Why is there no formal military alliance between all Arab countries?

[Azadkashmir]

ITS A CURSE FROM GOD WHEN THEY BETRAYED THEIR PRINCIPLES OVER THROW OF KHALIFAT STATE.

 

[TNT]

You need to look back, these countries were made in order to divide the ottoman empire. The west divided these areas among their lackeys, every lackey was made a king. Since that time, these countries are under dictatorships or monarchies who are loyal servants of the west.
The people of the arab world never have had a say in their politics or governance.

 

[Hussain93]

Because cleanshave dirty western educated lackeys of west are at the helm of affairs in Arab nation.
Give to mullahs ,be they shia or sunni they will see the bigger danger to ummah are act accordingly. When Morsi was in power he was very much pro Iran and was open to coooperate because religious folks are smart unlike dirty colonial inplanted cleanshaves who kill and destroy their own population. Just to remain in power.

 

[Corruptistan]

The opinions of my countrymen are the result of lack of knowledge of this topic.

Ottoman involvement in the Arab world is a tiny footnote in the long history of the Arab world and moreover most of the Arab world was never a part of the Ottomans and all the Arab lands under Ottoman jurisdiction were ruled by local rulers, many of the dynasties that rule today ruled back then as well as before 1517. There is a reason why there were never any Arab-Ottoman wars post-1517 outside of Yemen and until the succesful Arab revolt when the Ottoman Empire was already collapsing from within for ages.

No need to do something that already exists

Can you explain. Has the Arab League evolved into a military alliance or are you talking about well-known Arab alliances between Arab states?

Why has the Arab League not evolved into a EU-like institution ages ago? It is a relatively simple question and such a thing would only have benefitted the Arab world. The political fragmentation is a genuine cause of concern that has lead to actual conflicts. Syria, Libya and Yemen are exampels of this.

 

[Hydration]

Can you explain. Has the Arab League evolved into a military alliance or are you talking about well-known Arab alliances between Arab states?

Why has the Arab League not evolved into a EU-like institution ages ago? It is a relatively simple question and such a thing would only have benefitted the Arab world. The political fragmentation is a genuine cause of concern that has lead to actual conflicts. Syria, Libya and Yemen are exampels of this.

Theres already economic support from GCC to Egypt in the form of investments
If the gulf is threatned Egypt will intervene
Also intelligence integration as well and high level of COOP
Iraq and jordan are set to follow a similair policy and expand to other arab countries in the future once theyre stable

Because cleanshave dirty western educated lackeys of west are at the helm of affairs in Arab nation.
Give to mullahs ,be they shia or sunni they will see the bigger danger to ummah are act accordingly. When Morsi was in power he was very much pro Iran and was open to coooperate because religious folks are smart unlike dirty colonial inplanted cleanshaves who kill and destroy their own population. Just to remain in power.

Shut up

 

[Corruptistan]

Theres already economic support from GCC to Egypt in the form of investments
If the gulf is threatned Egypt will intervene
Also intelligence integration as well and high level of COOP
Iraq and jordan are set to follow a similair policy and expand to other arab countries in the future once theyre stable

Insha'Allah. There is already the GCC (KSA, UAE, Oman, Kuwait, Qatar, Bahrain). Once peace emerges in Yemen, Yemen will naturally align with the GCC. Jordan is formally allied with the GCC. Iraq will join its Arab family as well eventually like historically was the case. Syria likely too once the Al-Assad regime is gone. Palestine as well. Egypt is already part of this family as you wrote. Sudan too. Libya will naturally as well join this family. Morocco is already a part of this as is Mauritania.

Algeria and Tunisia are dark horses but the current government in Tunisia seems to be allied with this Arab bloc.

Anyway what I am talking about is for the Arab League to evolve into a FORMAL Arab military alliance as well and expand into an EU-like organization. Full economic, military etc. integration is needed.

 

[mulj]

Simply because they are umder firm control of collonial heritage and artifical non natural states and borders like in Gulf especially, for example all countries below and left of turkish/iranian borders should be one organized state. Similar thing in North africa, Morroco/Algier/Tunisia should be one state as well as Lybia/Egypt/Sudan.

 

[Hydration]

Insha'Allah. There is already the GCC (KSA, UAE, Oman, Kuwait, Qatar, Bahrain). Once peace emerges in Yemen, Yemen will naturally align with the GCC. Jordan is formally allied with the GCC. Iraq will join its Arab family as well eventually like historically was the case. Syria likely too once the Al-Assad regime is gone. Palestine as well. Egypt is already part of this family as you wrote. Sudan too. Libya will naturally as well join this family. Morocco is already a part of this as is Mauritania.

