US 'biggest' threat, say Pakistani Polls

[pakomar]

A survey commissioned by Al Jazeera in Pakistan has revealed a widespread disenchantment with the United States for interfering with what most people consider internal Pakistani affairs.

The polling was conducted by Gallup Pakistan - a separate organisation affiliated with the US-based Gallup Inc - and more than 2,600 people took part.


Interviews were conducted across the political spectrum, and represented men and women of every economic and ethnic background.

The resentment was made clear when residents were asked if they support or oppose Pakistan's own military offensive against Taliban targets.

Keeping with recent trends a growing number of people, now 41 per cent, support the campaign.

About 24 per cent of people remain opposed, but an additional 22 per cent of Pakistanis remain neutral on the question.

Taliban dialogue

That number changes quite significantly when people were asked if they would support government-sanctioned dialogue with Taliban fighters if it were a viable option.

The same 41 per cent said they would still support the military offensive. But the number of those supporting dialogue leaps up to 43 per cent.

So clearly, Pakistanis are, right now, fairly evenly split on how to deal with the Taliban threat.

However, when asked if they support or oppose the US military's drone attacks against what Washington claims are Taliban and al-Qaeda targets, only nine per cent of respondents reacted favourably.

A massive 67 per cent say they oppose US military operations on Pakistani soil.

"This is a fact that the hatred against the US is growing very quickly, mainly because of these drone attacks," Makhdoom Babar, the editor-in-chief of Pakistan's The Daily Mail newspaper, said.

"Maybe the intelligence channels, the military channels consider it productive, but for the general public it is controversial ... the drone attacks are causing collateral damage," he told Al Jazeera

The consensus of opinion on US military involvement is notable given the fact that on a raft of internal issues there is a clear level of disagreement, which can be expected in a country of this size.

Pakistani leadership

When asked for their opinions on Asif Ali Zardari, the Pakistani president, 42 per cent of respondents believe he is doing a bad job. Around 11 per cent approve of his leadership, and another 34 per cent have no strong opinion either way.

That pattern was reflected in a question about the Pakistan People's Party (PPP).


Forty-one per cent of Pakistanis say they support the offensive against the Taliban

Respondents were asked if they thought the PPP is good or bad for the country.

About 38 per cent said the PPP is bad for the country, 20 per cent believe it is good for the country and another 30 per cent said they have no strong opinion.

Respondents were even more fractured when asked for their views on how the country should be led.

By far, the largest percentage would opt for Nawaz Sharif, a former prime minister, as leader. At least 38 per cent back him to run Pakistan.

Zardari received only nine per cent support, while Reza Gilani, Pakistan's prime minister, has the backing of 13 per cent.

But from there, opinions vary greatly. Eight per cent of the population would support a military government, 11 per cent back a political coalition of the PPP and Sharif's PML-N party.

Another six per cent throw their support behind religious parties and the remaining 15 per cent would either back smaller groups or simply do not have an opinion.

Babar told Al Jazeera that Zardari's unpopularity was understandable given the challenges that the country had faced since the September 11, 2001 attacks on the US.

"Any president in Pakistan would be having the same popularity that President Zardari is having, because under this situation the president of Pakistan has to take a lot of unpopular decisions," he said.

"He is in no position to not take unpopular decisions that are actually in the wider interests of the country, but for common people these are very unpopular decisions."

US policies

The level of diversity disappears when broader questions of security and military intervention are posed.

In the same way that most Pakistanis right now reject what they see as US military interference, they strongly oppose US policies as a whole.

The respondents were asked what they consider to be the biggest threat to the nation of Pakistan: 11 per cent of the population sees the Taliban as the largest threat, while 18 per cent believe it comes from India.

But by an overwhelming margin, 59 per cent of respondents said the greatest threat to Pakistan right now is, in fact, the US.

That is a number worth bearing in mind the next time the US claims its military campaign is succeeding.
Al Jazeera English - CENTRAL/S. ASIA - US 'biggest' threat, say Pakistanis

 

[pakomar]

For the complete poll results
Al Jazeera English - Focus - Pakistan: State of the nation

 

[pakomar]

 

[LiberalPakistani]

nice polls that shows the people of Pakistan's opinion on US & India both are considered a major threat to Pakistan and its National Security Pakistan should do what is right for the long-term interest not on the Uncle Sams note just like Soivet Fall invading different countries US will follow.

