What's new

US Provided India Intelligence Input On Chinese Troop Deployments During Doklam Stand-Off ,Report

INDIAPOSITIVE

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Sep 20, 2014
Messages
9,318
Reaction score
-28
Country
India
Location
India
SOURCE: swarajyamag

During India’s 73-day long military stand-off with China in the Bhutanese territory of Doklam last year, the US provided New Delhi intelligence input on Beijing’s troop deployments, the Economic Times has hinted in a report.

The report, which talks about India’s changing position on the Communications Compatibility and Security Agreement (COMCASA) with the US, hints that New Delhi benefited from the intelligence Washington provided.

India’s position on the agreement started changing when it realised the benefits of US’ intelligence inputs, the report claims.

“The Dokalam face off was the turning point for the Indian position on the Comcasa when it realised the benefit of US intelligence on Chinese troop deployments in calibrating its approach. This sort of intelligence was not available with India,” the Economic Times report reads.

According to the report, the US has agreed to address India’s concerns related to this agreement. This includes the assurance that the equipment provided to India under this agreement will remain operational as long as the agreement stands. The US has also assured New Delhi that it will not share any Indian data with other entities without prior approval, the daily’s report says.

COMCASA is one of three foundational agreement that the US signs with other countries for high technology cooperation in the defence sector. The other two are Logistics Exchange Memorandum of Agreement (LEMOA) and Basic Exchange and Cooperation Agreement for Geo-spatial Cooperation (BECA). India signed LEMOA with the US in 2016 after years of negotiation.
 
SOURCE: swarajyamag

During India’s 73-day long military stand-off with China in the Bhutanese territory of Doklam last year, the US provided New Delhi intelligence input on Beijing’s troop deployments, the Economic Times has hinted in a report.

The report, which talks about India’s changing position on the Communications Compatibility and Security Agreement (COMCASA) with the US, hints that New Delhi benefited from the intelligence Washington provided.

India’s position on the agreement started changing when it realised the benefits of US’ intelligence inputs, the report claims.

“The Dokalam face off was the turning point for the Indian position on the Comcasa when it realised the benefit of US intelligence on Chinese troop deployments in calibrating its approach. This sort of intelligence was not available with India,” the Economic Times report reads.

According to the report, the US has agreed to address India’s concerns related to this agreement. This includes the assurance that the equipment provided to India under this agreement will remain operational as long as the agreement stands. The US has also assured New Delhi that it will not share any Indian data with other entities without prior approval, the daily’s report says.

COMCASA is one of three foundational agreement that the US signs with other countries for high technology cooperation in the defence sector. The other two are Logistics Exchange Memorandum of Agreement (LEMOA) and Basic Exchange and Cooperation Agreement for Geo-spatial Cooperation (BECA). India signed LEMOA with the US in 2016 after years of negotiation.
What kind of intelligence? Location and movement of Chinese troops? Our satellites are not enough to cover the Indian subcontinent?
 
What kind of intelligence? Location and movement of Chinese troops? Our satellites are not enough to cover the Indian subcontinent?
are you comparing US intelligence level with India's?
decades of fine tuning and increasing the intelligence gathering smarts during the cold war.

Indian satellites may be good, but as of now, not many can match US in int gathering and scientific advancements in this field (and a many other defense related areas). You still have Chinese nationals trying to steal R&D from American companies.
 
are you comparing US intelligence level with India's?
decades of fine tuning and increasing the intelligence gathering smarts during the cold war.

Indian satellites may be good, but as of now, not many can match US in int gathering and scientific advancements in this field (and a many other defense related areas). You still have Chinese nationals trying to steal R&D from American companies.
I'm not comparing overall US intelligence apparatus with India's. We need to know if US satellites give far greater raw info than Indian satellites in the Indian subcontinent. Of course I do find it believable that US will have greater ability to game plan and predict Chinese actions than us.

So it would be good to understand what exactly US can give us in terms of intelligence.

Chinese steal US intelligence gathering techniques because they view US as the superpower to compare with. Chinese goals are different and far more grand than ours.
 
Back
Top Bottom