Where is Make in Pakistan?

[AugenBlick]

LOL @ the Pakistani who thanked this post
FDI up 48% in seven months of 'Make in India' - The Times of India

From your link

"The FDI inflow under the approval route saw a growth of 87 per cent during 2014-15 with inflow of $2.22 billion despite more sectors having been liberalized during this period and with more than 90 per cent of FDI being on automatic route," the statement added.
That means the flow of FDI is uniform across sectors too ... Not concentrated to sectors where India has traditional advantages(e.g. IT/ITES)

 

[rezangahir]

I thought CPEC was going to solve all your problems in one swoop.

What CPEC has to do with Manufacturing,it is just an investment (loan by Chinese banks) for Basic infrastructure notably road and energy and like any other loan it would be returned with interest.

On the other hand China is not investing in basic infrastructure in India as we are fully capable of financing our own electricity and Roads.

China Promises $20 Billion Investment In India, A New Road To Kailash Mansarovar - NDTV

China to invest over $5 billion in 2 business parks in Maharashtra, Gujarat - The Times of India
Xiaomi to invest in Indian start-ups, overseas content

Chinese companies to invest $500 million in Kakinada SEZ - The Times of India

 

[vinay]

I opened this thread to read something about "make in Pakistan" but what i find is posts on "make in India"
Pakistani posters are like ... I am naked , so what ? you are also wearing a torn shirt

 

[Max Pain]

To all the fellow Indians,
kindly Visit the CPEC thread and then comment and express your views.
that'll ensure a healthy discussion,

Haier Pakistan is a joint venture of a Pakistani and Chinese Company and recently they have set up an Assembly Plant for Laptops, its the first of its kind, and it has employed Pakistani Workers,
Haier Develops Appliances to laptops and Smart Phones and the workers are Pakistani.
this just is one Example.

Anyways moving along,
I dont get this one thing,we as a country are able to Produce a Jet Fighter that Is Going to be Exported To Other Countries while we dont Manufacture a single Car,not Even Good Bikes are produced here.
for the first freaking time I have seen a decent Bike in Pakistan(Yamaha YBR 125) when Yamaha decided to start its operations in Pakistan and decided to set up Assembly in Jan 2015 due to the growing demand.this bike already has been sold in Numbers and rightly so. We all have been frustrated by the situation of Automobile Industry in Pakistan when we're still sold the same designs of 80's bikes with no change or innovation,
Suzuki still sells those Mehrans of 90's for expensive prices and we have no choice but to pay huge sums for such Old rubbish cars.

This industry really needs revival.

 

[AugenBlick]

I dont get this one thing,we as a country are able to Produce a Jet Fighter that Is Going to be Exported To Other Countries while we dont Manufacture a single Car,not Even Good Bikes are produced here.

That is because you assemble from a CKD . or a Knock down kit. There is zero pakistani contribution except for some stages of the final assembly process being in Pakistan.... these tasks are essentialy too simple and can be done without education/industry upgrade.
more info about CKD here : Knock-down kit - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

This industry really needs revival.

Yes and the govt has to play a role. e.g. if you decide to manufacture (not assemble) say screws for JF17 all the screw maker will be upgraded to Aerospace standard screws ... of course this will require ToT from China..... or a cunning Pak politician willing to copy /reverse engineer tech just like China did to the ruskies.

 

[tore]

The FTA with China was the Death warrant of Make in Pakistan.
But why would pakistanis want to copy a Chai waala "terrorist" in the first place?

-----------------------

The thing is that we dont want to copy a chai wala , but any good policies. All over the world you see, when any country in the region has good experience with any policy , also sorrunding countries implement that policy.

 

[SamantK]

-----------------------

The thing is that we dont want to copy a chai wala , but any good policies. All over the world you see, when any country in the region has good experience with any policy , also sorrunding countries implement that policy.

The thing is that presently you cannot copy a chai wala, let alone a PM.

 

[Max Pain]

That is because you assemble from a CKD . or a Knock down kit. There is zero pakistani contribution except for some stages of the final assembly process being in Pakistan.... these tasks are essentialy too simple and can be done without education/industry upgrade.
more info about CKD here : Knock-down kit - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Yes and the govt has to play a role. e.g. if you decide to manufacture (not assemble) say screws for JF17 all the screw maker will be upgraded to Aerospace standard screws ... of course this will require ToT from China..... or a cunning Pak politician willing to copy /reverse engineer tech just like China did to the ruskies.

as much as Id want to agree with you, im afraid youre wrong,
had it been so simple to just assemble jets, every other country would be assembling and exporting. its not as simple as it sounds nor it is,
we hold 58 percent of share in this project, do you actually think we're just assembling here.and the part where you claimed that tasks are essentialy too simple and can be done without education surely got me laughing.or maybe its your ignorance.
kindly get educated about JF-17 before talking about it, my comment was more about the automobile industry of Pakistan and this hilarious fella chose the very part that has been hurting your Indian feelings and has been a symbol of butthurt for years considering your Tejas Success in Mind. but I shouldve expected that from a person with 17 negative ratings.silly me.

