What's new

Why Karachi is unmanageable?

aliahmadtuff

FULL MEMBER

New Recruit

Joined
Aug 21, 2019
Messages
18
Reaction score
0
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
It is an Irony which nations commercial heart that ought to have been cared for as an advantage as it provides over 70 per cent earnings to the remainder of Pakistan has already been dubbed as the town of crap or just like solid waste management.

It is the time that the centre Sindh and the city authorities have to come out of the blame game shape an apex committee for both Karachi and attempt to provide a while without this town is crucial for growth the longer you provide. you need to quit taking a look at the town with biased outlook and also vision.

Dr Hafeez shaikh Thursday declared two jobs for Karachi values rs95 billion. sounds great on paper but when decades-old jobs like karachi mass transit stays only in document or lyari expressway that required decades for the present green lane bus had taken a long time to finish or for that thing k-iv like strategies no doubt that the 2 jobs declared by shaikh sb will be finished and that too long.delays in schemes multiply the problems rather than resolving them.

Large schemes led to the commission that was enormous and corruption.karachi encroached in any way levels and nobody is about to clean the wreck. option is there given anyone was prepared to listento. you might get all sort of mafias.among the issues of karachi is the population mismanagement in any way levels. its my view also to some extent un-controllable because nobody chooses its possession and seemed serious and that this town of potential is.

The town is split into KMC which regulates 24 per cent of town cantonment board and DHA together with some 30 bureaus. following 2013 bodies program the governments energy was decreased which resulted in a different argument that has to do with energy consumption and politics. local bodies elections must be kept for city and theres not anything wrong if weve got direct election of mayor. the entire city must have its own authorities and commissionerate in which men and women should be workers irrespective of cast or creed.

One expects the DHA and cantonment board might not oppose a board system. there ought to be aaccountability mechanism as jobs or in pockets. there is corruption in the top to bottom in all of the civic bodies. corruption may be found by you in every job which is only one of the reasons.it is ironic that a desalination plant nearbydo-darya that found and should have been finished in 2006 with a price tag of 100 million couldnt have removed has anybody made liable. the response is no.

If we wish to provide the folks with some aid there ought to be a functioning type of solution to every issue pertaining to power water distribution gas and building organization. among the citys biggest problems is that the menace ofkatchi abadi. the notion was conceived back in the title of home strategies which ought to happen to be a way and commendable for the man by bureaucrats into the 60s.

Following the influx of people with no preparation and direction bureaucracy and the governments encouraged people to settle through illegal ways in regions that were suburban.there are a few bases with approximately five thousand people. rather than opting for housing schemes settlements encouraged and after regularised a number of these to find political mileage. whats the most wonderful part of this is the simple fact that in none of the five big master programs made for your town the idea ofkatchi abadis never is different meaning that the town hasnt been developed or enlarged in line with the master program.

Now who supplied them all sort of connections that are illegal methods whether its water electricity or gas. karachi never needed any people management program and its never enforced if theres one. second due to prejudice and the political strategy justice hasnt yet been done together with the town at the population census. virtually all parties if those judgment or in opposition possess a consensus that injustice was done. a few petitions are pending at the courtroom.

How do you organize the town without knowing its inhabitants throughout the previous census it had been shown by NADRA resources which there are several four million aliens. karachi previously had this system enhanced rather than abolishing it and had ways of transportation the governments wouldnt have been confronting the challenges of bringing tens of thousands of buses or hammering the railroad.

A transport mafia with assistance from non-political and governmental elite generates barriers in the method for the transportation system. thus decades-old buses moreover auto rickshaws or taxis have controlled or handled transport. the taxation system that was personal brought any relief to some degree to the middle class and middle class households. folks will still continue to endure until the city is supplied an entire transport bundle and its railway not restored.back in 1984 one of the primary transport companies from japan had indicated size buses and an agreement was reached however the effort was foiled by also the bureaucrats.

Karachi has difficulty with water supply instead. if you ask people linked with kw&sb youd acquire stories as they supply links and make crisis. after all from the water crisis distribution is got by us therefore provided that the town been enlarged and develops within a ill- planned fashion of water connections will likely last and every year will confront called water catastrophe. the land supply of this town and illegal structure caused destruction tens of thousands and thousands of plots and locations were converted to places and plazas. all of these were awarded relations of gas electricity and water. sindh board of revenueruined the town by selling land.

Encroachment is just one of the problems in town. half of towns transportation problem was due to poorly constructed streets except a few of the recently assembled and occupied service streets by road restaurants and parking mafia. as scenario stand karachi is equally ungovernable and un-manageable. by turning consensus it took a few choices. now is the time to avoid any burst by fixing and defusing the problem in its true perspective although situation is volatile.

Source: Why Karachi is unmanageable?
 
Karachi is officially a "failed" city
It's administratively broken

The city has been running on , ad hoc basis for last 15-20 years


  • City Need to be divided into 10 Zones , each zone having it's own Junior Mayor / Administrator
  • Every one reporting to City Mayor
  • Each zone Administrator should be given $$ Budget and Right to select contractors
  • Each zone should be allowed to employ Private Security who works closely with Police
  • City Mayor , should appoint his 10 Junior Administrators to look after parts of city
  • Each City zone should be given budget for
a) Parks b) Road paving c) Tree Plantation d) Trash Collection e) Graffiti removal
f) Transport Bus Purchase​

* 10 Year Prison Term for corruption applicable to Mayor / Admin roles if city money is
redirected to private accounts or Bribe is taken