 

[pakomar]

nice polls that shows the people of Pakistan's opinion on US & India both are considered a major threat to Pakistan and its National Security Pakistan should do what is right for the long-term interest not on the Uncle Sams note just like Soivet Fall invading different countries US will follow.

check out the polls many Pakistani thinks US as bigger threat than long time rival India.

 

[Patriot]

This was bound to happen.US media and officials barking every day on tv that we should take war into Afghanistan had pretty bad impact on Pakistani Public.Not to mention the 80's sanctions which made Pakistani extremely Anti America.

 

[third eye]

Absence of consistency is the biggest threat Pak faces.

 

[EjazR]

Some really interesting stats here

Punjabis and PML-N supporters are least in favor of military action at 30%

MQM and urdu-speakers are most in favor of military rule with almost with 47% and 27% respectively.

And Sindhis are least likely to consider India as a threat at 3% but most likely to favor TTP as threat at 15%.

What would have been more intersting was if they added Afghanistan and Israel as well as options in the poll

 

[Fracker]

The resentment was made clear when residents were asked if they support or oppose Pakistan's own military offensive against Taliban targets.

If they would have said Pakistani operation against TTP, they would have much larger support in favor of these actions.

any ways, good polling.. but still i have doubt on

Zardari received only nine per cent support

Who were these people?

 

[S-2]

A crucial question missing was whether you favor permitting the afghan taliban to conduct an insurgency upon Afghanistan from Pakistani lands.

That would have shed much light on the anti-American sentiment here.

Most Pakistanis do, I suspect. Most have been sold that "strategic depth" in Afghanistan can only be gained via the gun and naturally see America standing in the way.

That would have been an immensely valuable question.

 

[muse]

While I'm not suggesting that the poll is inherently flawed, I would suggest that respondents are generally liable to present their "feelings" as opposed to what may be thinking.

Among US observers, the position that vast numbers of people are opposed to US policy is met with incredulity and a immediate spin is that people are envious, just plain don't like the US and so on - While we can understand this, because just imagine what changes in US policy might mean, beginning from inside the US, a change in the media, the congress and so on, down, to a reflection of the domestic inthe external policies.

 

[waraich66]

A crucial question missing was whether you favor permitting the afghan taliban to conduct an insurgency upon Afghanistan from Pakistani lands.

That would have shed much light on the anti-American sentiment here.

Most Pakistanis do, I suspect. Most have been sold that "strategic depth" in Afghanistan can only be gained via the gun and naturally see America standing in the way.

That would have been an immensely valuable question.

This is not reality that is why this question not asked?

 

[waraich66]

While I'm not suggesting that the poll is inherently flawed, I would suggest that respondents are generally liable to present their "feelings" as opposed to what may be thinking.

Among US observers, the position that vast numbers of people are opposed to US policy is met with incredulity and a immediate spin is that people are envious, just plain don't like the US and so on - While we can understand this, because just imagine what changes in US policy might mean, beginning from inside the US, a change in the media, the congress and so on, down, to a reflection of the domestic inthe external policies.

Its not their just feeling ,people are sick of US WOT . Pakstan is poor country per capita income is less then 400$ .Present government is depending on IMF loans,country is in financial termoil .

Even NATO countries (canada etc) will withdraw forces from Afghanistan.public pressure in UK is also building up but US media is still silent not presenting true picture of Afghanistan war may be because of control of stronge jew lobbies (AIPAC etc)

 

[S-2]

"...US media is still silent not presenting true picture of Afghanistan war may be because of control of stronge jew lobbies (AIPAC etc)"

OMG, 'dem dar Jews again...

This anti-semitism stuff is soooo incredibly engrained. So too the accompanying sense of impotent inferiority. Stunning stuff.

We need to hold some esteem-building seminars.

"I'm O.K. You're O.K."

Big group hug maybe.

Too little doing. Too much blaming others.

Do more. Blame less.

 

[pakomar]