on a specific set of values and rules. What values and rules does Pakistan really have? When most of us shamelessly lap-up indian music, movies and tv serials like a bunch of pigs. Disgraceful and utterly disgusting display of JAHILIYYAT is what our countrymen do every day.

And then we have the audacity to call for war against india on Kashmir?

Tell me where was your damn Kashmiriyyat when dancing like a bunch of depraved jackasses to indian music on your weddings? Where is your Kashmiriyyat go to the movie theaters and watch indian movies like a bunch of prostitutes? Where has your Kashmiriyyat been all this time, while going to concerts of indian musicians or flocking at the airports to see indian celebrities?

Y'all want to fight a war to liberate Kashmir ....then first liberate your Imaan, you ungrateful and pathetic excuses for Muslims.

Kashmir Baneyga Pakistan, Jab Pakistan Baneyga Musalmaan.
Bro here is one who never watched a single complete Indian movie...though rarely listened to songs from Rafiq and a few others but never fell for the cheap crap they produce.
 
.
@Signalian remember our conversation about light tanks and use of mass produced armor... this is an example of how our tactics could be better than what we have at present.
 
.
I don't think the Germans were technologically inferior, if anything their weapons tended to be better. Take Tiger tanks, Me-103 jets, King Tiger, Panther etc. However the Germans excelled in -

  • training
  • organization
  • command/control
  • strategy
  • fighting spirit
Pakistan has non of these advantages over India in sufficient degree to offset India's vastly disparity of 1:7 against us. And note despite everything the Germans still lost because Allies simpled out-numbered them. More men, more tanks, more aircraft overwhelmed the fantastic German fighting machine which finally lost everything after 5 years.

Afghans won by bloody guerilla warfare. Most Pakistani's don't have it in them to fight like that. It entails giving the enemy the country and then slicing them with death of 1,000 cuts over years. But on the negative side is losing millions of your people and being bombed to stone age.
In the westfeldzug , they were
Their majority tank comprised of the panzer 1 and 2, to be put in blunt words , absolutely jokingly crap compared to French mainstay tanks like the S types , or the Char series ,
Even when it comes to motorization , the Germans even when against Russia used majority horses , against France it was even worse ,
The kriegsmarine was hopelessly outclassed ,
The French has more artillery and even a better rifle ( MAS 36) , not to mention were the defenders,
Yet tactics , will , and a hell of a lot of luck allowed the Germans to win ,
The only thing on par or slightly better than the allies combined was the Luftwaffe, Even that had limitations
 
.
Bro i've not only seen documentaries about this but also heard from professors of military history that the Germans at the start of the war did not have a technological advantage. Did you know the many of their mobile units lacked heavy armour v the opposition, they also had to use horses for the most part to move infantry around.
The Germans developed in sophistication later in the war due to the need for it.
sir the blitzkrieg was impossible without panzers and shtukas etc as a combined strategy they were fare superior yes individual elements are subject to debate.

I don't think the Germans were technologically inferior, if anything their weapons tended to be better. Take Tiger tanks, Me-103 jets, King Tiger, Panther etc. However the Germans excelled in -

  • training
  • organization
  • command/control
  • strategy
  • fighting spirit
Pakistan has non of these advantages over India in sufficient degree to offset India's vastly disparity of 1:7 against us. And note despite everything the Germans still lost because Allies simpled out-numbered them. More men, more tanks, more aircraft overwhelmed the fantastic German fighting machine which finally lost everything after 5 years.

Afghans won by bloody guerilla warfare. Most Pakistani's don't have it in them to fight like that. It entails giving the enemy the country and then slicing them with death of 1,000 cuts over years. But on the negative side is losing millions of your people and being bombed to stone age.
attrition tells in the end sir
 
.
Why are you even on internet, it is so dangerous..


Or the Afghans beating USSR and then USA :)
And, the British....

In the present context a good example may be the Third Battle of Panipat b/w the Muslims and the Hindus!!! Although the Hindu Army was overwhelmingly larger in men, wealth, armaments (French), training (by the French), logistics etc. they got shredded into pieces by the fast charging Muslim Army fighting with a motivation of "for the Din"!!! They knew it too well the Hindu victory would have signaled the end of the Muslim existence in the sub-continent...
 
. .
Bro i've not only seen documentaries about this but also heard from professors of military history
Yes, I am aware of that. At the onset of the war typical German mechanized unit would have less tanks, less SPGs, APCs etc then allied units. In fact total at the dawn of Blitzkreig Alies had more tanks etc. As time went on German armour went up in quality but not in numbers. Typical German Panzer unit might only have 30 tanks at any given point. In fact in WW2 the chance of a allied soldier finding a Tiger tank was probably about same as finding a toilet in India. Very slim chance.

However as I enumerated earlier, the Germans fought the allies with blood and guts. Under ein Volk, ein Reich, ein Führer or One race, one realm, one leader Germany fought with united 80 million people. German cultural traits like discipline, hard work, physical prowess, competition sports and education came together to create a formidable force. In addition the ability to taking punishing losses and still keep fighting. Unfortunately Pakistan as a country has non of those qualities. We as people are lazy, slack, avoid competition sport and prefer indulging on boriani and then farting while holding a bloated stomach. The only thing we have is bombastic talk, some crazy delusions about a ummah and how 1,300 'we' defeated the might of Rome.

By the way have you see even today? German ability at sports, football, olympics, tennis etc Then you know about their hard work and discipline ethos that still is part of their culture. We have to be honest about these things. You think if Germans were in place of Pakistan Kashmir would still be in Indian hands?

And you are correct about Whermacht's dependance on horse transport for logistics. First because of he post WW1 restrictions had not given enough space for Germany to build up a full army and secondly as war progressed they began running out of fuel. so limited fuel they got from Romanian oilfields would go on priorty like aircraft etc.

Although an unpopular subject, Israel is a much better real life example of a smaller enemy defeating a larger enemy.
No it is NOT. Israel is small piece of Europe or America transplanted in Western Asia. They enjoy technical, manpower quality superiority against their enemies and are connected via a follopian tube to USA which supports them with latest military technology. Those F-22 Raptors will be in hands of IAF before even all US squadrons recieve them.Israel is first world versus third world.

Tell me where was your damn Kashmiriyyat when dancing like a bunch of depraved jackasses to indian music on your weddings? Where is your Kashmiriyyat go to the movie theaters and watch indian movies like a bunch of prostitutes? Where has your Kashmiriyyat been all this time, while going to concerts of indian musicians or flocking at the airports to see indian celebrities?
Hurah, Hurrah for you !
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom