What's new

"White People Lack Empathy for Brown People"

A1Kaid

PDF THINK TANK: ANALYST
Joined
Oct 20, 2008
Messages
9,667
Reaction score
8
Country
Pakistan
Location
United States
Human brain recognizes and reacts to race, UTSC researchers discover

Study by the University of Toronto Scarborough, Apr 26, 2010


by April Kemick

The human brain fires differently when dealing with people outside of one’s own race, according to new research out of the University of Toronto Scarborough.

This research, conducted by social neuroscientists at U of T Scarborough, explored the sensitivity of the “mirror-neuron-system” to race and ethnicity. The researchers had study participants view a series of videos while hooked up to electroencephalogram (EEG) machines. The participants – all white – watched simple videos in which men of different races picked up a glass and took a sip of water. They watched white, black, South Asian and East Asian men perform the task.

Typically, when people observe others perform a simple task, their motor cortex region fires similarly to when they are performing the task themselves.
However, the UofT research team, led by PhD student Jennifer Gutsell and Assistant Professor Dr. Michael Inzlicht, found that participants’ motor cortex was significantly less likely to fire when they watched the visible minority men perform the simple task. In some cases when participants watched the non-white men performing the task, their brains actually registered as little activity as when they watched a blank screen.

“Previous research shows people are less likely to feel connected to people outside their own ethnic groups, and we wanted to know why,” says Gutsell. “What we found is that there is a basic difference in the way peoples’ brains react to those from other ethnic backgrounds. Observing someone of a different race produced significantly less motor-cortex activity than observing a person of one’s own race. In other words, people were less likely to mentally simulate the actions of other-race than same-race people”

The trend was even more pronounced for participants who scored high on a test measuring subtle racism, says Gutsell.

“The so-called mirror-neuron-system is thought to be an important building block for empathy by allowing people to ‘mirror’ other people’s actions and emotions; our research indicates that this basic building block is less reactive to people who belong to a different race than you,” says Inzlicht.

However, the team says cognitive perspective taking exercises, for example, can increase empathy and understanding, thereby offering hope to reduce prejudice. Gutsell and Inzlicht are now investigating if this form of perspective-taking can have measurable effects in the brain.

The team’s findings are published in the Journal of Experimental Social Psychology.

Source: https://webapps.utsc.utoronto.ca/ose/story.php?id=2135

Perhaps this helps to explain recent and historical world developments and events. Perhaps, this can be an explanation to what happened with that US soldier who recently killed innocent Afghan civilians in a shooting spree, or urinating on dead Afghan youth labeled as "Taliban", and a whole set of controversial events.

Let's discuss the reports of this study, I had read this a few years back but then was reminded of it due to recent developments.

Brain Research: White People Lack Empathy for Brown People

By Austin Cline, About.com Guide July 12, 2010


There have been a lot of studies revealing unconscious and latent racism in whites but not so many studies about what might be happening physically in the brains of people expressing such unconscious attitudes. It's important for us to understand more about this because these people also typically express anti-racist sentiments and there's no reason to think that they are lying. How can a person say they support equality and sincerely believe that they support equality but then exhibit racism?

The answer may lie in mirror neurons. A new study from the University of Toronto at Scarborough indicates that when white people watch non-whites performing simple tasks, their "mirror neuron system" is far less active than when watching whites performing the same task. If this is indeed true, then it suggests that a person can simultaneously have strong anti-racist beliefs but then be easily susceptible to racist attitudes because their brains simply fail to react to non-whites with the same degree of empathy as with whites.

Excerpt from:

Source: Brain Research: White People Lack Empathy for Brown People
 
.
It would be interesting to see if it works the other way round too. Brown people showing apathy towards white people.

Which could probably explain why "brown" suicide bombers don't feel any guilt when blowing up people of other races :rolleyes:
 
.
That's logical. And that's why there are so many political boundaries based on color and race alone. Even on a multi-racial country like USA, there are many color barriers as well.
 
.
It would be interesting to see if it works the other way round too. Brown people showing apathy towards white people.

Which could probably explain why "brown" suicide bombers don't feel any guilt when blowing up people of other races :rolleyes:

It would be interesting to see if it works the other way round too. Brown people showing apathy towards white people.

Sure, post a scientific study if you can find one. Though, there have been studies done on African-American children called the "doll test" which showed the non-whites such as AA children preferred the "white" appearance and look and had less esteem for their own. In other words conditioning of minorities...

