Yvonne Ridley says Dr Afia Siddique was gang raped by 6 US soldiers in Bagram jail

[GiannKall]

As per sources She was captured inside Afghanistan along with one or two children with maps of building biological weapons.

But not convicted about it. Strange

 

[VCheng]

As per sources She was captured inside Afghanistan along with one or two children with maps of building biological weapons.

Incorrect Sir. She was apprehended in Karachi by Pakistani agencies. She re-appeared later outside Bagram airbase trying to help in carrying out terrorist attacks. Pakistani agencies also took two of her children and later reached an "accommodation" with her family. The attempted murder charges and conviction came much later when she tried to escape.

 

[wOnDeR-ChAp]

Incorrect Sir. She was apprehended in Karachi by Pakistani agencies. She re-appeared later outside Bagram airbase trying to help in carrying out terrorist attacks. Pakistani agencies also took two of her children and later reached an "accommodation" with her family. The attempted murder charges and conviction came much later when she tried to escape.

When she was arrested by agencies in Karachi then how comes she reappeared in Afghanistan? She was questioned here only after that she crosses the border to carry out the attacks.

 

[VCheng]

When she was arrested by agencies in Karachi then how comes she reappeared in Afghanistan? She was questioned here only after that she crosses the border to carry out the attacks.

Good questions, but these should be directed to Pakistani agencies. They have these answers.

 

[kamrananvaar]

You have serious comprehension issues...

I don't want to continue a debate with a retard.

Bye.

Look who's calling a retard , yeah you guessed it a retard

 

[ConcealCarry]

@mods please check this idiot

She committed murder, she should have been raped. Good.

 

[livingdead]

She committed murder, she should have been raped. Good.

so every murderer should be raped.... ?

She eventually got the justice she deserved, but that was by due process, under which she has certain rights which are inviolable.

I think most of those locked up in similar situation did not get a fair trial... pretty sure.. am saying this because of a story i got to know.. you can ignore it saying yeah its not reliable...
i met a guy few years ago with my friends.. later on my friend told me he was caught in USA(he was a student) after 9/11, tortured to confess that he has done some crime(he did not commit) and kicked out of USA to India.... the guy is not even muslim(he is hindu), so its not islamophobia. thankfully he has rebuilt his life, works for reputed MNC in india... got family and everything.
american justice system could be better than india....but thats pretty crappy standard to compare against....

 

[VCheng]

so every murderer should be raped.... ?


I think most of those locked up in similar situation did not get a fair trial... pretty sure.. am saying this because of a story i got to know.. you can ignore it saying yeah its not reliable...
i met a guy few years ago with my friends.. later on my friend told me he was caught in USA(he was a student) after 9/11, tortured to confess that he has done some crime(he did not commit) and kicked out of USA to India.... the guy is not even muslim(he is hindu), so its not islamophobia. thankfully he has rebuilt his life, works for reputed MNC in india... got family and everything.
american justice system could be better than india....but thats pretty crappy standard to compare against....

His deportation record will highlight everything that he underwent and its legal reasons, I am quite sure.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

A muslim woman was raped by 6 men at a US base but you seem to be more concerned with the title having "US soldiers" in it instead of men.

And this woman was raped by 6 men. You seem to be concerned by qualifying the woman with "Muslim" as if the crime is greater as a consequence of the prefix. Reveals your thought process.

And can somebody please explain to me what was this "woman" who called herself "Muslim" doing in Afghanistan?

Or more to the point what was this "Muslim" woman doing away from her family? On hen night out?

 

[livingdead]

His deportation record will highlight everything that he underwent and its legal reasons, I am quite sure.

yeah.. but it does not cite any torture and threat of jail on fake charges(not sure if it is legal in USA to threat somebody of jail by trumped up charges so that the person confesses to a lesser crime that you wanted to charge with anyway).
in any case this is relatively minor thing, pretty sure they just wanted to deport him, not jail him.... the 'due process' is a farce is what I am saying.. not saying people are necessarily innocent of any crime.

 

[VCheng]

yeah.. but it does not cite any torture and threat of jail on fake charges(not sure if it is legal in USA to threat somebody of jail by trumped up charges so that the person confesses to a lesser crime that you wanted to charge with anyway).
in any case this is relatively minor thing, pretty sure they just wanted to deport him, not jail him.... the 'due process' is a farce is what I am saying.. not saying people are necessarily innocent of any crime.

What he claims may not be true. Please quote his Deportation Case Number if you have it. He must have committed a felony for which a jail term of more than 6 months can be given. The law is quite clear.

 

[jamal18]

No, but
Attempted Murder X2,
Assault with a deadly weapon
carrying and using a prohibited firearm.
Assault without causing actual bodily harm X3

Is very much a crime, that deserved the punishment she got.

These 'crimes' don't add up to 90 years in any country.

 

[livingdead]

What he claims may not be true. Please quote his Deportation Case Number if you have it. He must have committed a felony for which a jail term of more than 6 months can be given. The law is quite clear.

yo bro... i dont even know the guy.. he was friend of a friend... who told the story to me... that too long time ago... if he committed felony he should be jailed.. and then probably deported... he was never jailed....
even i suspect some minor crime like may be visa term violation... which he could be hiding.. who knows...

 

[VCheng]

yo bro... i dont even know the guy.. he was friend of a friend... who told the story to me... that too long time ago... if he committed felony he should be jailed.. and then probably deported... he was never jailed....
even i suspect some minor crime like may be visa term violation... which he could be hiding..

This friend of a friend is lying, plain and simple. He committed a deportable offence and was deported. End of story.

 

[livingdead]

This friend of a friend is lying, plain and simple. He committed a deportable offence and was deported. End of story.

i am not saying deportation was definitely wrong, it could have been right... but torture was wrong... men dont admit torture usually... i guess its a masculinity thing... it makes you look weak.. he had no reason to tell his friends.