Who is the anti-national in India ?

[MilSpec]

Yes, that is off-putting. You have a dog but sorry I don't want to see dogs in India. Or anywhere. Maybe there can be special dog reserves like there are tiger reserves. Maybe an island.



1. Sterilizing dogs will not take away their propensity to attack humans and cats.

2. You sterilize a few dogs in an area but there will be more coming in from outside. That restarts the cycle of dog births.

3. Sterilization of that cat... yaar, as it is, cats are almost extinct in India and on top of that you sterilized one.



Indeed.



Thank you.

Dogs unless rabid won't attack humans,
Sterilizing is to ensure dogs in our area don't produce more litters.
There are probably 4 stray cats in and out of our house, and my parents have been feeding stray dogs and cats every day for the last 3 decades.
I grew up with dogs in my household, getting into fights with kids who throw stones at dogs all my childhood.

The last time when I was back in India, my wife wanted to bring one of the strays back with us, but the paperwork was too much of a hassle. Next time around will plan it better so we can get a pair of pariah dogs here, they are one of the smartest and bravest breeds.
We have a Black lab-Border Collie mix here, and she is the smartest pup we have ever seen, My wife's family has 2 husky's and 3 little Chihuahua's. One day, hopefully, we will be able to do something more substantial for the strays in India...

here is a Indian Pariah dog standing up to a Lioness.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1348158688331132929

 

[Titanium100]

India does have a highly educated elites who are baffled by the policies of Modi and the BJP. It is a ruinous political view as it only breeds chaos interally. Even the Bollywood elite can't wait to see Modi's reign pass.

India changed from a free-friendly country into an hostile backward extremist country within 6-7 years. The swift was dramatic. You see lynchers on the streets and tourists have declined due to rape and lynching activity.

The security is very poor and this is signs of a state that is melting down. You need intellectuals and diplomats to lead the country not an extremist or an extremist ideology. This will only deteriorate India

 

[El Sidd]

here is a Indian Pariah dog standing up to a Lioness.

Why are these being retweeted to protesting farmers?

What about the videos where villagers just tease and pull lioness from her tail? Its also quite indicative of genetical issues facing Leo in India.

 

[Juggernaut_Flat_Plane_V8]

Why are these being retweeted to protesting farmers?

What about the videos where villagers just tease and pull lioness from her tail? Its also quite indicative of genetical issues facing Leo in India.

Probably getting stunted and weak because of huge Lion population in a small area..The Lion needs to be rewilded in other parts of India...but then the Tiger will take it apart..Indian and Nepali tigers have finally surprassed wild Siberian tigers in size

 

[jamahir]

Dogs unless rabid won't attack humans,

No.

Vid link 1.

Vid link 2.

Vid link 3.

Vid link 4. Dog attacks boy and his cat saves him.

None of these dogs were found to be rabid.

There are probably 4 stray cats in and out of our house, and my parents have been feeding stray dogs and cats every day for the last 3 decades.

Good about the cats.

I grew up with dogs in my household, getting into fights with kids who throw stones at dogs all my childhood.

Well, about me, many years ago there was a BBC World Service Radio program called Outlook and one time they said to the listeners to tell them of any local problem so that they can send a reporter to do a small recording session. I wrote about the dogs in my city, and the consequent killings of cats, and they sent a reporter. The recording was edited to 11 minutes and I had said on air that I would shoot at my neighborhood's dogs with an air rifle.

here is a Indian Pariah dog standing up to a Lioness.

https://twitter.com/x/status/1348158688331132929

1. Dogs have enmity with the cat family and they mostly go in gangs to kill cats.

2. I posted the vid link of a cat standing up to a dog.

India does have a highly educated elites who are baffled by the policies of Modi and the BJP. It is a ruinous political view as it only breeds chaos interally. Even the Bollywood elite can't wait to see Modi's reign pass.

India changed from a free-friendly country into an hostile backward extremist country within 6-7 years. The swift was dramatic. You see lynchers on the streets and tourists have declined due to rape and lynching activity.

The security is very poor and this is signs of a state that is melting down. You need intellectuals and diplomats to lead the country not an extremist or an extremist ideology. This will only deteriorate India

The intellectuals and other progressive activists have been assassinated, jailed and generally made to suffer. And this happened while the middle class was busy in jobs, marriages, cricket match watching and religious rituals.

Whataboutism is particularly associated with Soviet and Russian propaganda.[4][5][6] When criticisms were leveled at the Soviet Union during the Cold War, the Soviet response would often be "What about ..." followed by instancing of an event or situation in the Western world.[7][8][9] According to Russian writer, chess grandmaster and political activist Garry Kasparov, it is a word that was coined to describe the frequent use of a rhetorical diversion by Soviet apologists and dictators, who would counter charges of their oppression, "massacres, gulags, and forced deportations" by invoking American slavery, racism, lynchings, etc.[10] Whataboutism has been used by other politicians and countries as well.

