What's new

Would America Risk a Nuclear War with China over Taiwan?

Status
Not open for further replies.
DF-21 hasn't been tested to hit ships in the Pacific, hence to me its still BS but you stated it has such capability. Do you believe it? Do you believe that they will be used on carriers in the Pacific? But that would show that there is conflict in the Pacific Ocean. But why would you do it? Why hit the ships in the Pacific Ocean?
I have never mentioned DF-21 has that kind of capability lol, it's the PLA that stated that. If you think DF-21 is BS then the US NAVY probably too must think it's BS so most likely they will get involved in a war between Mainland and Taiwan then?
Well if that's the case the PLA will have to deal with the Pacific Ocean too but that's all speculation isn't it? :rofl:
 
.
I have never mentioned DF-21 has that kind of capability lol, it's the PLA that stated that. If you think DF-21 is BS then the US NAVY probably too must think it's BS so most likely they will get involved in a war between Mainland and Taiwan then?
Well if that's the case the PLA will have to deal with the Pacific Ocean too but that's all speculation isn't it? :rofl:

Well it looks like the PLA is smarter than you in terms of thinking about dealing with the U.S. Navy in the Pacific Ocean whether its long range bombers or the so called carrier killer ballistic missile. Germany sure thought of that when they fought against Britain in the Atlantic Ocean before the U.S. was involved.
 
.
Ugh, I can't not agree with you. That's true. So except PRC want to flattened Taiwan (which is basically not in PRC agenda), it's hard to do it. But I still believe that PRC will attack Taiwan if they declare "De Jure" independent.

But, why PLA have to send their ground troop before the sea is safe?

The Sea is never going to be safe as the sea does not just guarded by the Naval Element, First, you have Taiwan own Island chain (Penghu, Kinmen and Matsu Island) that Chinese need to take before heading to Taiwan, simply Guns on those Island can shoot at ships crossing over the strait, SAM on those island would take down transport and PLA Troop have to take those 3 island before the grand assault, and that will divert resource such as ship, manpower and airpower for 3 miniature Invasion.

Then Come between those Island and the Main Island, Sub would be a problem, and also Missile, Guns, SAMs and Aircraft Based near the coastal area would be a problem. Also, since Taiwan knew the intention by the preceding invasion of the outlying Island. The Taiwanese would simply mine the approach. And all these you cannot touch until you have infantry on Taiwan Soil. Even then, China could most likely achieve Air Superiority but not Air Supremacy that mean the Air Campaign over Taiwan will be impeded by the ROCAF, and if USAF were involved, then I don't think China can achieve even Local Air Superiority, and the airspace between China and Taiwan will be contested.

It quite depend on Taiwan on whether or not they will declare dejure independence, the question is always, why? They have a good thing going on now, both China and Taiwan, why would both or one of them want to upset the balance??

As I said, eventually Taiwan will reunited with China, and that contrary to most Chinese member think, it would be on Taiwanese term, unless it's like you said, China wanted to flatten Taiwan, but then what is the point of reclaiming a flatten land??
 
.
Well it looks like the PLA is smarter than you in terms of thinking about dealing with the U.S. Navy in the Pacific Ocean whether its long range bombers or the so called carrier killer ballistic missile. Germany sure thought of that when they fought against Britain in the Atlantic Ocean before the U.S. was involved.
So now you are starting to sound like the PLA isn't stupid enough to deploy DF-21D if it didn't work in the first place but yet it has never been tested before so you think it's BS weapon. Guess the PLA isn't that smart after all according to you unless you believe in that BS yourself. :rofl:
If somewhere in your mind believe it might work then the more reason to believe the US won't get involved and that means i was correct assuming the war will stick to our home turf and not the Pacific Ocean.
 
. .
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top Bottom