Who's killing India's Secularism?

[salarsikander]

You think from a medieval point of view of Hindu rule and Muslim rule.

Workings of secular rule through modern democracy is beyond your capacity of imagination.

To answer your allegations that Muslims do not get respect from Hindus . Please see case of A P J Abdul Kalam ,he is the role model of every Indian be it Hindu or Muslim.

So brother,you tried your best to instigate Indian Muslims on Kashmir and what you get from @adil_minhas .. " Das Boot " please don't forget that.

I didn't provoke nothing first of all nor I need to
If anything adil minhas is the one crying and bitching not me. I am merely saying that there's nonuse when you had the chance you guys didn't leave so deal with it !

Spare the APJ rhetoric. The Gujarat riots the current situation of kashmir , the lynching over beef, Amir khan and Bollywood actors expressing fear, hell even major had to clarify what she was eating alone shows who gets respected and what not. Noob

We are not interested to take lessons from Islam on how to treat people.

The wars since inception do not inspire confidence.

BS
From Gandhar to Kashmir, from Bodhgaya to Nalanda, Islam's gifts to Buddhism is well documented.

You cannot just dismiss what happens to lower cast, evil brahmin

 

[SarthakGanguly]

You cannot just dismiss what happens to lower cast, evil brahmin

I don't. We are not perfect. We have problems. We have been solving them for centuries now.

 

[kathiyawadi khamir]

The Gujarat riots the current situation of kashmir ,

well, i cant call you Pakistani because you are an South Indian. but do you have any proof that Muslims were killed in Gujarat riots ?

 

[The_Showstopper]

We are not interested to take lessons from Islam on how to treat people.

The wars since inception do not inspire confidence.

Is that legitimized in scriptures? Well unlike Hindu scriptures where this subjugation is authenticated and legitimized, I don't find this in Quran.

BS
From Gandhar to Kashmir, from Bodhgaya to Nalanda, Islam's gifts to Buddhism is well documented.

Well documented? Are you suggesting Pushyamitra or Mihirkula? Their names don't sound Islamic.

 

[salarsikander]

well, i cant call you Pakistani because you are an South Indian. but do you have any proof that Muslims were killed in Gujarat riots ?

Call me anything but Indian and that too south. I have nothing domwith ganga people.

If you know how to read flag and are not colour blind.mread my flag or ask someone who can.
Don't insult me calling that.
Damn your so dense, so you're saying in that riots Hindus were killing dalits ? Or aliens

I don't. We are not perfect. We have problems. We have been solving them for centuries now.

You mean fixing the culture or scripture ?
Because supreme court of India still can't define Hinduism as religion

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Is that legitimized in scriptures? Well unlike Hindu scriptures where this subjugation is authenticated and legitimized, I don't find this in Quran.

No true Scotsman. Of course.
It only theologically distinguishes between the People of the Book and the 'dirty rest'. How sweet.

Well documented? Are you suggesting Pushyamitra or Mihirkula? Their names don't sound Islamic.

You still want to peddle this BS open another thread and quote Joe in it. I will be a spectator and see how it goes.

On a personal level the loss of Nalanda, Takshashila, Gandhara, Kamboja, Odantapuri, Vikramshila etc pain us to this day.

You mean fixing the culture or scripture ?
Because supreme court of India still can't define Hinduism as religion

We should be flexible.

 

[kathiyawadi khamir]

Call me anything but Indian and that too south. I have nothing domwith ganga people.

If you know how to read flag and are not colour blind.mread my flag or ask someone who can.
Don't insult me calling that.
Damn your so dense, so you're saying in that riots Hindus were killing dalits ? Or aliens

now now, dont hate your south Indian Heritage you told us earlier that you are from Nizami Hydrabad. dont be a self Hater my Friend.

700 Hindus were killed by Muslims in Gujarat including ? 54 were burned alive by Muslim Huligans in godhra. it was Painful for me as a Gujarati. ;(

 

[SarthakGanguly]

700 Hindus were killed by Muslims

Not entirely true. 250 of them were killed by the Indian Army. Muslims were probably able to kill the rest.

 

[Tiger Genie]

like everything else in life, there is tall and short, strong and weak, fast and slow, majority and minority.

Normally the majority will be benevolent to the minority, the rich to the poor, the tall to the short, the strong to the weak.....until the latter does not mistake benevolence to be a birth right or penalty due to them. When that happens, the majority, the rich, the strong and the tall shrug and assert themselves.

I have been to over 35 countries of the world and can categorically say the US, Canada and India are THE most tolerant countries of the lot.

 

[The_Showstopper]

No true Scotsman. Of course.
It only theologically distinguishes between the People of the Book and the 'dirty rest'. How sweet.

So you have nothing to disprove the fact that these sects aren't sanctioned in Quran whereas the "Varnas" are well defined in your scriptures.

You still want to peddle this BS open another thread and quote Joe in it. I will be a spectator and see how it goes.

On a personal level the loss of Nalanda, Takshashila, Gandhara, Kamboja, Odantapuri, Vikramshila etc pain us to this day.

BS? So Pushyamitra, Mihirkula were no one? Or may be they were saintly people spreading their faith. Is it?

 

[SarthakGanguly]

So you have nothing to disprove the fact that these sects aren't sanctioned in Quran whereas the "Varnas" are well defined in your scriptures.

Your faith divides people into two 'worlds'. One of the Book and the other grants us 'beautiful privileges'. Only the Hanafis at least allow us to live as Dhimmis. How considerate. How about we learn from that and extend the same 'privileges' to you? All people of the no Book and a pact of Omar equivalent for you?

Varnas divide labor, not people. Our gurus and swamis have been fighting evils since a long time. And we will continue.

BS? So Pushyamitra, Mihirkula were no one? Or may be they were saintly people spreading their faith. Is it?

Open a new thread on that subject and get your rear handed back to you. Or be reported.

 

[salarsikander]

No true Scotsman. Of course.
It only theologically distinguishes between the People of the Book and the 'dirty rest'. How sweet.


You still want to peddle this BS open another thread and quote Joe in it. I will be a spectator and see how it goes.

On a personal level the loss of Nalanda, Takshashila, Gandhara, Kamboja, Odantapuri, Vikramshila etc pain us to this day.


We should be flexible.

Flexible in first allowing sutee and then banning it ?

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Flexible in first allowing sutee and then banning it ?

Yes. Sati became common during the Middle Ages, we don't find classical examples of Sati. Banning it was needed.

 

[salarsikander]

now now, dont hate your south Indian Heritage you told us earlier that you are from Nizami Hydrabad. dont be a self Hater my Friend.

700 Hindus were killed by Muslims in Gujarat including ? 54 were burned alive by Muslim Huligans in godhra. it was Painful for me as a Gujarati. ;(

Not me. My ancestor. I was born in Pakistan. So as of now I am Pakistani hold Pakistani nationality and no other nationality. Certainly not Indian one

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Not me. My ancestor. I was born in Pakistan. So as of now I am Pakistani hold Pakistani nationality and no other nationality. Certainly not Indian one

Relax. Don't take such posts to heart.