Why India Deported U.S. Researcher Working on Amnesty Report on Kashmir?

[punit]

she was not teaching she was just investigating and writing.. an Indian has every right to investigate and report about race riot in USA for example...

really ! try ur luck .

 

[saurav]

Break the law..? Get kicked out...

 

[Guynextdoor2]

I agree, AFSPA should be removed. Lot of innocent people died due to it.

I think it's better left for the Army to decide. Let's not get too idealistic here.

 

[MilSpec]

I agree, AFSPA should be removed. Lot of innocent people died due to it.

Not until the threat of state sponsored terrorism looms in states where it exists.

 

[Guynextdoor2]

@Norwegian there is a 'real world' where people have to live in

 

[SrNair]

India is becoming more and more like Israel. Stop being so autocratic and take criticism like a man. Grow up!

Mr @Norwegian.
We are a democracy and we have a lots if NGOS in here under the leadership of eminent personalities like Aruna Roy,Medha Patkar.
We dont need foreign help to protect our laws.

And AFSPA is not a nation wide law.Recently Tripura kicked out that law because their is no problem in there.
Our Country ,Our law .
Those who cant obey that dont need to visit this nation.

 

[kakathiya]

what if we indians speak about the brutalities committed by pak army on balochi women and men aswell as the atrocities on sindhi population not to mention about FATA, and how the pakistanis are ethnic cleansing the baltistan population because they are shias,

 

[Mo12]

Maybe it was to protect her from terrorist from Pakistan illegally enter India Kashmir.

 

[kakathiya]

and india should report and also discuss the atrocities committed by american army in japan, vietnam, iraq, afghanistan, syria and guantanamo bay, as well as secret prisons in the balkans, as well as the atrocities committed by the american government on the black population of america, about the private mercinary armies of america who are illegally fighting in foreign countries, and about creating terrorists like osama bin laden who in turn f*cked america, and now they have created ISIS, and the taliban was created by american govt, why did the americans drop the nuke bomb on japan instead of germany, only because the japs were bhuddists, and asians, christian prejudice,

 

[kurup]

Why was Amnesty even allowed into Kashmir the first place ?

 

[dray]

classic duplicity of Indian army, cant get out of kashmir and creates fake encounter to legitimize further stay.. its like the friend who has overstayed, eats all your food from your fridge, and wont give your remote.
even Indian govt and their interlocutors in kashmir agree, the tide of militancy has turned in kashmir.

Awesome! Those men and women in uniform putting themselves in the line of fire without caring for their lives and their family to protect you and your family just needed this kind of encouragement.

 

[VCheng]

But Pakistan never de-ported anyone.......

Anyone? How about Declan Walsh and Christine Fair?

Come on you really think almost any Pakistani member will look to AI report on Pakistan and criticize their country, they are more interested in other country affairs.

If one likes what AI says about India, one should also pay attention to what it says about Pakistan.

 

[Ray_of_Hope]

Anyone? How about Declan Walsh and Christine Fair?

My post was in relation to human rights issues.....And yes no journalist has ever been deported from Pakistan for working on human rights issues in pakistan.......And Declan Walsh....He was`nt working on human rights.....He was deported due to some unknown issues(probably anti state or some other undesirable activities)

 

[Echo_419]

India is becoming more and more like Israel. Stop being so autocratic and take criticism like a man. Grow up!

Kashmir is a different case altogether
Any views as opposed to ours will be crushed with a iron fist

 

[Razia Sultana]

When I am out to find fault with others, I must ensure that i am not caught off guard. Its unfortunate that the amnesty researcher could not complete her work. But I have also come across some journalists who were investigating some big stories basis some hypotheses and when at the end of their invetigation nothing spicy came out, they did something odd to get their investigations stopped. Thats how they saved their face and jobs. I wish Amnesty International carries out the research left half way by Ms. Mehta by their other employees/agents so that the truth comes out. Amnesty has reported several cases of human rights violation in India and there are many other indigenous NGOs who work for human rights and Amnesty can engage them as well. Amnesty is an institution, they can always replace the researcher by another.