Why Kerala has no beef with beef.

[Dubious]

I was going to reply to you the other day, I had typed it and then deleted. But now looking at your comments again I would like to know what are your basis to give statements about Prophet Muhammad S.A.W? How much research did you do on Muhammad S.A.W and what is your source(s)?

What do you know about his childhood? What do you know about His (PBUH) pre prophet hood life? What is your definition of meditation? How he was different from his own people he lived among? Do you even have the slightest idea what is the difference between a messenger and a prophet? What do you know about orders He (PBUH) he got and followed from Quran and lead by example? Please give individual answers to my questions.

@Akheilos @TankMan @syedali73 (sorry I am tagging you, but this guy should have been stopped from carrying this argument to other non relevant threads the other day.)

Hit the report button

 

[Screambowl]

I was going to reply to you the other day, I had typed it and then deleted. But now looking at your comments again I would like to know what are your basis to give statements about Prophet Muhammad S.A.W? How much research did you do on Muhammad S.A.W and what is your source(s)?

What do you know about his childhood? What do you know about His (PBUH) pre prophet hood life? What is your definition of meditation? How he was different from his own people he lived among? Do you even have the slightest idea what is the difference between a messenger and a prophet? What do you know about orders He (PBUH) he got and followed from Quran and lead by example? Please give individual answers to my questions.

@Akheilos @TankMan @syedali73 (sorry I am tagging you, but this guy should have been stopped from carrying this argument to other non relevant threads the other day.)

This is not a thread to discuss this. I discussed this on other thread where it was meant to be discussed . My post was to @MokshaVimukthi regarding different philosophies of Hinduism and I quoted advaita vedanta which is the basis of one God theology. And hence my answer to @Rain Man that IF the ideology is similar then it won't affect if you ban idol worship. We were discussing that. Not something else and hence you proved me correct that ideology is not same.

Ghar Wapsi ............ are you guys planing to settle in Germany ?

nahi.. i will settle in India. after few years

 

[cybertron]

Nammde swanthammm B.D.F - Beef Dry Fry

 

[SarthakGanguly]

I just wish you had used your knowledge about hinduism in the right direction...I wish.

I also believed the same. But cowards like us won't get what he would be saying anyway.

??
I know that for hindutvawadis like you it is hard to accept that

4)the Supreme Court in the past has held "A total ban [on cattle slaughter] was not permissible if, under economic conditions, keeping useless cattle be a burden on the society and therefore not in the public interest."
So in how many states and for how long will you get beef banned??

Trivia:
cricket which is arguably the most popular sport in India does use cow skin leather in making the cricket ball.
Get cricket banned now!!
Plsss!!

I just wish you had used your knowledge about hinduism in the right direction...I wish.

I also used to believe the same. But cowards like us won't get what he would be saying anyway.

lev - Why are you lying and trolling deliberately? I told you before what the Supreme Court stated. Picking what suits your fancy from the middle is lame.

 

[Wine&Steak]

Nope. You guys are not too clever or cunning. Just plain stupid. Land which has been constructed on is degraded land and cannot go back to agriculture. Given your population pressure and the builtup, agriculture is practically over as far as Kerala is concerned. If what @SpArK says is true, agriculture is dying there even now. So that option wont be available for you and given that your state is not industrially developed nor agriculturally sustainable, hope Arab oil prices zoom sky high again to keep pushing Kerala economy.

you don't know anything about Kerala. All you know is the "brownie scoring" comments about Kerala from RSS comrades in Kerala. heard about tourism ? Kerala's population is declining, hence workers are imported from North India.

Which state do you belong to ?

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Well throughout the history, i have read about how kshatriyas ( who are not hindus?????) hunted animals like deer and tiger...

Of course they did. They do today as well. Just not cows. Never the cows.

 

[cybertron]

Kerala Beef Curry - yummm!!

 

[I.R.A]

This is not a thread to discuss this. I discussed this on other thread where it was meant to be discussed . My post was to @MokshaVimukthi regarding different philosophies of Hinduism and I quoted advaita vedanta which is the basis of one God theology. And hence my answer to @Rain Man that IF the ideology is similar then it won't affect if you ban idol worship. We were discussing that. Not something else and hence you proved me correct that ideology is not same.

You should have refrained from citing Islam and Prophet (PBUH) here. It is totally totally irrelevant. I don't discuss Hinduism with Muslims or quote Hinduism teachings as examples to my fellow Muslims.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

This thread has served it purpose, Beef will be available in plenty across kerala. Similarly pork also will be available across Kerala.

Those who eat beef (including hindu's) will keep eating beef.
Those who eat pork also (including hindu's) will keep eating beef.

Kerala will be a secular state, u like it or not

All of that will be history. It never happened.

You should have refrained from citing Islam and Prophet (PBUH) here. It is totally totally irrelevant. I don't discuss Hinduism with Muslims or quote Hinduism teachings as examples to my fellow Muslims.

Ignore some posts. Will keep you well. Howdy by the way?

