Where does the soul of Bangladesh lie?

[Luffy 500]

Regardless of whether vedas was a word of God , it is corrupted (i.e changed over time by humans) now just like all other previous scriptures sent before the Quran. Now people looking for truth have to follow the last and final revelations from God i.e the Quran, which will be protected in its authentic form by God himself till the end of time. The correct statement would be vedas might have been a authentic scripture sent by God for people of that time only and in that region. Vedas does state that God has no image or shape what so ever and that there is only one God who is all knowing and all powerful similar to the Islamic concept of God. Infact making images of God in whatever shape or form is totally prohibited in the vedas but hindus don't follow it naturally.

Dr. Zakir Naik's point is very clear that find similarities between Hinduism and Islam and there by bring followers of vedas accept Islam. And if someone want to follow those verses of the vedas that are compatible with Islam , they must come to Islam and accept prophet Muhammad (pbuh) as the last and final messenger and believe in Tawhid, the islamic concept of monotheism . The similarity is just for doing dawa to Hindus and spread Islam.

 

[PlanetSoldier]

Actually it is very much possible that the Vedas are authentic scriptures from God.After all God did send Prophets to all nations.Why not here??

God did send Prophets to mid-east only not all nations, that's a mystery !

 

[Mattrixx]

Common women of KSA

Elite of KSA

How much is Hefajoti knowledge.

 

[Anubis]

I am not preaching here but the Vedas do form a basis for Tawhid which is the core for Islam.Even if Hindus don't convert to Islam we should all know that we are not so different to each other.

When the Shahbas migrated to Abyssinia they were brought before the king.The Sahabas recited verses from Sura Mariyam on request from the king.It is said that the king drew a line on the sand and told them,'The difference between you and me is no more than this line.' Thus they were allowed to stay in Abyssinia.

Peace comes from commonality.If we ever face aliens it is only natural that we will be able to make peace with humanoid aliens and not The Blob.

God did send Prophets to mid-east only not all nations, that's a mystery !

The Authority disagrees:And for every NATION, there is a Messenger; when their Messenger comes, the matter will be judged between them with justice, and they will not be wronged. (Qur'ân 10:47)

 

[LaBong]

I think I'd rather prefer vedas to be man made literature, music, philosophy and folklore (which exactly what they are), than to be a corrupted version of Islam. I know your intention is honest but you guys seems to be able to offend people even by saying their scriptures were sent by god.

I am not preaching here but the Vedas do form a basis for Tawhid which is the core for Islam.Even if Hindus don't convert to Islam we should all know that we are not so different to each other.

When the Shahbas migrated to Abyssinia they were brought before the king.The Sahabas recited verses from Sura Mariyam on request from the king.It is said that the king drew a line on the sand and told them,'The difference between you and me is no more than this line.' Thus they were allowed to stay in Abyssinia.

Peace comes from commonality.If we ever face aliens it is only natural that we will be able to make peace with humanoid aliens and not The Blob.



The Authority disagrees:And for every NATION, there is a Messenger; when their Messenger comes, the matter will be judged between them with justice, and they will not be wronged. (Qur'ân 10:47)

While I don't agree with the technicalities of your post but your to the point at the gist. The key is to respect each other difference and accept the commons.

 

[Anubis]

I think I'd rather prefer vedas to be man made literature, music, philosophy and folklore (which exactly what they are), than to be a corrupted version of Islam. I know your intention is honest but you guys seems to be able to offend people even by saying their scriptures were sent by god.

Well that's a skeptic view and a sign of cultural exchange between the Middle Eastern civilization and Indian civilization.YOU NASTIK!

 

[PlanetSoldier]

I am not preaching here but the Vedas do form a basis for Tawhid which is the core for Islam.Even if Hindus don't convert to Islam we should all know that we are not so different to each other.

When the Shahbas migrated to Abyssinia they were brought before the king.The Sahabas recited verses from Sura Mariyam on request from the king.It is said that the king drew a line on the sand and told them,'The difference between you and me is no more than this line.' Thus they were allowed to stay in Abyssinia.

Peace comes from commonality.If we ever face aliens it is only natural that we will be able to make peace with humanoid aliens and not The Blob.



The Authority disagrees:And for every NATION, there is a Messenger; when their Messenger comes, the matter will be judged between them with justice, and they will not be wronged. (Qur'ân 10:47)

Does it really satisfy you? We know many prophets in Arab zone, can you mention a single name from western hemisphere or eastern hemisphere or this subcontinent only. Why is this abstractness "there is a messenger" while we know Arab origin messenger names?

 

[Skallagrim]

No you do not understand my point of view.I know the Vedas was composed by many people of many generations.But God hints in the Quran that he has sent prophets to all nations in many generations.That means that it is very much 'possible' that many prophets were to sent to India too.Vedas is not one book.So it is asserted by scholars that the books(not all of them) that match the fundamental ideas of Abrahamic monotheism were actual scriptures.The Bible is also a collection of books from different people.

The imageless,body-less,all prevailing,all knowing,universal nature of God that the monotheistic books of the Vedas preach is the very essence of Abrahamic monotheism.

From a skeptical point of view Abrahamic religion might have been heavily influenced by Indian religions and vice versa.Prophet Zul-Kifl(literally meaning a guy from some place called Kifl) received revelations under a fig tree.Mind you there is no 'P' in arabic.So,Kifl might be Kipl which might be a reference to Kapilabastu.Sounds familiar doesn't it??Either Buddha himself was one such Prophet similar to the ones who had books which became a part of the Vedas or the legend of Buddha(if any such person actually existed) got mixed up and appeared in Abrahamic scripture.There's also reference to prophets in the Book of Ezekiel whose description match that of Buddha's.Either we are all part of a divine plan or its a matter of cultural exchange.

BUT THIS IS ALL SPECULATION.



They are still there.I said authentic not uncorrupted!

Now we're discussing semantics. Anything authentic must be uncorrupted!

 

[Luffy 500]

God did send Prophets to mid-east only not all nations, that's a mystery !

Allah(swt) clearly states in the Quran that he send messengers to all nations not just ME or Bani Israel.

And We certainly sent into every nation a messenger, [saying], "Worship Allah and avoid Taghut." And among them were those whom Allah guided, and among them were those upon whom error was [deservedly] decreed. So proceed through the earth and observe how was the end of the deniers. (Surat An-Naĥl 16:36)

Surat An-Nahl - The Noble Qur'an - ?????? ??????

And We have already sent messengers before you. Among them are those [whose stories] We have related to you, and among them are those [whose stories] We have not related to you. And it was not for any messenger to bring a sign [or verse] except by permission of Allah . So when the command of Allah comes, it will be concluded in truth, and the falsifiers will thereupon lose [all].(Surat Ghāfir 40:78)

Surat Ghafir - The Noble Qur'an - ?????? ??????

 

[Anubis]

Now we're discussing semantics. Anything authentic must be uncorrupted.

NO.If someone claims that "Half Blood Prince" is a revelation that is unauthentic let alone corrupted.If someone claims "Torah" is a revelation that is an authentic claim although the Torah is corrupted.

Allah(swt) clearly states in the Quran that he send messengers to all nations not just ME or Bani Israel.



Surat An-Nahl - The Noble Qur'an - ?????? ??????



Surat Ghafir - The Noble Qur'an - ?????? ??????

Thanks.Sura Ghafir makes it clearer that there were prophets whose stories Allah had not related to our Prophet(Pbuh).So,there were more prophets than mentioned by name in the Quran.

 

[Android]

I think Vedas are way too..... much different from Quran to just be called as a corrupted version of it

 

[Banglar Bagh]

What you fools say nobody cares.
Say your women and children to follow Islam properly.
Dont bother what others are doing. If people like to lead their life Islamic way, its their wish.
This types of tone of islamism its not new. Gulam Azam also said these for Islam we shouldnt split
pakistan. So where were you.

Appearently everybody cares what I or many like me thinks. Infact the majority of Bangladeshis dont want to be a so-called secularist country where the religion of the majority will get hammered everybody and you cant say anything. You are living in shahbagi dreamland and you are so unaware of what the majority wants. Its yours number which is a handful and not the other way around.

Just dont use gulam azom and other similar cards everytime anyone talks against you lots anti-islam stand. You guys have lost all your credibility by bringing this issue in every matter. And one more thing you should be the last person in the world to call anyone fool.

 

[Luffy 500]

@Banglar Bagh ,bhai replying to madx posts is a waste of time and band width. Only reply when its a must otherwise I suggest avoid his blabbering. That guy once posted saying he wants Bakshal. U can't argue with chapatti mentality.

 

[Anubis]

I think Vedas are way too..... much different from Quran to just be called as a corrupted version of it

The Vedas are NOT are a corrupted version of the Quran.The Quran is ONE book.It is a huge monologue.The Vedas are many books.There are books that contradict with each other.I am talking about books that have similar monotheistic foundation.Foundations that match with books thousands of miles away from different cultures.That is what I am pointing at.

 

[Android]

The Vedas are NOT are a corrupted version of the Quran.The Quran is ONE book.It is a huge monologue.The Vedas are many books.There are books that contradict with each other.I am talking about books that have similar monotheistic foundation.Foundations that match with books thousands of miles away from different cultures.That is what I am pointing at.

Sorry my mistake no offence was intended

PS guys stop discussing Vedas for as yourl are unintendedly offending us by saying they are unauthentic