What's new

US move of tagging Indian students unacceptable: India

you are making a fool out of your self here .
so you mean to say - that these student intentionally went to a fake university to ruin their carreer and life ?????

more than these student u need this tag around your neck or head.

- its inhuman to treat student like this - when one expect their murderer diplomat in Pakistan to be free why not bunch of student can be handled better ?
Of course they intentionally went to a fake university! So they can get the hell out of a third world country. Now the US government busted the scam and they're all criminals, going to be deported back to the third world.

You won't get preferred treatment from any country (okay except maybe Nepal). You obey the law, or don't go.
 
.
OK, it seems the Indians want to stay. No? I don't think they would be forced into a situation where their departure to their homeland is denied. Otherwise, I have to condemn the horrible human rights record of the world's oldest "democracy" *and* the world's largest "democracy."
 
.
Simple work to do now, just call back all the Indian students who studied there and put the hell of restriction to go to study in other countries.. never mind increase the tax who studied and work there or cancel their citizenship.
 
.
Unfortunate for the students, they got what they paid for.
 
. .
First off, of course the Indian students know about the scam! It is no coincidence that 95% of the students are Indians and are working illegally! So they are treated as criminals because they have broken the law!

What about the millions of mexicans working illegally......have any of them been tagged?

Come on bro.....the majority of the students are just normal people trying to make a better life for themselves.
 
. .
- its inhuman to treat student like this - when one expect their murderer diplomat in Pakistan to be free why not bunch of student can be handled better ?

You got to love Indian media, one piece of delectable information was omitted likely intentionally to stir up the masses. The ankle bracelet is ordered by a judge and this is how we routinely handle non violent criminals - just ask Lindsay or Paris Hilton:agree:
 
Last edited:
.
crazy....i came across a felon near a convenience store who had one of those GPS-trackers on his ankle. Sucks to be those 'students'




BBC News - US says radio-tagging of duped Indian students is okay

The United States has said the use of ankle monitors on Indian students duped by a fake university in California was justified.

In a statement, the US embassy in Delhi said the use of monitors was widespread across America and did not imply guilt or suspicion of criminal activity.

It allows freedom of movement and is an alternative to confinement during a pending investigation, it said.

India has condemned US authorities for tagging Indian students.

External Affairs Minister SM Krishna has said that Indian students were "not criminals" and that radio collars put around their ankles must be removed.

US authorities shut down the Tri-Valley University near San Francisco, accusing it of an immigration fraud.

The university has more than 1,500 students and reports say nearly 95% of them are from India.

Most of the students are reported to be from the southern Indian state of Andhra Pradesh and many of them now face deportation.

In the state capital, Hyderabad, members of the All India Students' Federation demonstrated over the weekend against the Tri-Valley University near the US consulate.
 
.
I have zero sympathy for them. they knew perfectly what they ARE DOING and they got it. :hitwall:
 
.
Well, I can't agree with that "radio-tagging", I think it's not polite!
 
.
1 Feb, 2011, 05.24PM IST,PTI
Tri Valley University blames Indian-origin staffer for immigration fraud

..................................................


"Starting in April, one of student assistants Anji Reddy, who worked in TVU administrative office, teamed with another student Ram Krista Karra , who also has a consultant company, conducting a large cheating scheme by asking students to make tuition payment into Ram Krista Karra's personal account in exchange for student I-20 and CPT approval. TVU has fired these two individuals," the e-mail said.

The complaint against TVU before the ICE was made by these two, Su claimed.

...............................................................

Full report:
Tri Valley University blames Indian-origin staffer for immigration fraud - The Economic Times
 
.
Hundreds of Indian students to return from US for immigration fraud by Univ

..........................................

The university is said to have 1,555 students. As many as 95 per cent of these students are Indian nationals, the complaint said.

Investigations by Immigration and Custom Enforcement (ICE) found that while students were admitted to various residential and online courses of the university and on paper lived in California, in reality they "illegally" worked in various parts of the country as far as Maryland, Virginia, Pennsylvania, and Texas.

ICE has called it as a "sham university." The ICE investigations found that more than half of these students were reported to be residing in a single apartment located in Sunnyvale California.

.......................................................................

Full report:
Hundreds of Indian students to return from US for immigration fraud by Univ, World news - e-news4u.com
 
.
Tri-Valley gave its students a 20% cut to lure buddies: Report

HYDERABAD: Students in Tri-Valley University apparently got a 20% cut from the sham varsity for every admission they facilitated: The commission was lucrative as it was calculated on the tuition fee (approx Rs 8 lakh) of the fresher.

Moreover, many from Andhra Pradesh had taken a circuitous route to Tri-Valley — first joining another varsity and then landing up at the fake varsity, lured probably by its offer of instant employment.

