Mr first read about Karbala and don't quote me Shia things I have read it in detail and many have been proven wrong yes Yazid always in our elections and followers of Imam Hussain always loose Mr Democracy is complete kufr not even close to Islam
My brother why are you so arrogant?
1. If you remember your Fiqh class - you would know that the most important concern is the intent of the legislator (Allah). A true Faqeeh never forgets that. Parroting other people's opinions without understanding the nuances of age/era, context, meaning, & intention does not help in understanding an issue of vital importance. Your view is probably based on one Hadees. If you are capable of looking at how mature democratic system actually works with choosing of candidates, process of elections, checks & balances, and the system of safeguards, you would realize that the admonition contained in that Hadees does not quite apply here
2. I would like to ask how come Ulema accepted Kingship as an acceptable system of governance, when kingship went against everything that Islam teaches in matter of establishment of government? In this day and age, the only way of peacefully changing government is through ballot box. If you have a better idea, please let me know.
I hope you realize one day that your opinion indirectly supports confusion and fitnah in today's Islamic world. Calling democracy Kufr and extrapolating this Kufr to the whole of nation is the AlQaeda way of looking at things. This is how killing of innocents is justified and this is how Muslim countries are falling into ruin. I am not saying that you are related to AQ, but that your view finds its expression in how they justify their actions.
3. When you call democracy Kufr, then do you also mean that all the people who participate in democratic process are practicing Kufr? What about the members and supporters of religious political parties? Are they also practicing Kufr? Our elected representatives and government functionaries are also product of Kufr?
When you call democracy Kufr, you are effectively denying the basis of Pakistan's creation. I am not sure you have the right to speak about Pakistan's political & strategic issues when you are against the basis of creation of Pakistan. Tell me straight up: Do you consider Pakistan a product of Kufr?
4. What makes you think I do not know about what happened at Karbala? What makes you think I am quoting Shia things? What Shia thing did I say and how can you prove me wrong? What do you mean when you say "many have been proven wrong"? Perhaps you derive certitude and security from your belief that you are automatically always right, but I would like to know the basis of it.
5. It would be best if you leave aside your interpretation of Islam when you post on this forum. Your opinions and pronouncements fit very nicely with negative stereotypes of what many here consider a "religious person". Many here ridicule religion, religiosity, and religious people and you provide them with plenty of ammunition on this count. You are source of embarrassment and ridicule for practicing Muslims who are aware of nuances and distinctions necessary in today's world. A saving grace would be a show of courtesy & politeness, but you can not manage to do that even.
If you care to use the term Mister, you may as well mean it. It is a polite and formal way of addressing the other person. You seem to be using it in a derogatory manner - as suits a Mullah who is unaware of many things, but is very aware of his assumed position of moral & educational superiority.
)