Which could probably explain why "brown" suicide bombers don't feel any guilt when blowing up people of other races

"Brown" suicide bombers seems to be rooted in political conflict not racial, considering "brown" suicide bombing is relatively a new phenomenon and according to many sources in response to a political and/or military cause.
 
.
It would be interesting to see if it works the other way round too. Brown people showing apathy towards white people.

Which could probably explain why "brown" suicide bombers don't feel any guilt when blowing up people of other races :rolleyes:

What a dumb post by .....oh a bharti! Never mind.


Just out of curiosity , political conflict has nothing to do with "suicide" bombing...its all due to racial difference , right?
 
.
Just out of curiosity , political conflict has nothing to do with "suicide" bombing...its all due to racial difference , right?

And obviously some American soldier killing going on a killing rampage has to be racism, it can't be the stress of war, mental breakdown right?

And a Taliban beheading a white journalist can't be racism, its all about political conflict and differences :rolleyes:

Yes I am very dumb:lol:
 
.
Sure, post a scientific study if you can find one. Though, there have been studies done on African-American children called the "doll test" which showed the non-whites such as AA children preferred the "white" appearance and look and had less esteem for their own. In other words conditioning of minorities...

"Brown" suicide bombers seems to be rooted in political conflict not racial, considering "brown" suicide bombing is relatively a new phenomenon and according to many sources in response to a political and/or military cause.

I hope one day some "brown" scientist at a "brown" university would conduct such study. If I was a clinical psychologist I would do a study myself.

I don't have any issue with the result of the study. Would have been more interesting if they did the tests the other way round too.

And either case a sample size of thirty university students is just not big enough for you to reach that inference and link it to the case of American soldier killing civilians and urinating on the corpse of taliban fighter.
 
.
Source: https://webapps.utsc.utoronto.ca/ose/story.php?id=2135

Perhaps this helps to explain recent and historical world developments and events. Perhaps, this can be an explanation to what happened with that US soldier who recently killed innocent Afghan civilians in a shooting spree, or urinating on dead Afghan youth labeled as "Taliban", and a whole set of controversial events.

Let's discuss the reports of this study, I had read this a few years back but then was reminded of it due to recent developments.



Excerpt from:

Source: Brain Research: White People Lack Empathy for Brown People

You are trying too hard.. The Afghan massacre is more about hatred for the enemy than race. cultural differences do make it tough for them to understand each other but that's not the primary reason. More often than not, people who have been closest to each other seem to become the worst of foes. there is more passion involved in that hate. Example: India-Pakistan, China-Japan, Soviet Russia-Nazi Germany.
 
.
And obviously some American soldier killing going on a killing rampage has to be racism, it can't be the stress of war, mental breakdown right?

And a Taliban beheading a white journalist can't be racism, its all about political conflict and differences :rolleyes:

Yes I am very dumb:lol:

"Mental breakdown", "stress of war" sound like convenient excuses, what "stress of war" are you talking about all Afghan conflict recently has been low intensity to no intensity, what battlefield stress could that soldier have possibly endured. The US/NATO soldiers there aren't fighting pitched battled there. Sometimes, skirmishes, ambushes, low-intensity battles that pretty much it, generally speaking.

"Mental breakdown" if it were truly a mental breakdown why did he specifically target Afghan civilians not his own comrades? I have read about actual mental breakdowns occurring in soldiers in past wars and in many of those cases the soldiers fire on their own comrades because they have truly lost their senses and eventually have to be neutralized by their own comrades, that is a true "mental breakdown".

Besides, US army trains it's troops to deal with a lot of trouble mentally, so any low intensity stuff they should be able to withstand... This just seems like a convenient textbook excuse.

You are trying too hard.. The Afghan massacre is more about hatred for the enemy than race. cultural differences do make it tough for them to understand each other but that's not the primary reason. More often than not, people who have been closest to each other seem to become the worst of foes. there is more passion involved in that hate. Example: India-Pakistan, China-Japan, Soviet Russia-Nazi Germany.


You can disagree. Though, why did you not focus on the article's findings at all?
 
.
I would agree here to some extent .

Thanks to Western and particularly American media , us Easterners of other races have begun to understand them and empathise with them more often due to the influences of american TV and movies .

