10 captives, Over 20 soldiers, including Commanding Officer killed at Galwan border clash with China

[Armchair]

At least the liberals and assorted criminals need to not divert this thread. Let us enjoy the beating these Indians are getting. Pakistani liberals - always on the wrong foot.

 

[Mighty Lion]

Today's satellite images have proved Chinese pushed out of Galwan. This is only possible if PLA had heavy casualties.

 

[Syed Asif Bukhari]

So, basically Indian soldiers were mauled , beaten and lynched by Chinese soldiers with iron rods, nails ridden clubs & God knows what. That's a brutal death. Even worse than bullets. Indians atleast should be thankful to us that we give them quick and painless death.

 

[Mighty Lion]

if you see responses of majority of Indian members from page 1, they have only focused on numbers of casualities and have been defending own figures and researching Chinese figures throughout this thread. This is how Indian media has brainwashed them and bollywood have groomed their thinking.

There are many other things as stakes here, not causality numbers. IA has failed to perform and unable to prove itself as a professional army which should be worrisome. The analysis by Indian members should go deeper into why and what failed and how it should be rectified. This is an opportunity lost and the initiative handed over to PLA troops.

What you should analyze is who cotnrols Galwan, today's Sat images show China failed to push into Indian side of LAC.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

They have occupied Quora as well, and huge part of Youtube...

The Chinese state really needs to invest in English as second language. The reality is that English has now become the default global lingua france and as such means it offers a way to global influence. Chinese students in UK are very poor in English. My son and daughter at university have been running a fee paid service to help brush up English which has attracted lot of the Chinese students. This points to poor English teaching in China. You need to up the ante as you become a global power and speak to global audience. Thus you get to shape the global narrative.

 

[Passionaire]

India controls Galwan. See this:

https://twitter.com/x/status/1273212435017564160

https://twitter.com/x/status/1273213659045482496

If you think otherwise, provide satellite images as proof.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1273165002703331328

 

[Imran Khan]

At least the liberals and assorted criminals need to not divert this thread. Let us enjoy the beating these Indians are getting. Pakistani liberals - always on the wrong foot.

what have i did wrong ?????????

 

[maverick1977]

So, basically Indian soldiers were mauled , beaten and lynched by Chinese soldiers with iron rods, nails ridden clubs & God knows what. That's a brutal death. Even worse than bullets. Indians atleast should be thankful to us that we give them quick and painless death.

i didnt know that part... This is crazy... beaten to death ??????

 

[Signalian]

Apparently you are an analyst on PDF. Wow. @Nilgiri @dharmi @Chhatrapati

Anyway, I would always prefer running away and coming to fight another day when the odds are stacked against you instead of losing your life for nothing. Mind you, that's just my personal opinion otherwise you'll try to attribute it to some sort of IA method.

Another point worth mentioning is that if soldiers don't flee, they risk being captured which gives more bargaining power to China. So yeah, fleeing is not some haram thing lol.

As for you running away in such a situation, by all means do as you wish, however such is not expected from Professional Military which comes prepared to the battlefield. Lastly, I have explained thoroughly, why its important to re-group and improvise.

Honestly, dont quote me since you have no idea what im talking about.

 

[Zohair Alam]

I believe you brought "faith" into it. Do you want me to quote it? The Chinese prevailed because of superior training, determination, discipline, driven by nationalism and underpinned by a very strong work ethic. Very qualities, secular qualities that when used in the civilian domain has turned China into a global economic powerhouse. Lesson here for Pakistan. Point being. Praying does not make armies. Training does. I know you carry the halo on your shoulder of being ex-military or whatever but I also know a thing or two. Good day !

Move your feet while you pray.

 

[Aaloo Tikki]

in our country we call it beghairat brigade . hahahha if they have honor they should fight like men on border

We called it human emotions. Hard times, emotions and tempers keep rising.

 

[In arduis fidelis]

Today's satellite images have proved Chinese pushed out of Galwan. This is only possible if PLA had heavy casualties.

Sat Imagery is from yesterday. It only proves Indian went to Chinese side and engaged in hostilities and got their a**es thrown off the mountains.

 

[Sharma Ji]

Apparently you are an analyst on PDF. Wow. @Nilgiri @dharmi @Chhatrapati

Anyway, I would always prefer running away and coming to fight another day when the odds are stacked against you instead of losing your life for nothing. Mind you, that's just my personal opinion otherwise you'll try to attribute it to some sort of IA method.

Another point worth mentioning is that if soldiers don't flee when they are outnumbered, they risk being captured which gives more bargaining power to China. So yeah, fleeing is not some haram thing lol.

Pretty sure Sun Tzu might have said something to that extent as well.

I'm going to wait till the dust settles on this one a bit, read all sorts of insane reports about what might have gone down there..

 

[Song Hong]

Based on my impression on China social media

1. There was construction at China LAC at 15th June
2. Indian regular unit intruded and beat up people.
3. China reinforcement arrived and started fighting (They were well prepared and could be special forces)
4. Indians regular unit was no match of Chinese special forces. China did not have fatalities but rather minor injuries.

 

[Signalian]

I believe you brought "faith" into it. Do you want me to quote it? The Chinese prevailed because of superior training, determination, discipline, driven by nationalism and underpinned by a very strong work ethic. Very qualities, secular qualities that when used in the civilian domain has turned China into a global economic powerhouse. Lesson here for Pakistan. Point being. Praying does not make armies. Training does. I know you carry the halo on your shoulder of being ex-military or whatever but I also know a thing or two. Good day !

Faith in weaponry. Im not interested in discussing religion.