Zakir Naik: Pakistan should not have been created

[war&peace]

Poor zakir naik can't come back so he is saying this to win over hindu hardliners from india.

This is almost 7 years old video but I guess now his mind would have changed by the treatment he is getting from the hindutva state.

 

[SrNair]

On topic:
Pakistan is the best thing happened in sub continent .We will protect our minorities .
And will always made us proud.

 

[Nexus]

Still no Kashmir for you.
You are free to give away your birthplace. My homeland is not for barter.

Don't take that NRI seriously,she's not even an Indian. Kashmir in India and Idia is kashmir just like Punjab,Gujarat Maharashtra etc etc.

 

[Tea addict]

This is an old video but I guess his opinion, if asked now, would be antithetically different. The mistreatment he is receiving at the hands of the hindu terrorist state should be sufficient to open his eyes wide for realising this bitter reality that we are two different nations and cannot live together especially under the rule of hindu majority since they are the most narrow-minded people on this planet. If he still believes in the same crap then he is a FOOL.

He is not some indian ultranationalist(akahand bharat) or some liberal snowflakes who think Pakistan was a mistake..his only concern is islam as he think 600million muslims of india would have surpassed 900 million hindus in few decades and complete india would be islamic..he doesn't care that 1 million people were killed with gandasays in few weeks in 1947 whereas in 5 years 250k people have died in syria even after using modern firearms and missiles

 

[Nexus]

Except Azad Kashmir, of course.

"Mirpur" aka pahari region, not kashmir

 

[Kabira]

Yup.
Do you know how many of them took refuge in India?How many of them applied for our citizenship?.
How many from our minorities applied for refuge or citizenship in Pakistan?
Do you have any statistics?

Pakistan isn't open to minorities in India. We don't have land for 200 million more. India on the other hand with 1400 million population will not mind even if all of hindus who only number few million migrated there.

 

[SrNair]

Well some of them are loyal to their country despite being treated like crap by hindu hardliners from india.
Btw Pakistan is not a refugee camp.

All of them are loyal to India .And if they have any issue we will have a Constitution ,a powerful judiciary system and media to support them.

How many of the Afghan refugees are in Pakistan?How much your nation spend to feed them?

 

[Kabira]

He is not some indian ultranationalist(akahand bharat) or some liberal snowflakes who think Pakistan was a mistake..his only concern is islam as he think 600million muslims of india would have surpassed 900 million hindus in few decades and complete india would be islamic..he doesn't care that 1 million people were killed with gandasays in few weeks in 1947 whereas in 5 years 250k people have died in syria even after using modern firearms and missiles

1947 riots were stupid, hey look people are leaving but lets kill them anyway. Indian muslim country in future most have better plan and peaceful way to transplant people from one place to another. For people religion comes first so they will not mind leaving their place behind for peaceful future.

 

[saurav jha]

One more Pakistan out of India is needed to accommodate 200 million muslims, even if 100 years from now on when Indian muslim population most have passed 500 million. Total exchange of population was never on cards. For that India would had to give up land like it will happen now. You guys shouldn't have played facade of secularism back then to retain so many non-hindus along with land.

Any more land is out of question. We need find out another solution.

 

[Nexus]

It is funny to see armchair activists like us discussing so seriously. As if WE CONTROL ANYTHING.

Maybe one day one of us will controlled delhi and kick start suddhii movement.

 

[SrNair]

Pakistan isn't open to minorities in India. We don't have land for 200 million more. India on the other hand with 1400 million population will not mind even if all of hindus who only number few million migrated there.

Nope ,we cant easily allow all refugees in India.If a certain religious groups in your nation seeks refugee in neighbouring country ,then that is the failure of your Govt and institutions .
We Indians irrespective of their religion donot like more refugees in India .
We can afford few millions because of our economy .Not more than that.
Our minorities wont apply refugee in other nation because that is the success of Govt institutions.

 

[Kabira]

Any more land is out of question. We need find out another solution.

Land was solution before and it will be solution in future. People in north west british raj got their freedom along with in east bengal. But there should have been Israel like solution for 200 million Indian muslims. Give them huge piece of land somewhere along coast and ask them to migrate there while hindus leave and occupy muslim areas.

This is how I see it in 100 years down the road. For people religion comes first so conflict will continue because of hindutvas ruling Delhi.

 

[Tea addict]

1947 riots were stupid, hey look people are leaving but lets kill them anyway. Indian muslim country in future most have better plan and peaceful way to transplant people from one place to another. For people religion comes first so they will not mind leaving their place behind for peaceful future.

They were not stupid, they were just series of retaliation after retaliation.
And no region of india other than kashmir valley has absolute muslim majority, so no another partition is not happening..and if it happen then i don't think 200 million muslims will be get large piece of land and that too will be isolated regions not connected..some part of west bengal,kashmir, one or two district of Kerala and one or two district im Hyderabad and west up..they will end up with much dense population than Bangladesh with no connectivity and natural resources.. that's why even the radical elements of indian muslims don't ask for partition.

 

[Kabira]

Nope ,we cant easily allow all refugees in India.If a certain religious groups in your nation seeks refugee in neighbouring country ,then that is the failure of your Govt and institutions .
We Indians irrespective of their religion donot like more refugees in India .
We can afford few millions because of our economy .Not more than that.
Our minorities wont apply refugee in other nation because that is the success of Govt institutions.

Only few thousand hindus have gone to India. We on the other hand have received millions of illegal Indian muslims migrants till 90's.

 

[Jackdaws]

Well some of them are loyal to their country despite being treated like crap by hindu hardliners from india.
Btw Pakistan is not a refugee camp.

Nope, but it must have a refugee policy. It did take in a lot of Afghan refugees. How many Indian citizens have applied for refuge there?