Algeria and Tunisia are dark horses but the current government in Tunisia seems to be allied with this Arab bloc.

Anyway what I am talking about is for the Arab League to evolve into a FORMAL Arab military alliance as well and expand into an EU-like organization. Full economic, military etc. integration is needed.

well thats for the future
it wont happen due to some countries have differences with others and we simply cant isolate them
like we cant add morroco in its current conflict with Algeria
Once they settle down we can expand but i dont think this formal alliance will happen anytime soon

 

[The SC]

I agree but Arabs are the extreme example of wasted talents and opportunities. It is actually criminal.

For starters why the hell do countries such as Kuwait, Qatar, UAE, Bahrain even exist as separate entities in 2022? Why have the GCC not merged into 1 single federal state ages ago? If they had done that it would be a top 10 economy and top 15-20 population by now in the world.

Sure, once not long ago Europe was divided into 1000's of political entities, Germany and Italy alone were composed of numerous city-states, principalities, kingdoms, duchies whatever but yet they correctly united and put their differences aside. Often that occurred when 1 party among them overruled the others.

Or even a better example would be South Asia. If this policy had continued what is today Pakistan would be divided into 30 + entities and India into 1000's.

To me it seems (when reading about contemporary history) that the West (being a direct neighbor of the Arab world) is doing everything in their power in order to create divisions within the Muslim world (we are not helping ourselves in this regard by creating themselves as well) and the rulers/dictators/whatever you want to call them, are also working alongside this policy in order to keep their thrones intact.

Unity is strength.

There is one fact that most outsiders to the Arab world don't know about.. it is called The "O'rouba Soul" or Rouh El O'rouba that concerns the MENA region in its entirety.. it is somehow like a latent hidden coalition..In North Africa, Algeria is the only black cheep..but just as far as Morocco is concerned, and don't be surprised to see them fighting side by side if let's say Saudi Arabia or Egypt get involved in a conflict.. Syria and Iraq were out of the equation,, but are coming back..

The only other special case is Yemen..and that is due to its own internal conflict..

 

[Corruptistan]

The Arab family won't become a reality unless America is kicked out of the region, as long as foreigners will retain the role of security brokers there will always be resistance. And you're being too optimistic about Iraq, Yemen, Palestine, Syria and Libya. There's a lot of bad blood here that won't just disappear. The only family right now is the lackeys of America in the region. Gulf and Saudis and their Israeli cousin.

Security brokers of what? Arabs have no regional enemies, lol. No regional actors are strong enough (even remotely) to take all Arabs on head on. They are all heavily outnumbered in terms of population, economics, military power, geography, resources, religious, cultural, linguistic influence, alliances etc.

The bad blood is mostly local and will eventual disappear. At the end of the day they are brothers and sisters that share everything in common.

Obviously Arab cooperation and unity is a cause of butthurt for certain followers, this is all well-known but unfortunately for them, I think this development is inevitable.

Outside of Zionism and Israeli oppression of Palestinians, Jews and Judaism are the closest people to Muslims and Islam. Non-anti-Muslim Jews are talented people and Arab-Jewish cooperation is only a good thing for the region if it leads to permanent peace and cooperation like throughout much of Islamic history.

 

[Goritoes]

Disunity among the Ummah and downfall of Muslims was foretold by Rasool Allah, these modern states and their leaders whether within their conscious minds or unconsciously doing what Allah had planned, I know people won't believe me when I say this is still a good time for Muslims, and the worse is yet to come.

 

[Beny Karachun]

For the same reason there's no world peace.

 

[The SC]

What's the purpose of American bases in the region if the dynasties don't need any protection?

We live in an era of nationalism, pan-Arabism was something that was tried in the past with the unification of Syria and Egypt. It has lost popularity now. There will be no Arab Nato or Eu.

There is better than an Arab "NATO" .. It is called the Soul of Arabism.. it goes from Iraq to Morocco,, with a population mass of around 500 million people.. this is a fact, despite what external views are.. and don't get me wrong.. this mass will also mobilize if Islam is threatened.. because it is its key motivation of this Arabism.. in the first place..

 

[PakFactor]

it is called The "O'rouba Soul" or Rouh El O'rouba that concerns the MENA region in its entirety..

What is that? Never heard of this term before.

 

[The SC]

where's the headquarter located? in my heart is not the right answer.

Your heart is not part of it at this level.. this is on the Arab hearts only.. so we can understand you.. just read my post before this one.. post # 30..

What is that? Never heard of this term before.

Of course..since you're not An Arab..it is normal..