People of non white races are in a way almost always in some way connected to the white people's world through TV and video games etc but the whites are not connected in any way to the world of non-white people . That is why they probably don't care and empathise with us because they don't understand us at all.

They are happy in their own world , ofcourse lets face it , since atleast 3 centuries now whites have literally ruled almost every field in the world , why should they care about what is happening elsewhere .

They can't connect with us like we do with them for the above reasons .

P.S- I don't think racism has much to do with the rogue American soldier incident . Soldiers commit suicide due to depression and frustration all the time , this one just decided to take out his frustration on the others
 
.
I would agree here to some extent .

Thanks to Western and particularly American media , us Easterners of other races have begun to understand them and empathise with them more often due to the influences of american TV and movies .

People of non white races are in a way almost always in some way connected to the white people's world through TV and video games etc but the whites are not connected in any way to the world of non-white people . That is why they probably don't care and empathise with us because they don't understand us at all.

They are happy in their own world , ofcourse lets face it , since atleast 3 centuries now whites have literally ruled almost every field in the world , why should they care about what is happening elsewhere .

They can't connect with us like we do with them for the above reasons .

since atleast 3 centuries now whites have literally ruled almost every field in the world, why should they care about what is happening elsewhere .

You raise a critical point, so do you think westerners or "whites" were more empathetic to Easterners when the global balance of powers favored Easterners during certain historical periods? For example, Al-Andalus, Ottomans, Mughals, it seemed even during times of Eastern powers the situation remained similar perhaps I am wrong. Though one critical difference is back then there was no electronic media that we have today connecting us 24/7.

Do you think if Eastern powers attain global power, the trend will differ? According to the study, there is a neurological reason for the lack of empathy for other races/ethnic groups. So even a "brown person" westernized (and residing in the West) would experience the same lack of empathy it seems that is what the study implies.

This research, conducted by social neuroscientists at U of T Scarborough, explored the sensitivity of the “mirror-neuron-system” to race and ethnicity.
 
.
You raise a critical point, so do you think westerners or "whites" were more empathetic to Easterners when the global balance of powers favored Easterners during certain historical periods? For example, Al-Andalus, Ottomans, Mughals, it seemed even during times of Eastern powers the situation remained similar perhaps I am wrong. Though one critical difference is back then there was no electronic media that we have today connecting us 24/7.

Do you think if Eastern powers attain global power, the trend will differ? According to the study, there is a neurological reason for the lack of empathy for other races/ethnic groups. So even a "brown person" westernized (and residing in the West) would experience the same lack of empathy it seems that is what the study implies.

Though your question is not to me, i would like to answer it. I don't think the trend would be reversed exactly as i feel the cultural differences stall us from reacting so (easterner's) and also the intellectual shackles of western supremacy ingrained in eastern minds will take a lot go including time. Another important point is that when there is a precedence of ill effects such apathy towards others causes the later on's tend to not repeat it.
 
.
What a dumb post by .....oh a bharti! Never mind.


Just out of curiosity , political conflict has nothing to do with "suicide" bombing...its all due to racial difference , right?

oh you are on 1st position..
There are some exception also everywhere ..not all whites are like that...
 
.
You raise a critical point, so do you think westerners or "whites" were more empathetic to Easterners when the global balance of powers favored Easterners during certain historical periods? For example, Al-Andalus, Ottomans, Mughals, it seemed even during times of Eastern powers the situation remained similar perhaps I am wrong. Though one critical difference is back then there was no electronic media that we have today connecting us 24/7.

Do you think if Eastern powers attain global power, the trend will differ? According to the study, there is a neurological reason for the lack of empathy for other races/ethnic groups. So even a "brown person" westernized (and residing in the West) would experience the same lack of empathy it seems that is what the study implies.

you have answered your own question ,

during those times when the East was dominant , there was no media connecting us people so none of us were empathetic to each other . Neither they cared about us nor we cared about them .

it is all about whether the whites will able to connect with us or not and that has to do with presence of non-whites in popular world media and less to do with how strong your race is .

If tomorrow whites start watching movies , TV serials and sitcoms and sports in which us brown people dominate and the themes are dominated by the issues that we face then after a few years of such continuous connection with our world they will start to connect and empathise with us better because they will begin to understand us better .

It is the power of media dude , not the race or country that matters
 
.
Valid point, media conditioning is a critical aspect in this as media helps to shape the way many people think.
 
.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom