3 Indian soldiers killed as Pakistan retaliates

[AnnoyingOrange]

Nothing compared to what RTI revealed after covering up for some 15 years.
No questions asked, no explanation given.

How can the Reply to RTI be withheld for 15 years when the RTI Law itself is 10 years old... LOL... Pakistani logic.

 

[Windjammer]

Well at least there is something called RTI in India.. .. I heard even your parliament were told that we can't share the data.... I am not a causality fan like you... I feel these deaths are unnecessary and happy that we have an army which listen to what my elected govt says it asks.. ...

But you haven't heard something called DSC....which was the actual establishment that revealed the case of almost written off Ereye AWACS to the Parliament, the highlighted incident which has become the punchline for every Indian actually involved the energy minister who was just standing in for the defense minister and found it convenient to cover his own shortcomings...BTW, wasn't it the IA which awarded a posthumous medal to a soldier who walked out of a hospital a few days later.

 

[Laozi]

www.tribuneindia.com/news/jammu-kashmir/3-army-jawans-injured-as-pakistan-shells-loc-areas-in-poonch/477230.html

3 Army jawans injured as Pakistan shells LoC areas in Poonch
Jammu Kashmir
Posted at: Oct 4, 2017, 10:54 AM; last updated: Oct 4, 2017, 3:23 PM (IST)

The Indian Army is retaliating effectively and the firing is still on. ANI
Jammu, October 4

Three Army jawans were on Wednesday injured as Pakistani troops fired from automatic weapons and shelled mortars at forward posts and villages along the LoC in Jammu and Kashmir’s Poonch district.Pakistani troops also violated the ceasefire in Laam sector by briefly opening fire along the LoC, police officials said.The Indian Army is retaliating effectively and the firing is still on, a Defence Spokesman said.
(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)

“Pakistan Army initiated unprovoked and indiscriminate firing of small arms, automatics and mortars from 0845 hours in Poonch sector along the Line of Control (LoC),” the spokesman said.In the firing along the LoC in Poonch sector, three Army jawans suffered injuries, police officials said.On Tuesday, an Army jawan was killed when Pakistan Army violated the ceasefire along the LoC in Poonch.On October 2, two minors were killed and 12 civilians injured in cross-border shelling by Pakistan along the LoC in Poonch district.Five children were among the injured, the youngest being five-year-old Zobia Kousar. PTI

 

[nair]

But you haven't heard something called DSC....which was the actual establishment that revealed the case of almost written off Ereye AWACS to the Parliament, the highlighted incident which has become the punchline for every Indian actually involved the energy minister who was just standing in for the defense minister and found it convenient to cover his own shortcomings...BTW, wasn't it the IA which awarded a posthumous medal to a soldier who walked out of a hospital a few days later.

Why Army refused to disclose the casualties to the parliament?

If IA makes mistakes then that will be published and taken up.... Govt can pull up the culprits without fear of being over thrown.....

Edit: Unlike you I believe these casualties are unnecessary (even if itis PA)

 

[Windjammer]

RTI report reveal the casualties summmed up for 15 years which is reported almost on a daily basis ? .The point is If even beheading of our soldiers gets reported in our national media why would we hide the casualties of a ceasefire violation

Do you have any idea of the figures revealed by the RTI......Close to 5000 casualties over a period of some 15 years, breaks down to an average of 27 every month....when was the last time, IA accepted such a toll during any month. !!!!
It's a well known fact that Indian authorities are known to play with public sentiments by creating a hype of soldiers tortured and beheaded....PA would never indulge into such barbaric acts....not even against the likes of TTP who are never shy of releasing videos of their brutalities.

Why Army refused to disclose the casualties to the parliament?

If IA makes mistakes then that will be published and taken up.... Govt can pull up the culprits without fear of being over thrown.....

Edit: Unlike you I believe these casualties are unnecessary (even if itis PA)

Seems you are quick to press the reply button without even reading my post.
Read again, it had nothing to do with army, rather a clay footed politician making lame excuses to escape an argument.

 

[nair]

Seems you are quick to press the reply button without even reading my post.
Read again, it had nothing to do with army, rather a clay footed politician making lame excuses to escape an argument.

I did not see an answer to my question.... if you had given then pls explain..... even not in your second post.... let us not forget we both follow similar political system.... soni understand....

 

[Mrc]

www.tribuneindia.com/news/jammu-kashmir/3-army-jawans-injured-as-pakistan-shells-loc-areas-in-poonch/477230.html

3 Army jawans injured as Pakistan shells LoC areas in Poonch
Jammu Kashmir
Posted at: Oct 4, 2017, 10:54 AM; last updated: Oct 4, 2017, 3:23 PM (IST)

The Indian Army is retaliating effectively and the firing is still on. ANI
Jammu, October 4

Three Army jawans were on Wednesday injured as Pakistani troops fired from automatic weapons and shelled mortars at forward posts and villages along the LoC in Jammu and Kashmir’s Poonch district.Pakistani troops also violated the ceasefire in Laam sector by briefly opening fire along the LoC, police officials said.The Indian Army is retaliating effectively and the firing is still on, a Defence Spokesman said.
(Follow The Tribune on Facebook; and Twitter @thetribunechd)

