Why don't you understand and act like a landay ka liberal.....?
This law imposed to stop Shia who are abusing Sahaba in all of their Majalis and in return getting @ss kicked by Sunnis....
After we declare Qadianis Kafir they are no riots or widespread killings because of Qadiani fitna.
I am not comparing it but just giving an example that if Pakistani Shia have some issue with human rights then we will gave them same rights as Sunnis have in Iran.
I act the way I do because I have an education and realize I don't live in the middle ages where the cure for diseases was to eat mercury.
Is your God so weak that you need need to make laws so people don't hurt his feelings?
My God is not that weak.
My God is that of the prophet, who didn't lift a finger against the absolute worst abuse hurled at him by the people in Mecca.
My God is the one of peace, mercy and patience.
Also please address my point point of hypocrisy in Pakistani society.
Last I checked batcha bazi was haram.
stealing, in the form of corruption, was haram
marrying children against their will was haram.
please address this point. Are the things I mentioned not haram?
If they are, why is the ISLAMIC REPUBLIC of PAKISTAN not taking action against them?
After all, Islam is in danger right?
This is exactly the issue, they don't say such things to each other within their sect. They can preach whatever they want in their madrissas or private gatherings.
But instead they do it public gathering, record it and widely spread it over the social channels. Why would you do that deliberately knowing that you live in the country as minority and this will deeply hurt sentiments of majority of the people?
and?
You can preach what ever you want.
Go and preach that what they preach is wrong.
Why does your God have such thin skin and will get his feeling hurt so quickly?
My God is not that weak.
The problem is that they not only say to each other but when they also try to force what they say to each other on me
This is the issue that we want to tackle here
You can say whatever you want to in your home. Don't impose it on others
What part is wrong in that?
See my comment above
Wait for Sunni sects to join in near future too ... when their books start getting banned ... hate is everywhere and this bill targets it wholesale.
THIS
This is what people don't understand.
Once you start banning things, it is only a matter of time until it starts to affect the proponents as well.
For me it's frustrating how people can't see this.
Your house is on fire and you are bragging that your room is nice and warm... eventually the flames will get you too.
Look at the countless examples in history.
Only Shias are objecting to this bill and their main arguments are:
- We cannot put "رضی اللہ غنہ" after the name of every Sahabi (because they don't consider a lot of Prophet's companions as Sahabi especially Hazrat Muawiyah). The bill asks to respect all Sahaba, no disrespect, insult or abuse against any of Prophet's companion is to be allowed. All books or literature with such material is to be removed.
- They put "علیہ السلام" (which is mostly used for past Prophets) after Hazrat Ali's name instead of "رضی اللہ غنہ" because they consider Hazrat Ali as equal in islami stature as other Prophets (Again they don't consider Hazrat Ali merely a Sahabi or Khalif, but way more than that - either equal or Prophets, better than all Prophets, or some of them even consider Ali as the God).
- They don't consider Abu Bakr, Umer and Usman as first 3 Khalifas. The bill asks to recognize all four Khalifs and write the words "خلیفہ راشد" before the name of all four of them.
- The bill asks to give respect to all four daughters of Prophet Mohammed (p.b.u.h) but Shias only consider Hazrat Fatima as the only daughter of Prophet.
- All wives of Prophet Muhammed (p.b.u.h) are to be duly respected (which again is a problem for Shias as they are widely against Hazrat Ayesha).
Now put the sectarianism aside and think about it. Is there any unreasonable demand in this bill?
I am objecting to this bill as a non Shia on the bases that it violates fundamental human rights, and rights that are enshrined in Sharia as well.