What's new

Why Pakistan stands to lose big in trade war with India

.
https://tradingeconomics.com/india/exports/pakistan
India Exports to Pakistan was US$2.35 Billion during 2018, according to the United Nations COMTRADE database on international trade.

https://tradingeconomics.com/pakistan/exports/india
Pakistan Exports to India was US$383.05 Million during 2018, according to the United Nations COMTRADE database on international trade.

India is on the losing side here. No more trade with India.
we have to stop import of indian filth through dubai as well and thats more than official trade. so india will lose good 4-6 bil usd a year trade with Pakistan.
 
. .
https://m.timesofindia.com/india/wh...dia/articleshow/70752104.cms?platform=android

The ongoing trade war between India and Pakistan will hit Islamabad hard as it is dependent on India as far as bilateral trade is concerned
On August 9, Pakistan formally suspended trade relations with India in response to the revocation of the special status of Jammu & Kashmir. In 2018, according to data collated by United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, bilateral trade between India and Pakistan was worth $2.8 billion, of which $2.3 billion was India’s exports to and $500 million its imports from Pakistan.
1. Pakistan is more dependent on India for its exports
Pakistan’s dependence on India is slightly higher than India’s on its neighbour. India’s exports to Pakistan are 0.73% of its total exports while India accounts for 1.62% of Pakistan’s exports.
70754573.jpg


2. Pakistan’s imports from India are five times India’s imports from Pakistan
When it comes to imports, India is even less dependent on Pakistan. In 2018, Pakistan accounted for 0.09% of India’s total imports. India constitutes 3.9% of Pakistan’s total imports.
70754761.jpg


3. One-fifth of India’s cement imports come from Pakistan
Cement is the only good with a significant chunk coming from Pakistan. No other commodity imported from Pakistan is more than 10% of India’s total imports.
70754898.jpg


4. Pakistan is hugely reliant on India for 40 commodities
For 40 commodities, Pakistan’s imports from India constitute more than 10% of its total imports. For 17 of these goods, more than one-fourth of Pakistan’s imports come from India. These commodities are likely to become costlier in Pakistan.
70752734.jpg


5. Trade ban could hit exporters in both India and Pakistan
While an import ban will push up domestic prices, an export ban can hurt domestic producers, who may struggle to find new markets. Pakistan is a big market for India’s animal oils and cotton.
70752719.jpg


6. For 26 goods, more than 10% of Pak’s exports go to India
There are 13 commodities for which more than one-fourth of Pakistan’s total exports go to India and the ban will badly impact its domestic producers.
70756498.jpg


70753408.cms


Pakistan’s actions have backfired before

After the Pulwama terror attack in February and the Balakot strike, Pakistan closed its airspace to Indian flights in retaliation. Though the closure was meant to stifle flights to and from India, it ended up hurting Pakistan considerably.

While airlines lost time and money on rerouting flights, Pakistan lost millions in overflight fees earned when planes pass through foreign airspace. About 400 flights a day avoided Pakistani airspace, resulting in losses of $100 million since the closure, which was lifted on July 12

What is air toll?

Airlines pay civil aviation administration of the country they are flying over a certain fee based on the type of aircraft, the distance covered while overflying a country and the weight of an aircraft before it takes off. For a Boeing 737, Pakistan charges $580. The amount will rise in case of larger aircraft like the Airbus 380 or Boeing 747. The rates differ from one country to another.


I understand Times of India is not considered as a credible source here and the article seemed biased. It uses trade statistics to make its point and I was wondering what the Pakistani members here could share about the points mentioned in the article.

Majority of the media outlets on both sides are guilty of biased reporting and it becomes difficult to get a clearer picture, my purpose for posting this article was to get a clearer picture by listening to what the Pakistani members had to say about it.

Yeah Yeah whatever. There is a trade imbalance between Pakistan and India. Pakistan hardly exports anything to India except for artists and Indians stealing Pakistani lawn prints and designs. There is not much to loose from this so called Trade War.
 
.
https://m.timesofindia.com/india/wh...dia/articleshow/70752104.cms?platform=android

The ongoing trade war between India and Pakistan will hit Islamabad hard as it is dependent on India as far as bilateral trade is concerned
On August 9, Pakistan formally suspended trade relations with India in response to the revocation of the special status of Jammu & Kashmir. In 2018, according to data collated by United Nations Conference on Trade and Development, bilateral trade between India and Pakistan was worth $2.8 billion, of which $2.3 billion was India’s exports to and $500 million its imports from Pakistan.
1. Pakistan is more dependent on India for its exports
Pakistan’s dependence on India is slightly higher than India’s on its neighbour. India’s exports to Pakistan are 0.73% of its total exports while India accounts for 1.62% of Pakistan’s exports.
70754573.jpg