“Pakistan Army initiated unprovoked and indiscriminate firing of small arms, automatics and mortars from 0845 hours in Poonch sector along the Line of Control (LoC),” the spokesman said.In the firing along the LoC in Poonch sector, three Army jawans suffered injuries, police officials said.On Tuesday, an Army jawan was killed when Pakistan Army violated the ceasefire along the LoC in Poonch.On October 2, two minors were killed and 12 civilians injured in cross-border shelling by Pakistan along the LoC in Poonch district.Five children were among the injured, the youngest being five-year-old Zobia Kousar. PTI

They will die one by one.... actually they are dead just the news is broken as injuries first

 

[Laozi]

They will die one by one.... actually they are dead just the news is broken as injuries first

Even you and I will die eventually

If and when someone from Indian forces die on the line of duty, that Jawan is honoured with a state funeral, which is puclic and telecasted by many channels.

Why are you so anxious to hear about the casualities ?

 

[Taimoor Khan]

https://twitter.com/x/status/915496357212966913

Even yesterday, some Indian bunkers were turned into rubble, again the Indian Army never disclosed it's casualties which is nothing new as like before the true figures will come to light in a few years time.

http://www.indiatimes.com/news/indi...oldiers-since-2001-an-rti-reveals-265046.html

The level of punishment and destruction meted out to the Indian army and its installation along the LOC in recent days, its astonishing that only 3 Indian soldiers were neutralized. Those Indian post will not be habitable in foreseeable future.

 

[Windjammer]

,

Wrong the RTI information is for 27 years not 15 years

Data released by the union ministry of home affairs (MHA) has revealed that over 40,961 people have been killed in different parts of Jammu and Kashmir from 1990 to March 31, 2017.

In an RTI reply, chief public information officer of the union home ministry said 13491 civilians and 5055 security force personnel were killed in different terror attacks. Around 21,965 terrorists have also been neutralized by the security forces in the last 27 years

http://www.dnaindia.com/india/repor...d-in-last-27-years-reveals-rti-report-2422689

Over 4,500 soldiers killed along LoC in Pak firing since 2001: Army
It revealed that post Kargil conflict, as many as 4,675 soldiers have lost their lives along the LoC in ceasefire violations by Pakistan. The RTI reply does not reveal the number of instances of ceasefire violations reported in the last 15 years.

So by your logic below is the casualties of US army from 2001 to 2016

As of October 18th, 2016, there have been 2,386 U.S. military deaths in the War in Afghanistan. 1,834 of these deaths have been the result of hostile action

That makes the monthly average of around 15 so when was the last time, US army accepted such a toll during any month. !!!! Does this mean US army is hiding or they are not aware of your average calculation

LoL....You try very hard to remain relevant but sadly without talking some basic facts into your lame argument....firstly do you know the difference between a conflict happening in Afghanistan and the subject aka....ceasefire violations.....besides how much attention does the conflict in Afghanistan draws or is discussed here, on the contrary, you characters don't miss the news even if a Pakistani national gets deported from anywhere....now work on some better logic and comparison.

 

[YeBeWarned]

Maybe PA intercepted IA communication, not sure but could be possible way to figure out the casualties. Or maybe its just a guess

 

[noksss]

Over 4,500 soldiers killed along LoC in Pak firing since 2001: Army
It revealed that post Kargil conflict, as many as 4,675 soldiers have lost their lives along the LoC in ceasefire violations by Pakistan. The RTI reply does not reveal the number of instances of ceasefire violations reported in the last 15 years.



LoL....You try very hard to remain relevant but sadly without talking some basic facts into your lame argument....firstly do you know the difference between a conflict happening in Afghanistan and the subject aka....ceasefire violations.....besides how much attention does the conflict in Afghanistan draws or is discussed here, on the contrary, you characters don't miss the news even if a Pakistani national gets deported from anywhere....now work on some better logic and comparison.

LOL look back your comments you invented the monthly average calculation and questioned me saying did IA report these many monthly casualties ? . So the american casualties i posted is to point out the flaws in your Nobel prize winning average calculation theory for military casualties

 

[Windjammer]

LOL look back your comments you invented the monthly average calculation and questioned me saying did IA report these many monthly casualties ? . So the american casualties i posted is to point out the flaws in your Nobel prize winning average calculation theory for military casualties

Your stupidity is beyond help, firstly how can you compare an ongoing war figures with that of a cease fire violations....when was the last time you took note of US casualties in Afghanistan.... or i will make it simple for you, like the US, which once suffered over 30 casualties in a single incident, when did the IA ever reported such a loss .
First acquire the ability to understand the psyche of a subject before ridiculing yourself.

http://www.history.com/news/the-costliest-day-in-seal-team-six-history

 

[BATMAN]

ISPR claims not confirms

We don't expect India to acknowledge deaths of its own soldiers, due to Pakistani retaliation.
Yesterday you killed our kids and today we killed few Indian soldiers.
If your soldiers had balls, they would not die in hiding.

 

[sangh]

We don't expect India to acknowledge deaths of its own soldiers, due to Pakistani retaliation.
Yesterday you killed our kids and today we killed few Indian soldiers.

How does ISPR knows 3 Indian soldiers died ??
Does Pakistan shell carries camera on it ?? LOL

India also claims killing dozen of Pakistani soldiers every time in bunker buster shellings , do you accept them ever ??