Why PTI failed in KPK?

[Realistic Change]

Trust me urdu speaking nationalists are just the same. Hate everyone around them and unwilling to accept their prominent position in Pakistan with urdu the national language, muhajirs having highest gdp per capita and education, and wealth being skewed towards them. Karachi accounts for 30% of revenue for Pakistan and is the capital of Sindh. Completely in the hands of muhajirs financially, socially and demographically. On the other hand Sindhis have a worse poverty rate in rural sindh (95% sindhi) than even Balochistan which is the poorest province in the country.

This is not only a problem in Punjab. I mean what is the logic of having ethnic parties. Its like a fashion statement these days. Punjabis and Muhajirs are at the top of the national heirarchy, this is not opinion but fact. Balochistan and parts of KPK are in a terrible situation and that is the only reason-no development and education occurring there that Afghans and Indians are exploiting and leading the youth astray.

I hate PMLN and its Punjabi chauvinism but I don't think these people will look at the bigger picture or change the way they vote for the benefit of Pakistan or for a uniting ideology even if it makes Pakistan a fractured state of varying ethnic groups each voting for an ethnic party. Their thinking is small and based on the fracturing concept of regionalism. Hence no point arguing with them. You argue with someone willing to change his ways and try for a better Pakistan, those who accept the status quo and corruption as a natural part of the system. No wonder people lose hope in the system and set their rocks in a foreign boat of another country. Pakistanis aren't ready to think beyond ethnicity. The voting trends can be seen very clearly if there hasn't been rigging. PMLN has its base in Punjab, PPP in Sindh, ANP in KPK, MQM in Karachi and hyderabad, so on. The ones defending pmln are part of the corrupt system and part of the wider problem of tolerating corruption.

This ethnic divide was deliberately highlighted by N$'s spiritual dad (Zia) when partyless elections were conducted to counter PPP - fully knowing that this will create hell for Pakistan in future.

Ghulam Ishaq Khan spearheaded that under direct guidance of Zia and that faultline was fully exploited by Nawaz Sharif to divide country when he ran his whole campaign in 1988 on this slogan:

Jaag Punjabi Jaag
Teri Pagg Nou Lag Gaye Aag

And...

Jaag Punjabi Jaag
Teri Pagg Nou Lag Gaya Daagh


This along with ISI funding and rigging turned the tide when PPP won the National Assembly (almost) majority and Provincial Assembly in Punjab was gifted to N$.

40+ independents were bought in Changa Manga and Murree Punjab House and rest everyone knows what resulted.

Those seeds sowed by N$ - further divided the nation and now we see how Ch votes for Ch etc., and this is how we welcomed 21st century!

 

[Imad.Khan]

Favourite arguments of Karachi muahjirs is to say look N is ethnic party like MQM. When the reality couldn't be further from the truth. Here is the difference, no punjabi, baloch and sindhi in MQM and ANP. In N league there are members from every corner of Pakistan, they most have missed N league ethnic manifesto.

Reality is PPP, N and now PTI are only true mainstream parties in this country. They may make governments in certain provinces and not others but that doesn't make them ethnic.

PPP is gone except in Rural Sindh. It was once a main stream party but not anymore.

ANP and MQM politics is based on ethnics so they will never ever be main stream parties. Same applies to PkMAP, BNP, PML-F. While JUI-F politics is based on deobandi Islam so they too will never be a main stream party.

 

[Zibago]

If N is punjabi nationalist party then why I see so many muhajirs, baloch, and patahsn in it? hahaha

Do you see any punjabi in ANP and MQM?

Think of them as Muslim wing of RSS
They are just for token show

Do you think rural areas will become developed in few years? I wish that was possible but even cities have clean water and electricity shortages. N have started many projects and slowly whole punjab will have clean water starting from south punjab districts.

You just signed off our electricty supply to cities no ?

 

[Kabira]

Think of them as Muslim wing of RSS
They are just for token show

Remember if others want to shut down Nawaz doors in other provinces over ethnic differences then PTI should rename itself as pathan tehrik insaaf. They will not be allowed to do politics in punjab on ethnics. Some other party will take their place.

 

[Zibago]

Remember if others want to shut down Nawaz doors in other provinces over ethnic differences then PTI should rename itself as pathan tehrik insaaf. They will not be allowed to do politics in punjab on ethnics. Some other party will take their place.

Pathan kaisey the best mna to be ever elected to the NA is an Urdu speaking Pakistani called Asad Umar
His brother om the other hand is too busy spreading alternative facts overthe media

 

[Kabira]

Pathan kaisey the best mna to be ever elected to the NA is an Urdu speaking Pakistani called Asad Umar
His brother om the other hand is too busy spreading alternative facts overthe media

token hai jaise musle rss mein hote hai. While his brother in N is governor of Sindh now. asad ko nalkon ke liye rakha hai

If potis play ethnic politics then PTI shall remain limited to KP and that to in Peshawar. They will then can compete with ANP as it's supposed to be.

 

[Zibago]

While his brother in N is governor of Sindh now

Kiyon key parchi judge faut ho gaya aur koyi option hi nahi rahi

If potis play ethnic politics then PTI shall remain limited to KP and that to in Peshawa

Ethnic politics to jaag punjabi jaag waley bhai ki policy hey

 

[Kabira]

Ethnic politics to jaag punjabi jaag waley bhai ki policy hey

And I can fill 2 pages with the number of times PTI have played pathan card, but I'm willing to give them benefit of doubt.

 

[Zibago]

And I can fill 2 pages with the number of times PTI have played pathan card, but I'm willing to give them benefit of doubt.

Bhol gaye jab choti tind ny punjab card use kiya aur 2012 ky violent protests kay doran 2 bandey bhi mardiye?

 

[Kabira]

Bhol gaye jab choti tind ny punjab card use kiya aur 2012 ky violent protests kay doran 2 bandey bhi mardiye?

I didn't follow politics back then, only after PTI/IK wave. But I doubt they played punjab card.

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

Remember if others want to shut down Nawaz doors in other provinces over ethnic differences then PTI should rename itself as pathan tehrik insaaf. They will not be allowed to do politics in punjab on ethnics. Some other party will take their place.

Pathan tehreek e Insaaf lol
What is ethnic group of Imran? Is he not like attaullah khan niazi speak saraiki?
Imran khan dont seem like ethnic nationalist though have no clue whether he has pashtun nationalist in his party

 

[Kabira]

Pathan tehreek e Insaaf lol
What is ethnic group of Imran? Is he not like attaullah khan niazi speak saraiki?
Imran khan dont seem like ethnic nationalist though have no clue whether he has pashtun nationalist in his party

He's not but PTI social media wing try hard to prove N is ethnic punjabi party and anyone voting for them is same as someone voting for Indian funded traitors like ANP and MQM.

 

[TalhaMoazSarwar]

It's a biggest fight of the century..

 

[Proudpakistaniguy]

He's not but PTI social media wing try hard to prove N is ethnic punjabi party and anyone voting for them is same as someone voting for Indian funded traitors like ANP and MQM.

Let them do this and it will be self destruction
You cannot convince people to vote for PTI by abusing them and insulting their choice of voting. Such hate propaganda and approach will make these people more hardcore supporter of PML (N)

 

[Zibago]

Indian funded traitors like ANP and MQM.

Jindal bhai jan modi kay liye aam leney kay liye bulaye gaye thay kiya ?