2. Pakistan’s imports from India are five times India’s imports from Pakistan
When it comes to imports, India is even less dependent on Pakistan. In 2018, Pakistan accounted for 0.09% of India’s total imports. India constitutes 3.9% of Pakistan’s total imports.
70754761.jpg


3. One-fifth of India’s cement imports come from Pakistan
Cement is the only good with a significant chunk coming from Pakistan. No other commodity imported from Pakistan is more than 10% of India’s total imports.
70754898.jpg


4. Pakistan is hugely reliant on India for 40 commodities
For 40 commodities, Pakistan’s imports from India constitute more than 10% of its total imports. For 17 of these goods, more than one-fourth of Pakistan’s imports come from India. These commodities are likely to become costlier in Pakistan.
70752734.jpg


5. Trade ban could hit exporters in both India and Pakistan
While an import ban will push up domestic prices, an export ban can hurt domestic producers, who may struggle to find new markets. Pakistan is a big market for India’s animal oils and cotton.
70752719.jpg


6. For 26 goods, more than 10% of Pak’s exports go to India
There are 13 commodities for which more than one-fourth of Pakistan’s total exports go to India and the ban will badly impact its domestic producers.
70756498.jpg


70753408.cms


Pakistan’s actions have backfired before

After the Pulwama terror attack in February and the Balakot strike, Pakistan closed its airspace to Indian flights in retaliation. Though the closure was meant to stifle flights to and from India, it ended up hurting Pakistan considerably.

While airlines lost time and money on rerouting flights, Pakistan lost millions in overflight fees earned when planes pass through foreign airspace. About 400 flights a day avoided Pakistani airspace, resulting in losses of $100 million since the closure, which was lifted on July 12

What is air toll?

Airlines pay civil aviation administration of the country they are flying over a certain fee based on the type of aircraft, the distance covered while overflying a country and the weight of an aircraft before it takes off. For a Boeing 737, Pakistan charges $580. The amount will rise in case of larger aircraft like the Airbus 380 or Boeing 747. The rates differ from one country to another.


I understand Times of India is not considered as a credible source here and the article seemed biased. It uses trade statistics to make its point and I was wondering what the Pakistani members here could share about the points mentioned in the article.

Majority of the media outlets on both sides are guilty of biased reporting and it becomes difficult to get a clearer picture, my purpose for posting this article was to get a clearer picture by listening to what the Pakistani members had to say about it.
The main thing is: India is also exporting things to other countries. If we will not deliver commodities to India, we will supply it to others. So, yeah, worry, but little.
 
.
The ongoing trade war between India and Pakistan will hit Islamabad hard as it is dependent on India as far as bilateral trade
hahahahahaha ......

The idiot who wrote this article does not even know how to manipulate the statistics ..... his efforts are such amateurish that the very first comparative graph (in terms of %) posted in the article is giving definitive $ figures of trade as well
70754573.jpg

Now just tell how any person with little bit of commonsense would believe that $383 million of Pakistani exports to India is bigger to $2.345 million of Indian exports to Pakistan ..... ????

And Pakistan will be a bigger loser in bilateral trade with India ..... ????

----------------------------------------------------
Unfortunately comments of Pakistani members are showing they didn't read the article properly .... and they are so gullible that a headline of an article can distract them from reality .....
 
Last edited:
.
How so?
The first priority for PM IK was to financially secure your country, it remains true even today. Ideals are often the first casualty before pragmatic measures set in.


I suggest you read the last two paragraphs
You are right Finance was our first priority but them your Modi came up with the idea of genocide in Kashmir, so we changed our priority (we can always change our priority if your Modi jee does something as stupid as this cant we ?) so now we will sort you out first then we will focus on financial situation, any doubt ?
 
.
You are right Finance was our first priority but them your Modi came up with the idea of genocide in Kashmir, so we changed our priority (we can always change our priority if your Modi jee does something as stupid as this cant we ?) so now we will sort you out first then we will focus on financial situation, any doubt ?
Ofcourse, it's entirely GoP's prerogative how it handles it's finances, but financial constraints directly affect actionable options.
 
.
But but, Pakistan was biggest market for Indian products and we were so dependent. What happened to those claims or either this is yet another Chanakya spanner? BTW last time when Pakistan closed airspace, Indian figures were far bigger than Pakistani losses.



Care to elaborate?

upload_2019-8-23_7-28-37.png


How so?
The first priority for PM IK was to financially secure your country, it remains true even today. Ideals are often the first casualty before pragmatic measures set in.

When there is Economic superpower China supporting Pakistan why care about trade with India?
 
.
Back
Top Bottom