Need 1 Scrap metal recovery Unit from trash
Need 1 Trash burning factory built with local man power
Need 400-500 Trash Collector trucks & 5,000 Labor force who operate machinery
Need 400 Vaccum Truck Units pick up excessive dust
Federal Authorized Budget
1 Mayor
10 City Zone Administrators
10 Road Paving Contractor Company (Refreshing Roads)
20,000 Tree planters (Basic Laborers)
20,000 Grafiti Remover Painters (Basic Laborers)
400 City Buses Imported
 
Last edited:
Karachi is officially a "failed" city
It's administratively broken

The city has been running on , ad hoc basis for last 15-20 years


  • City Need to be divided into 10 Zones , each zone having it's own Junior Mayor / Administrator
  • Every one reporting to City Mayor
  • Each zone Administrator should be given $$ Budget and Right to select contractors
  • Each zone should be allowed to employ Private Security who works closely with Police
  • City Mayor , should appoint his 10 Junior Administrators to look after parts of city
  • Each City zone should be given budget for
a) Parks b) Road paving c) Tree Plantation d) Trash Collection e) Graffiti removal
f) Transport Bus Purchase​

* 10 Year Prison Term for corruption applicable to Mayor / Admin roles if city money is
redirected to private accounts or Bribe is taken

You'll have to generate revenue first to support these initiatives.

Congestion charges upon entering main city thoroughfares - PKR 1000 for cars and PKR 100 for bikes (could be scheduled for night / day / peak / off peak hours
Every household should be charged PKR 5000 per month for municipal services (mandatory)

amongst many more.
 
There is a Federal Special Package budget given by Prime Minister Imran Khan for Karachi , their should be no excuse , plus their is also Sindh yearly budget in billions of Dollar

Sindh Budget 2019-2020
https://tribune.com.pk/story/199257...s1217b-provincial-budget-next-financial-year/

RS 1,200,000,000,000 (1.2 Trillion Rupee)

7.6 Billion Dollars :coffee::smokin: Big money people big money


Special Package for Karachi RS 162,000,000,000 (162 Billion Rupee)

1 Billion Dollars :smokin::pop: No pocket change folks .....:big_boss: Big money
 
Last edited:
You'll have to generate revenue first to support these initiatives.

Congestion charges upon entering main city thoroughfares - PKR 1000 for cars and PKR 100 for bikes (could be scheduled for night / day / peak / off peak hours
Every household should be charged PKR 5000 per month for municipal services (mandatory)

amongst many more.

You're out of your mind on those charges. Just because we have money doesn't mean every single other household is well off as well.

All the current administrators and government officials responsible for the city should be booked and jailed.
 
You're out of your mind on those charges. Just because we have money doesn't mean every single other household is well off as well.
All the current administrators and government officials responsible for the city should be booked and jailed.
Probably. Only way to get people to use public transport instead of wasting fuel in a car which will transport only one single person.
 
their is encroachment on every street of karachi, khi a low line has natural channels to dumb rain water into the sea but even those channels have been encroached and their bellies narrowed and then their is issue of plastic bags thats clogging the swerage system lack of management,law and planning and yes greed and partnership btw law enfrocement agencies and criminal mafias!
 
2019-2020

Sindh Budget 7.6 Billion Dollar
Government Top up Special Package for Karachi 1 Billion Dollar Extra


Now if you can't fix the garbage and city issues , that is just sad

Imran Khan , Prime Minister has released the funds to Sindh and also to Karachi now it is up to the local bodies to show their performance

  • If Private Cleaning contractor company was given 50 Million dollar they would have cleaned up karachi with Local Cheap Labor force

If performance is not visible Federal Government should ask for Audit of where the money has been spent since it was allocated
 
@newb3e what you think why Karachi is unmanageable at least here you can't say Imran Khan and Usman Buzdar are responsible responsible for this
Because jab Imran Khan ka prime minister bannay ka koi chance bhi nahi that tab bhi Karachi aisa hi tha
 
Probably. Only way to get people to use public transport instead of wasting fuel in a car which will transport only one single person.

Then start by providing good public transport first then. People cry about use of Lahore Metro Train but a transport like that, Karachi is dying for at the moment.
 
its not unmanageable Pakistanis are just incompetent buffoons
 
@newb3e what you think why Karachi is unmanageable at least here you can't say Imran Khan and Usman Buzdar are responsible responsible for this
Because jab Imran Khan ka prime minister bannay ka koi chance bhi nahi that tab bhi Karachi aisa hi tha

Karachi voted for PTI and gave them seats, there should be a sense of responsibility on PTI at least. That's the most grieving part.
 
@newb3e what you think why Karachi is unmanageable at least here you can't say Imran Khan and Usman Buzdar are responsible responsible for this
Because jab Imran Khan ka prime minister bannay ka koi chance bhi nahi that tab bhi Karachi aisa hi tha


lawlessness , protection of criminals and criminal activities by Law enfrocement agencies , greed ,"Maslihat"


criminals were selected to sit on throne of sindh karachi law enfrocement agencies became their puppet because they were making good money in the prcoess their was no considerstion for human life or rule of law Karachi was more like FATA where mafias instead of tribes were runningthe show ab may details may jaon ga jazbati log traitor ka label laga dain gay!
 
Karachi voted for PTI and gave them seats, there should be a sense of responsibility on PTI at least. That's the most grieving part.
Unfortunately PTI isn't in power there; can't do jack about Karachi if they don't have power.

Then start by providing good public transport first then. People cry about use of Lahore Metro Train but a transport like that, Karachi is dying for at the moment.
Sindh government is to blame. They're the ones who'll have to rectify administrative problems. If they can't; they simply should resign and ask the Federal governement to take over.
 
Back
Top Bottom