 

[Screambowl]

You should have refrained from citing Islam and Prophet (PBUH) here. It is totally totally irrelevant. I don't discuss Hinduism with Muslims or quote Hinduism teachings as examples to my fellow Muslims.

I was asked by one of the members that idol worship is haram so ban idol worship too, according to religious tolerance. Then I counter questioned, that this is also not allowed during Gyan Yog or Raj yog, and I equated this with Mohammed's meditation in cave Hira. Please read the post again.

And I can discuss Islam with Indian Muslims here, you have no authority to guide terms to me. If there is any thing they find wrong they will tell me, you need not to preach.

 

[dray]

1. It has a caste system where cow eaters get thrown out of the caste. This can be validated both through history as well as scriptures.
2. It was only to that argument I replied.
3. If it was a dressing style or a housing style or whatever, I do not think Hindus would have cared much about differences. But this is a matter of a living being. A being very dear to us. You cannot compare it with secular stuff.

1. Sangh don't believe in caste, aren't you contradicting Mohan Bhagwat?

2. Caste is fixed anyway, you don't go up and down the ladder, and who can send you up and down? There is nobody to decide that.

3. Don't say 'Hindus', you don't represent all Hindus, neither the sangh.

btw, the biggest cow trade happens through Bangladesh border, the figures are actually in millions, and guess what, most of the cows and bulls come from the 'cow belt' of India, claimed to be sangh's own turf.

Strawman. Irrelevant noise.

You want to tag me, quote me.

You said "Then don't be a Hindu. No one is forcing you to be one", and I replied "How not to be a Hindu"? Got it?

and that logical argument extended to banning islam too.

And further extends to banning all religions, including Hinduism.

The only alternative to that is vigilante justice.

In others words, you want goons to protect Hinduism.

 

[TankMan]

I was going to reply to you the other day, I had typed it and then deleted. But now looking at your comments again I would like to know what are your basis to give statements about Prophet Muhammad S.A.W? How much research did you do on Muhammad S.A.W and what is your source(s)?

What do you know about his childhood? What do you know about His (PBUH) pre prophet hood life? What is your definition of meditation? How he was different from his own people he lived among? Do you even have the slightest idea what is the difference between a messenger and a prophet? What do you know about orders He (PBUH) he got and followed from Quran and lead by example? Please give individual answers to my questions.

@Akheilos @TankMan @syedali73 (sorry I am tagging you, but this guy should have been stopped from carrying this argument to other non relevant threads the other day.)

@Screambowl I thought we ended this here: Islam from the eyes of another | Page 4
If you want to continue it, do it in that thread.
I'm just going to quote what I said there:

All that is your theory, from books Islam doesn't recognize as authentic mixed together by you to support your own preconceived ideas.
You can believe whatever you want to believe but those arguments aren't going to convince, impress or even annoy anyone, nevermind an actual scholar.

As for the beef - an interesting article, well written. But the conclusion doesn't really answer why there is no beef with beef in Kerala - how did cultural osmosis and taste overcome the factors that cause a beef with beef in other states? I suppose it isn't intended to be an in-depth article, but some explanation would've been nice.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

I was asked by one of the members that idol worship is haram so ban idol worship too, according to religious tolerance. Then I counter questioned, that this is also not allowed during Gyan Yog or Raj yog, and I equated this with Mohammed's meditation in cave Hira. Please read the post again.

And I can discuss Islam with Indian Muslims here, you have no authority to guide terms to me. If there is any thing they find wrong they will tell me, you need not to preach.

Chill. He is from a different country. No point in searching for enemies in other countries when you have more than enough in your own.

 

[I.R.A]

Ignore some posts. Will keep you well. Howdy by the way?

I am doing good sir how is you?

I now ignore almost all posts on this forum, just look for some funny comment and that makes my day. This poster is to be taken seriously because he is totally wrong in his understanding about Prophet (PBUH).

 

[cybertron]

Of course they did. They do today as well. Just not cows. Never the cows.

Haha...you guys never give in, do you.
Onto the Valmiki passages:

• Sita promising Ganga meat-rice on safe return:

From Ayodhya Kandam:52: As Sita crosses Ganga she promises to Ganga what she will offer on safe return: “thousand pots of spirituous liquor and jellied meat with cooked rice”

Valmiki Ramayana - Ayodhya Kanda

suraaghaTasahasreNa maamsabhuutodanena cha |
yakshye tvaam prayataa devi puriim punarupaagataa || 2-52-89

89. devii= “Oh, goddess! Upaagata= After reaching; puriim= the city (Ayodhya); punaH= again; yakshhye= I shall worship (you); suraaghata sahasreNa= with thousand pots of spirituous liquor; maamsa bhuutodanena cha = and jellied meat with cooked rice; prayataa= well-prepared for the solemn rite.”

“Oh, goddess! After reaching back the city of Ayodhya, I shall worship you with thousand pots of spirituous liquor and jellied meat with cooked rice well prepared for the solemn rite.”