These findings figure in the detailed report submitted by the NRI cell (at the Secretariat) to chief minister N Kiran Kumar Reddy. As per the report, a majority of the Indian students had moved to Tri-Valley from other universities. It also states that only a little more than 100 students who had obtained visas from US Consulates in India were Tri-Valley bound, indicating that most with F-1 visas were going to other universities.

The students needed a crooked route to Tri-Valley as it was not approved by the US to provide I-20 forms, which every applicant for student visa (F-1), needs to submit. Using illegal I-20 forms issued by Tri-Valley raised the risk of being caught during a thorough check. Consequently, students preferred to take admissions in other universities with valid I-20 forms and then used it to enter Tri-Valley.

The university, however, claims on its website that it was "authorised'' by the US government to issue I-20 forms. But only 140 of its 5,500 students had this form from Tri-Valley. Parents have also accused Tri-Valley of running a scam even in issuing these "fake" I-20 forms.

"While most universities issue I-20 forms without much hassle, Tri-Valley University management or agents charged Rs 25,000 to Rs 50,000," said a parent from the city.

Some students from Hyderabad even received an I-20 directly from the university and it is reliably learnt that both Hyderabad US Consulate and the one at Chennai failed to detect the fraud and processed these F-1 visa forms.

In some cases it appeared that students had not really intended to move to the sham Tri-Valley unversity. For instance, a local student who went for her MBA to Schiller International University, Florida, eventually moved to Tri-Valley along with a bunch of 20 other students after her course was over. The reason? While most joined it lured by the prospect of being legally allowed to work (Tri-Valley gives Curricular Practical Training enabling students to work from Day 1 for 20 to 40 hours a week), others simply joined the bandwagon.

Now with several students being radio-tagged and interrogated for long hours, the CM on Wednesday said that the state had written to the ministry of external affairs and the Indian consulate in California to protect students and provide them with legal aid.
 
.
somewhat related

Tighter rules for UK student visas

The rules for student visas into the UK are to be much tougher - after fears that this route of entry is being used dishonestly.

Home Secretary Theresa May said student visas were being abused and "too many were here to work and not to study".

She announced plans to cut the number of student visas by up to 80,000 - about a quarter of the current numbers.

Shadow Home Secretary Yvette Cooper warned that rules must not damage an industry worth £5bn a year.

Mrs May told the House of Commons that the misuse of student visas had become a "symbol of a broken and abused immigration system".

Language rules

Tightening rules to stop false applications would be "in the best interests of legitimate students," she said.

The tougher rules will include a requirement for students to be able to speak English.

Mrs May said she wanted to end the situation where would-be students arrived at UK airports unable to even describe the courses they were about to begin.

There will also be tighter regulations on allowing the dependents of students to join them in the UK - and less flexibility in the number of years that overseas students can spend in the UK after courses are finished.

In response to concerns that students visas are being misused by economic migrants, there will be limits on the hours of paid work which overseas students will be allowed to carry out.

Universities had previously expressed fears about the loss of overseas students from tighter visa rules - but Universities UK said that their concerns had been taken into account.

Many of the restrictions are targeted at students in private colleges - rather than universities.

Language colleges and providers of pre-university entry courses had warned of the damage to their businesses if visa rules make it difficult for legitimate students to enter the UK.

But Mrs May told MPs that such "pathway" courses into universities would be protected, if universities acted as sponsors to students.

"We will need to look closely at the finer detail, but they have listened to our concerns about pathway courses into universities and the need for the language requirement to be set at a realistic level that will not deter good students," said Edward Acton, vice-chancellor of the University of East Anglia.

Bogus colleges

The Shadow Home Secretary Yvette Cooper warned that the plan was being driven by the need to meet political promises about cutting immigration numbers, rather than to improve the visa system.

She said that Mrs May should act "in the interests of a sensible, controlled migration policy, rather than taking risks with an important export industry for the sake of promises she knows she can't keep".

The proposals from the government are the latest attempt to find a way to stop false applications without deterring legitimate students, who have become an important source of funding for UK universities and colleges.

There has been a long-standing problem with bogus colleges, set up to get around visa rules under the pretence of offering courses.

Despite repeated efforts to tighten the rules, there are still concerns about the misuse of the visa system by self-regulated, private colleges.

There have been 64 colleges which have had their right to sponsor overseas students withdrawn, since the current regulations were introduced.

Last week the Home Affairs Select Committee recommended that the government should abandon plans to raise the level of English required to gain a visa.

UCU general secretary, Sally Hunt, said: "The government's student visa plans are short-sighted and risk sending out the worrying message that the UK is closed for business."


BBC News - Tighter rules for UK student visas
 
.
Back
Top Bottom