 

[AugenBlick]

-----------------------

The thing is that we dont want to copy a chai wala , but any good policies. All over the world you see, when any country in the region has good experience with any policy , also sorrunding countries implement that policy.

The thing is that this policy is the brain child of Modi...a Chai wala .... so it is a chai walla's policy ... if you want to copy it we have no objection ... but just want to inform you that you are copying a chai waala.

 

[Guynextdoor2]

So Pakistan is going to grow into a developed civilized country by being a mango economy? I don't think so. Agriculture, textiles and donkey harvesting can only get you so far.

Even China is investing in plants in India to locally manufacture products, creating jobs and increasing knowledge.

What is Pakistan doing? Where are initiatives to increase manufacturing? I don't see anything happening apart from roads being built.

There is no 'make in pakistan'.....

 

[Chanakya's_Chant]

Honestly, for all of India's push - the "make in India" thing is a great slogan but there has not been anything tangible achieved so far. And the biggest problem of course remains corruption at every level - from municipal corporation employees to corporate slaves - everyone wants a kickback. Unless this goes and 24x7 electric supply is there all over the country - mere sloganeering is not going to achieve much.

(01) Foreign direct investment (FDI) into India during October 2014-April 2015 period rose by 48% year-on-year after the launch of ‘Make in India’ initiative.

FDI soars 48% after 'Make in India' launch | Free Press Journal

(02) "Make in India" is considered to be a prime factor behind the 22% FDI Inflows growth in FY14 making India one of the Top 10 Global FDI Destinations at #9 From #15 in FY13

FDI Inflows in India up by 22% - Joins Top 10 Global FDI Destinations at #9 in '14 (From #15 in '13)

(03) As far as corruption is concerned - The consensus among Indian Industrialists and Investors - or India Inc. is that regardless of whether things have changed or not 'on the ground', things appear to have changed at the top - with the top-level corruption's going down in Modi govt.

Top-level corruption's down in Modi govt, fingers crossed: India Inc - The Times of India
One year of Modi government: A look at what does India Inc think - The Economic Times

Even foreign based investors like Prem Watsa seen to think so -

Corruption at highest levels in India has disappeared, says Prem Watsa - The Economic Times

 

[AugenBlick]

had it been so simple to just assemble jets, every other country would be assembling and exporting. its not as simple as it sounds nor it is,

Son I have experience in Automotive industry with functions like sourcing, quality and manufacturing .... I know more about CKD and vendor development than you or most members here.

we hold 58 percent of share in this project, do you actually think we're just assembling here.and the part where you claimed that tasks are essentialy too simple and can be done without education surely got me laughing.or maybe its your ignorance.

Establishing a JV with 58% share in the company =!= 58% of work share ... your govt. and media lies to you.

kindly get educated about JF-17 before talking about it, my comment was more about the automobile industry of Pakistan

Both are related....

a symbol of butthurt for years considering your Tejas Success in Mind

Hahah tejas has more indigenous content like fly by wire , composits etc than all of Pakistani manufacturing industry combined.

but I shouldve expected that from a person with 17 negative ratings.silly me.

The price for typing the truth.

There is no 'make in pakistan'.....

Make in Pakistan is a success in the Terrorism sector ... they had ToT from Saudia and CIA and have now set up their ingenious assembly and design teams

 

[GURU DUTT]

So Pakistan is going to grow into a developed civilized country by being a mango economy? I don't think so. Agriculture, textiles and donkey harvesting can only get you so far.

Even China is investing in plants in India to locally manufacture products, creating jobs and increasing knowledge.

What is Pakistan doing? Where are initiatives to increase manufacturing? I don't see anything happening apart from roads being built.

good thread with great intention ... god bless you and god bless pakistan ... congrats

 

[black-hawk_101]

So Pakistan is going to grow into a developed civilized country by being a mango economy? I don't think so. Agriculture, textiles and donkey harvesting can only get you so far.

Even China is investing in plants in India to locally manufacture products, creating jobs and increasing knowledge.

What is Pakistan doing? Where are initiatives to increase manufacturing? I don't see anything happening apart from roads being built.

Imported Western used goods are really of good quality. No one needs China or Pakistani made.

 

[OrionHunter]

Just imagine ..Pakistan does not manufacture AC compressors and imports from Poland & others.

Poland? Why the heck can't they import from India at one third the cost? Ego problems?

Imported Western used goods are really of good quality. No one needs China or Pakistani made.

Pakistanis don't like Chinese made stuff? Missiles, aircraft, nukes, tanks, choppers subs, ships.....???