What's new

Will Pakistan’s energy crisis ever end?

Men in Green

FULL MEMBER
Joined
May 2, 2014
Messages
1,413
Reaction score
0
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
23386-energycrisis-1406381020-164-640x480.jpg


Ever since the energy crisis hit the country, the whole nation is looking for an answer to one question – will it ever end? This is just one simple question which many governments have failed to address. The former Pakistan Peoples Party (PPP) government gave false hopes to the people and as evident, even after the end of their five-year tenure, there is no improvement in the energy sector and the people are left suffering from 10 to 14 hours of load shedding.

Since the formation of PML-N government with their aggressive energy policy cum metro bus approach, the question arises again whether their energy policies will help curtail the energy crisis till 2017 or at least reduce the number of load shedding hours.

Here is an analysis of the energy policy of Pakistan the government has released in October 2013. As per section 7 (1) of the National Power Policywhich defines the supply strategy, the government has planned a number of power projects which are expected to be completed during their five-year term. The following projects have being initiated by government expected to be completed by 2017-18:

energy.jpg


This means that if everything goes as planned, the government will increase the generation capacity by 5094 megawatt (MW) till the end of their five-year term. At present, we have an installed capacity of 22,797 MW and the average demand is around 17,000 MW while the short fall fluctuates between 4000 to 5000 MW.

The point of contention is whether the predicted figure of 5094 MW will be enough for curtailing the energy crisis in the country. A load forecast report published by National Transmission Dispatch Authority (NTDA)every year states that by 2017-18 the electricity demand in the country will go up to 35,000 MW.

Now, for instance, if we add 5094 MW into the national grid till 2017 and considering that the government brings installed capacity (22,797 MW) online by retiring the circular debt and reducing the line losses by 9%, which means adding 27,891 MW under ‘ideal circumstances’ by end of 2017 even then if the demand side is considered, we will still be facing a short fall of 7,109MW (35,000 – 27,891) by the end of 2017.

The National Energy Policy of 2013 reflects on the government’s attitude in resolving the energy crisis of the country. The government needs to seriously revise their energy policy keeping in view load forecast, otherwise the conditions will be worse than ever; the nation will probably experience load shedding of 15 to 20 hours a day and many remote areas will be left in darkness.

Almost 65% of Pakistan’s electricity production is based on thermal fuel sources such as Residual Fuel Oil (RFO) and High Speed Diesel (HSD) which are highly expensive and non-renewable sources of generation. Dependence on such fuels increases the cost of generation. On the contrary, it has a negative impact on the environment due to excessive carbon oxide emissions which result in climatic changes. Beside this, we are facing an acute shortage of gas as well. If the Iran-Pakistan gas pipeline had worked out, it would have been contributing substantially to resolving the energy crisis. But unfortunately, due to foreign pressure, the project eventually ended up in the loss of billions of rupees.

At present, to overcome the energy crisis and to meet future energy challenges, Pakistan needs to build micro-hydro projects. They are cheaper and one of the most reliable forms of renewable energy source.. We need to put our focus on energy conservation by minimising energy usage through developing effective energy management plans and ensuring its implementation in corporate, industrial and housing sectors. The government should set energy conservation standards for large, medium and small scale industries and encourage the industrial sector to reduce their energy consumption by benchmarking their energy usage and energy saving drives.

Moreover, Independent Power Producers (IPPs) should be provided subsidy and tax rebates so that they can enter into Power Purchase Agreements (PPAs) with industrial owners and sell electricity on cheaper rates to industries which will eventually help catering the demand of industrial consumers and decrease their reliability on the national grid.

Since solar technologies are becoming prominent all over the world due to massive decrease in cost per watt from $7 per watt to $1 per watt, the concept of Net Metering should be introduced to encourage domestic and commercial consumers to setup their own small scale grid connected Photovoltaic (PV) solar plants. This step will not only help boosting the PV solar market in Pakistan but will also result in adding surplus units to the national grid, favouring both the user and utility service providers.

Pakistan has abundant resources of shale oil and gas which needs to be explored and can be used effectively as alternative fuel for electricity generation. According to Energy Information Administration (EIA), a US agency working on energy statistics and analysis has estimated recoverable shale gas reserves of 105 Trillion Cubic Feet (TCF) and more than nine billion oil barrels within Pakistan. Thus overcoming the energy crisis in the five-year term for any government will not be a problem if the existing resources are utilised effectively.

If we really want to resolve the energy crisis in our country, our policy should focus on demand based energy conservation and load forecasting of the upcoming years, and an effective implementation plan. Otherwise, we will end up building more circular debt, hence leading to prolonged periods of dark ages.

Will Pakistan’s energy crisis ever end? – The Express Tribune Blog
 
It is not just the generation , but actually what is the mode of generation. We need to concentrate on hydel and nuclear for bulk power generation whereas solar and wind for lower base demand areas.
We have already wasted too much time on kala bath, bash a and dassu dam. Ñeelam Jhelum in 15 year behind schedule.
 
"Pakistan will / can only break free from shackles of Energy hunger if it chooses the Path of Solar Pannels for Residential Homes

180 million population , 4 people/ home -> 45 Million Homes that need to be converted to use Solar Energy

If Government sets a target of 10 Million homes converted to use Solar Energy , in 5 years we can be energy Independent


Phase 1 : Encourage Homes to use Solar Panel Systems
Phase 2 : Setup Solar Farms outside of Main Cities (Supplimental Energy Generation)
Phase 3 : Establishment of Nuclear Energy Systems for Industrial Areas

Its a very simple process

Cost of Solar Pannel System is just $1500-$2500 per home


Example:
Saudia Donated 1 Billion dollar recently its enough to convert
700,000 Thousand homes to be energy independent (Of conventional Electricity Usage)

Example : 2.8 Milion people would not be complaining of Electricity problem


Also the average population can afford to setup a system by their own purchasing power.

People can buy $1500-2500 systems for their homes in Pakistan its almost cost of 1 month rental for home


Some peopel argued it will cost 1 Billion for Lahore Metro Bus project

Well you can solve electricity problem with that 1 Billion

Another 700,000 people are free of electricity burden or 3 Million people


What could have been a successful Government Policy:

Donation from Saudia Arabia : 1 Billion Dollars
Divert Funds from Metro Train Project : $1.6 billion
Attain a loan from World Bank : $2 Billion
Loan from Islamic Bank : $400 Million
Pakistan's own investment :$1 Billion
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
$6.0 Billion Dollars
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------



6 Billion would have helped 4 Million homes across Pakistan

Directly effected Citizens : 16 Million Citizen

Indirect Effects: ( May be you are helping another 16 million people indirectly)
Surplus energy in grid system (Less people using grid) , the energy would be diverted to perhaps industrial areas or residential areas


Turn around time would have been 1.5 years


2013 Pakistan Electric Creation 15,000MW/ Year , and we have shortfall of about

Lets see how much this innitiative would have saved in term of energy

1 home /month 903 kilowatthours (kWh) per month (USA HOME with Microwave and AC)
12 Month = 10,836 kWh

Convert 10,836 kWh to Kilowatts = 103 Watts of energy producerd by home in 1 year

103 watts x 4,000,000 Million = 412,000,000 Watts per year produced by 4 Million Homes

412 MW Energy created directly at grass root level (Homes) , its 100% free clean


>The advantage of this strategy is you are by passing electric companies
> You are by passing their old transformer "excuse"
> You are by passing any power loss in transmission lines "excuse"
> You get free power and it comes fuels your own home so you are not stealing electricity




Please note

"Pakistan has 42 Million house holds (4 people per home = 180 Million Population)
so we need 4 Billion Watts per year for residential area

So our need is 4,000 MW " for powering homes , all homes in Pakistan not just in lahore
(Calculation done above for 1 year 1 home : 103 watts x 4,000,000 Million = 412,000,000 Watts per year produced by 4 Million Homes)


Terbella Dam Capacity to make power 3478 MW


The fact that our Power system analyst say they produce 15000MW - 20,000 MW energy and yet we have load sheding is questionable

May be they should do ENERGY AUDIT .. where electricity is disappearing , is it just we don't have storage capacity to store the energy , or is is equipment lines / transformers need upgrading and no new plant constructions are needed

If we make 15,000 MW - 20,000 MW and all calculations say our need for residential sector is 4,000 MW , so where is all the extra Electricity going ?

May be they should have 4 Electric companies handling each Province Seperately

1996 we had power surplus we were planning to sell energy to other countries

2001 we had power surplus , 3000-4000MW surplus , that is big number

and then we had no power ???

Very questionable.....


Is this shortage artificially created by Power companies or "Private" power companies so they can keep charging people and government ?


If we view this problem another way

42 Million Homes need how much energy = 4000 MW (ALL PAKISTAN )
All factories in Pakistan need perhaps energy = 6,000 MW


Still it is just 10,000 MW , our eningeers say they make 15,000MW -22,000MW per year
So where is energy going ? It does not fits the mathematical formulas ?
Is there like Underground line going from Pakistan to Afghanistan that we don't know of ?




Do Pakistan run Electricity driven Ships (NO)
Do Pakistan runs Electricity driven Trains (NO)
Do Pakistan runs Electricity driven Subways (NO)
Is there a electrical fence across Pakistan - Aghanistan Border (NO)


So where is the 10,000-12,000 MW lost energy going ? ? ?


Logical Answers:

> Electricity Mafia running private power plants
> Low quality engineers in WAPDA and other electricial companies who can't figure out
where electric energy is disappaering
> Out dated transformers and equipment
> Someone is hijacking our electricity ?????
 
Last edited:
1. Solar power technology as of today is over rated.

2. We need visionaries in these fields like energy security, education and sustainable transportation means etc. Unfortunately in south asia, the scum politicians with their 5 year terms doesn't do justice to the positions.
 
Also note that even if we make 5,000 MW as our government promises , it can "MYSTERIOUSLY" disappear as well just like the other 10,000 WM we have unaccounted for already

Any reasonable person would allocate % electricity to each province

Total Capacity : 22,000 MW

Sindh 6,000 MW
Punjab 6,000 MW
KPK 5,000 MW
Balouchistan 5,000 MW

And at provincial level setup organizations that track the "wastage of energy" and see if they need to fix transformers or lines

And then track where is the loss happening ?

May be we don't need "New Loans for Power plants"

May be we just need to update "transformers , put in new lines for electricity underground "
or other initiative..


10,000 MW un accounted for and , adding 5,000MW will vanish just like other unless we introduce system that helps us track loss of electricity
 
In india, there are concept of building intelligent towns/societies, These town store rain water, recycle garbage to generate Bio Gas for cooking, and generate electricity for small use. It's need of the hour that some industrialist get in, and start developing complete house appliance using solar energy. If somehow residential area is independent from Energy Needs from the Electricity Companies, they can save most of energy losses. This Expensive energy should only be concentrated only for industries.
 
Last edited:
Not if you don't convert 80% of home to use solar energy

Solar is still very inefficient. The technology still has to fully mature, and it's changing rapidly. You spend a good amount of money buying panels today, you'll need to replace it a year from now because the efficiency has improved drastically and your panels are now obsolete.

Solar is unreliable because it's heavily reliant on the weather. The only widespread solar scheme that will work is one that feeds into the grid and draws power from it when solar is down. Such a system will require heavy investments into upgrading the grid - which again is quite costly.
 
The issue in Pak isnt that we dnt have the capacity, its tht we dnt pay our Power Companies their dues. U can setup 100,000MW but loadshedding will remain. Unless u pay the IPPs there dues, they will have cash flow problems and wont produce as much power as their installed capacity. Its simple, solve the circular debt= majority loadshedding finished
 
so much of the claims! Showbaz Sharif, sorry my bad, I mean Shahbaz Sharif should change his name.
Thats not his job, he is CM. I think pmln should consider changing his portfolio to minister water and power.
 
energy.jpg


Many projects are missing from this list which will be completed by 2017-18. Solar park is 1000mw not 341. Sahiwal is of 1320mw not 660mw. Tarbela 5th extension 1340MW. And Godani coal power plants, Qasim port etc

This list have missed many coal power projects.
 
the list contains projects that are surely to be implemented..it doesnt contains projects that are in final stage of designing..its missing coal projects in karachi too which is in construction

those are saying solar,solar, i will like to ask what will u do in winter and cloudy season as well as at night??? also making a grid for low input at every location will be another problem..solar may be good for homes, excellent for tube wells but not for industries etc

its cheaper but dirtier to invest in coal, otherwise every coal mined would have been closed by now...we can afford some coal as we are not using it yet..as compared to india/china which produces over half from coal
 
Last edited:
Real answer is , that if you give gift to your relatives , given them Solar Pannel system for their home
When peopel will buy this 1 time , instead of Motor bike or car , they will automatically uneffected by any load sheading
 
Real answer is , that if you give gift to your relatives , given them Solar Pannel system for their home
When peopel will buy this 1 time , instead of Motor bike or car , they will automatically uneffected by any load sheading

how much does it cost to go solar for a single family home? In India, solar is mostly used for heating water.
 
Back
Top Bottom