1. Why did you originally speak about communists and not made even one mention about all those I listed in my long OP ?

2. How can you give reference of a Western tool like Garry Kasparov ?

What about areas of Muslim majority? Do they get to be Brahmin? Its legally possible in India to be Dalit in one state and Brahmin in others. Complex stuff.

Kashmir is the only Muslim-majority state and it has 700,000 army and paramilitary soldiers.

Does the Indian constitution define who is an Indian? I am talking about pre A370 A35 and the other systematic legislature brought by the current BJP government?

I will have to do some research.

 

[El Sidd]

Probably getting stunted and weak because of huge Lion population in a small area..The Lion needs to be rewilded in other parts of India...but then the Tiger will take it apart..Indian and Nepali tigers have finally surprassed wild Siberian tigers in size

I doubt the size theory. The ones in Himalayan corridor are maybe just bigger than Sumatran variant.

I cannot believe ancient Indians sold these Lions to be set upon the Christians. They can't even fight a rabies infected dog.

 

[Juggernaut_Flat_Plane_V8]

I doubt the size theory. The ones in Himalayan corridor are maybe just bigger than Sumatran variant.

I cannot believe ancient Indians sold these Lions to be set upon the Christians. They can't even fight a rabies infected dog.

why would Romans need Indian lions to kill Christians when there were Barbary and Atlas lions ready to go in their own territories

 

[El Sidd]

Kashmir is the only Muslim-majority state and it has 700,000 army and paramilitary soldiers.

Pakistan will free Kashmir.

What about Hyderabad or Junagarh or Barreilly or Deoband or Qadiyan or Kerala? Can you not migrate to their lands for safety.

why would Romans need Indian lions to kill Christians when there were Barbary and Atlas lions ready to go in their own territories

Barbary ones aren't easy to find.

Asiatic lion now known as Indian lion was available more readily.

 

[MilSpec]

No.

Vid link 1.

Vid link 2.

Vid link 3.

Vid link 4. Dog attacks boy and his cat saves him.

None of these dogs were found to be rabid.

Millions of Videos out there showing dogs saving humans.

Well, about me, many years ago there was a BBC World Service Radio program called Outlook and one time they said to the listeners to tell them of any local problem so that they can send a reporter to do a small recording session. I wrote about the dogs in my city, and the consequent kills of cats, and they sent a reporter. The recording was edited to 11 minutes and I had said on air that I would shoot at my neighborhood's dogs with an air rifle.

Try shooting a dog with a pellet gun in my presence, you would regret that you were born.

 

[Naofumi]

1. Why did you originally speak about communists and not made even one mention about all those I listed in my long OP ?

The question was a rhetoric one, I answered it in a general form.

2. How can you give reference of a Western tool like Garry Kasparov ?

Everyone's a tool in the grand scheme of things and such ad hominems can extended by any side indefinitely. For example, Communists were useful ideological tools for murdering political opponents and ex-colleagues like Trotsky, stealing Nuclear technologies for building atomic bombs (btw largest A-bomb ever detonated was by USSR - supposedly peace loving welfare state which should have pushed for demilitarization like a communist's utopia is expected) and so on.

 

[Clutch]

The Hindutva right-wing groups ( BJP, RSS etc ) in India and their many supporters in the visual and print media, on Twitter and on various websites are fond of assigning the phrase "anti-national" and so demonizing certain groups who either revolt against the right-wingers or don't fit into the category of Indians as understood by the Hindutvadis. Such groups include Muslims, Dalits, Christians, Socialists / Communists, Liberals, Centrists and recently the Sikh and other farmers protesting in Delhi.

But who is the real anti-national ? Is it the micro-finance company and the mahajan who force the farmer to commit suicide ? Is it the hospital which allowed the actor Ashiesh Roy to die of kidney ailment because he couldn't pay the treatment fees they demanded ? Is it the coaching center in Kota and the college which force students to commit suicide ? Is it the Maneka Gandhi adoring woman in my neighborhood who used to daily prepare special rice for the stray dogs and deliver it to them on her scooter while millions of humans in the country go hungry ? Is it Mukesh Ambani who built an obscene 27-storey for his family of four while millions are homeless or live in slums ? Is it Yogi Adityanath and Sadhvi Pragya who quote fondly from the Manusmriti and want to make it the Constitution ? Is it the Tablighi Jamaatis in IBM-India who instead of agitating for an employee union for the benefit of all employees instead agitate selfishly for prayer place and time within the office ? Is it some self-styled moral police who prevent inter-faith marriages from happening ? Is it the film maker Ashoke Pandit who makes films against the Naxalites without thinking of the unjust feudalism in Naxalbari which led to the Naxal uprising ? Is it various aalims and babas who spread superstition and child sacrifice in the society in 2021 instead of the country having a settlement on Mars given its big industrial base and supposedly talented engineers ? Is it the "defense" minister who has made the Indian military to become the second-largest importer of armaments in the world while millions of civilians lead a miserable life because of lack of money ? Is it some idiot at the top who spends resources on needless purchases and projects while millions of citizens lack money and so lead a miserable life ? is it the maintainers of the entire political, social and economic system of India which allows these wrong things ? So who is the anti-national ?

---

@The_Showstopper @Naofumi @xeuss @Joe Shearer @T90TankGuy @AgnosticIndian @Zapper @SuvarnaTeja @-=virus=- @dharmi @SrNair @Gadkari. Tag other Indians.

@Mentee @fitpOsitive @ps3linux @Cliftonite @Indos @AgNoStiC MuSliM

Indian Muslims are anti-Indian.

They seek freedom from Hindutvaism .

 

[Cliftonite]

iword that was coined to describe the frequent use of a rhetorical diversion by Soviet apologists and dictators, who would counter charges of their oppression, "massacres, gulags, and forced deportations" by invoking American slavery, racism, lynchings, etc.

Now the Iranians and other Islamists here do it. Live in a shithole themselves but point to BLM and George Floyd to divert their shortcomings.

 

[SrNair]

The Hindutva right-wing groups ( BJP, RSS etc ) in India and their many supporters in the visual and print media, on Twitter and on various websites are fond of assigning the phrase "anti-national" and so demonizing certain groups who either revolt against the right-wingers or don't fit into the category of Indians as understood by the Hindutvadis. Such groups include Muslims, Dalits, Christians, Socialists / Communists, Liberals, Centrists and recently the Sikh and other farmers protesting in Delhi.

But who is the real anti-national ? Is it the micro-finance company and the mahajan who force the farmer to commit suicide ? Is it the hospital which allowed the actor Ashiesh Roy to die of kidney ailment because he couldn't pay the treatment fees they demanded ? Is it the coaching center in Kota and the college which force students to commit suicide ? Is it the Maneka Gandhi adoring woman in my neighborhood who used to daily prepare special rice for the stray dogs and deliver it to them on her scooter while millions of humans in the country go hungry ? Is it Mukesh Ambani who built an obscene 27-storey for his family of four while millions are homeless or live in slums ? Is it Yogi Adityanath and Sadhvi Pragya who quote fondly from the Manusmriti and want to make it the Constitution ? Is it the Tablighi Jamaatis in IBM-India who instead of agitating for an employee union for the benefit of all employees instead agitate selfishly for prayer place and time within the office ? Is it some self-styled moral police who prevent inter-faith marriages from happening ? Is it the film maker Ashoke Pandit who makes films against the Naxalites without thinking of the unjust feudalism in Naxalbari which led to the Naxal uprising ? Is it various aalims and babas who spread superstition and child sacrifice in the society in 2021 instead of the country having a settlement on Mars given its big industrial base and supposedly talented engineers ? Is it the "defense" minister who has made the Indian military to become the second-largest importer of armaments in the world while millions of civilians lead a miserable life because of lack of money ? Is it some idiot at the top who spends resources on needless purchases and projects while millions of citizens lack money and so lead a miserable life ? is it the maintainers of the entire political, social and economic system of India which allows these wrong things ? So who is the anti-national ?

---

@The_Showstopper @Naofumi @xeuss @Joe Shearer @T90TankGuy @AgnosticIndian @Zapper @SuvarnaTeja @-=virus=- @dharmi @SrNair @Gadkari. Tag other Indians.

@Mentee @fitpOsitive @ps3linux @Cliftonite @Indos @AgNoStiC MuSliM

First of all..It is always the basic instinct of the commies that itches something they cant touch or understand.
RSS is not in the social media and they dont care what others says about them.
They have a mission for nation construction .
Seva bharathis activity is one example .
Nor they depends media for their activity .

Now if some people is insults commies or so called liberals.
Then that is because your people hypocrisy .
When your crticism is in bias in nature a reaction will follow .
RSS dont need to anything about it .

 

[Microsoft]

Calling someone anti national is the easiest way to chicken out of a debate.

That's a very anti national statement. Do you not support PM Modi?

 

[Jackdaws]

That's a very anti national statement. Do you not support PM Modi?

Not at all. Think he is the worst PM in Indian history. And that includes Deve Gowda.