What's new

Valid doubts about authenticity of space missions by ISRO.

Joined
Jan 16, 2013
Messages
5,241
Reaction score
-66
Country
India
Location
India
The very fact that NASA's probe carried by lunar satellite launched by ISRO found vast amount of water on moon's surface should raise doubts about whether the mission was real or fake. Because Moon was previously thought to be dry.

NASA probe on Chandrayaan-1 orbiter: Moon’s water is widely distributed across the surface

If the Moon has enough water, and if it is reasonably convenient to access, future explorers might be able to use it as drinking water or to convert it into hydrogen and oxygen for rocket fuel or oxygen to breathe.

Washington:
The Moon’s water is widely distributed across the surface and is not confined to a particular region or type of terrain, say scientists who studied data from a NASA probe aboard India’s Chandrayaan-1 orbiter.

The water appears to be present day and night, though it is not necessarily easily accessible, they said.

The findings may help understand the origin of the Moon’s water and how easy it would be to use as a resource.

If the Moon has enough water, and if it is reasonably convenient to access, future explorers might be able to use it as drinking water or to convert it into hydrogen and oxygen for rocket fuel or oxygen to breathe.

“We find that it doesn’t matter what time of day or which latitude we look at, the signal indicating water always seems to be present,” said Joshua Bandfield, a senior research scientist with the Space Science Institute in the US.

“The presence of water doesn’t appear to depend on the composition of the surface, and the water sticks around,” said Bandfield, lead author of the study published in the journal Nature Geoscience.

The results contradict some earlier studies, which had suggested that more water was detected at the Moon’s polar latitudes and that the strength of the water signal waxes and wanes according to the lunar day (29.5 Earth days).

Some researchers proposed that water molecules can “hop” across the lunar surface until they enter cold traps in the dark reaches of craters near the north and south poles.

In planetary science, a cold trap is a region that’s so cold, the water vapour and other volatiles which come into contact with the surface will remain stable for an extended period of time, perhaps up to several billion years.

The debates continue because of the subtleties of how the detection has been achieved so far. The main evidence has come from remote-sensing instruments that measured the strength of sunlight reflected off the lunar surface.

When water is present, instruments like these pick up a spectral fingerprint at wavelengths near three micrometres, which lies beyond visible light and in the realm of infrared radiation.

However, the surface of the Moon also can get hot enough to “glow,” or emit its own light, in the infrared region of the spectrum.

The challenge is to disentangle this mixture of reflected and emitted light. To tease the two apart, researchers need to have very accurate temperature information.

Researchers came up with a new way to incorporate temperature information, creating a detailed model from measurements made by the Diviner instrument on NASA’s Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter (LRO).

The team applied this temperature model to data gathered earlier by the Moon Mineralogy Mapper, a visible and infrared spectrometer that NASA’s Jet Propulsion Laboratory in Pasadena, California, provided for the Chandrayaan-1 orbiter.

The finding of widespread and relatively immobile water suggests that it may be present primarily as OH, a more reactive relative of water that is made of one oxygen atom and one hydrogen atom.

OH, also called hydroxyl, doesn’t stay on its own for long, preferring to attack molecules or attach itself chemically to them. Hydroxyl would therefore have to be extracted from minerals in order to be used.

The research also suggests that any water present on the Moon isn’t loosely attached to the surface.

“By putting some limits on how mobile the water or the OH on the surface is, we can help constrain how much water could reach the cold traps in the polar regions,” said Michael Poston of the Southwest Research Institute in the US.

Sorting out what happens on the Moon could also help researchers understand the sources of water and its long-term storage on other rocky bodies throughout the solar system.

The researchers are still discussing what the findings tell them about the source of the Moon’s water.

“Some of these scientific problems are very, very difficult, and it’s only by drawing on multiple resources from different missions that are we able to hone in on an answer,” said LRO project scientist John Keller of NASA’s Goddard Space Flight Center in the US.

http://www.newsnation.in/science-ne...buted-across-the-surface--article-192582.html
 
. . .
The very fact that NASA's probe carried by lunar satellite launched by ISRO found vast amount of water on moon's surface should raise doubts about whether the mission was real or fake. Because Moon was previously thought to be dry.

Earth was also considered to be the center of Universe previously. Explorer missions are exactly for the same reason, to explore various possibilities.

How did you come to conclusion that the mission was fake? The article accepts the existence of water on lunar surface, albeit it challenges the location, which according to Chandrayaan-1 was on Lunar Poles.
 
.
You believe Communist propaganda? What is your proof that this is real and others aren't?

I think they wouldn’t have declared the rover dead after a day if they went through the trouble of faking the landing.

Speaking of which you guys declared seeing the Apollo landing sites in your pics but then suddenly hushed up and refused to publish the pics.

We only have Indian and Japanese moon pics as third party evidence.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom