USA is a secular country and should not make foreign policy based on religious views. If USA policy makers are not pragmatic then they can only blame themselves for decline.
Israel is an apartheid nation with little in common with the USA style democracy. Arab countries are far more strategically important on the global chess board. Israel is not a meaningful military base for USA ops in the MENA.
One can argue that KSA's support for the petro-dollar, China's tilt toward the USA (after the Nixon visit), and Pakistan's draining of the USSR in Afghanistan were all critical for the USA to winning cold war one. All these countries are now villainized in America. Discarded after their perceived usefulness was up.
It should not be a surprise if Europe, MENA, most of Asia, Africa, and Latin America remain neutral in cold war two.
Idiotic USA think tanks are now obsessed with building a team of scrubs for cold war two.
Israel (a country fighting over less and less territory ever day), India (a country were a third of its citizens don't have toilets), Japan (a country that's population decline is so rapid it could be extinct in a few decades), and the Anglo remnants UK, Australia (probably the must useful of the bunch).
Unless some major changes happen in strategic thinking, I am not very optimistic for USA chances in cold war 2.