US: China's sea claims exceed what treaty permits

[Zero_wing]

What China should do is (1)prove that she owns Scarborough shoal or (2)declare war to her neighbors and land grab every
territories she wants. Or (3)China recognizes UNCLOS and abandon her 9-dash claim.

Option 1 is no good. China can't find her historical map. Can't prove her sovereignty over SCS.

Option 2 is no good. US is watching. China will be beaten black and blue. Plus China is a big fat coward.

Option 3 is good. China's most sensible thing to do.

What China should do is (1)prove that she owns Scarborough shoal or (2)declare war to her neighbors and land grab every
territories she wants. Or (3)China recognizes UNCLOS and abandon her 9-dash claim.

Option 1 is no good. China can't find her historical map. Can't prove her sovereignty over SCS.

Option 2 is no good. US is watching. China will be beaten black and blue. Plus China is a big fat coward.

Option 3 is good. China's most sensible thing to do.

Again only an idiot will think the 9 dot claim is legal because all laws should be logical and sound does claiming a whole sea sound logical? Hell no!

 

[Battle of Bach Dang River]

What China should do is (1)prove that she owns Scarborough shoal or (2)declare war to her neighbors and land grab every
territories she wants. Or (3)China recognizes UNCLOS and abandon her 9-dash claim.

Option 1 is no good. China can't find her historical map. Can't prove her sovereignty over SCS.

Option 2 is no good. US is watching. China will be beaten black and blue. Plus China is a big fat coward.

Option 3 is good. China's most sensible thing to do.

I think many Chinese who have conscience and responsibility, also sees China's claims absurd and exceed in the SCS. But they dared not speak, because they are afraid of blind nationalism in China will point spearhead at them.
How can they believe in the sketch of the so-called "nine-dashed line" unreasonable and unfounded?

 

[fly2012]

When I first saw the map of China's claim on South China Sea, I could not stop laughing. These Chinese are really incredible.

And Vietnam claims exactly the same, how do you think of that?

 

[Battle of Bach Dang River]

And Vietnam claims exactly the same, how do you think of that?

No, We have coordinated maritime boundary delimitation with Malaysia, Indonesia. And Vietnam-Philippines are jointly patrols together.
This is the Vietnam-Malaysia:

Pursuant to Article 76 of the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea, Malaysia and Vietnam on 6 May 2009 jointly submitted to the Commission on the Limits of the Continental Shelf a notification of the two countries' extended continental shelf claims.[6] The "defined area" claimed in the joint submission covered a stretch of the South China Sea which lay in between the 200 nautical mile limit of the two countries. The area in question includes part of the Spratly Islands and its adjacent waters.
Malaysia

This is the Vietnam-Indonesia:

The Agreement between the Government of the Republic of Indonesia and the Government of the Socialist Republic of Vietnam concerning the delimitation of the Continental Shelf Boundary was signed on 26 June 2003 in Hanoi, Vietnam, by Indonesia's Foreign Minister Hasan Wirajuda and his Vietnamese counterpart Nguyen Dy Nien.
The agreement defined the continental shelf boundary of the two countries as the imaginary straight line located between the two terminal points - namely Point 20 and Point 25 - of the 1969 continental shelf agreement between Indonesia and Malaysia with four turning points in between.
Indonesia

This is the Vietnam-Philippines, and I believe that the two countries can be solved peacefully together:

THE Philippines and Vietnam have moved closer to jointly patrolling their claimed maritime territories in the disputed Spratly Group of Islands that are being aggressively claimed by China.
The standard operating procedure for the joint patrol by the country’s Navy and the Vietnam People’s Navy (VPN) of the Northeast Cay and Southwest Cay, both on the South China Sea, was signed by Vice Admiral Alex Pama, Navy flag officer in command and the Vietnam Navy’s commander in chief Adm. Nguyen Van Hien.
PHL, Vietnam navies to jointly patrol Spratlys

We have only the greatest controversy with China's greedy claim "9 dashed line".

 

[FairAndUnbiased]

What China should do is (1)prove that she owns Scarborough shoal or (2)declare war to her neighbors and land grab every
territories she wants. Or (3)China recognizes UNCLOS and abandon her 9-dash claim.

Option 1 is no good. China can't find her historical map. Can't prove her sovereignty over SCS.

Option 2 is no good. US is watching. China will be beaten black and blue. Plus China is a big fat coward.

Option 3 is good. China's most sensible thing to do.

We already proved it belongs to us. You just ignore the proof, so we ignore you. If you dare, evict our ships lol?

 

[Great Sachin]

We already proved it belongs to us. You just ignore the proof, so we ignore you. If you dare, evict our ships lol?

World is ignoring you....why should we evict your ship...we are not claiming South China Sea

 

[WuMaoCleverbot]

We already proved it belongs to us. You just ignore the proof, so we ignore you. If you dare, evict our ships lol?

What these Chinese only proved is that they are brainwashed by their gov't into unquestionably believing that they own SCS.
The Chinese gov't can't even produce their 1200's historical evidence. China can't even defend her claim under UNCLOS. China's evidence of sovereignty over SCS is very weak.

China's greed and her people's jingoism will cause her downfall. I predict China will lose in a war and be cut into smaller states.

 

[Contract Killer]

We already proved it belongs to us. You just ignore the proof, so we ignore you. If you dare, evict our ships lol?

.

Lol. You guys are even claiming to have discovered America much before KC.

What these Chinese only proved is that they are brainwashed by their gov't into unquestionably believing that they own SCS.
The Chinese gov't can't even produce their 1200's historical evidence. China can't even defend her claim under UNCLOS. China's evidence of sovereignty over SCS is very weak.

China's greed and her people's jingoism will cause her downfall. I predict China will lose in a war and be cut into smaller states.

There is a say in our Hindi "Jan Gidar ki maut aati hai, to wo seher ki or bhagta hai".

In english......... "When death of Jackal comes, He runs towards City". In China's case SCS is there City.