tipu sultan ancestors were pakistani

[saiyan0321]

Of course. Pakistan as the home for Muslims in South Asia may have been true once upon a time, but in the present day and age such a claim may no longer hold true, demographically speaking.

Does it matter now. Pakistan is home for Pakistanis and the state is responsible for the welfare of Pakistanis and pakistanis are responsible to be law abiding citizens of the said state.. There is a critical population awareness in pakistan. We are not in some race.. Other Muslims of south Asia have their own States and their responsibility is to their state and their state's responsibility is to them

 

[VCheng]

Does it matter now. Pakistan is home for Pakistanis and the state is responsible for the welfare of Pakistanis and pakistanis are responsible to be law abiding citizens of the said state.. There is a critical population awareness in pakistan. We are not in some race.. Other Muslims of south Asia have their own States and their responsibility is to their state and their state's responsibility is to them

It really does not matter now, but for those stuck in the past it is still a huge issue.

 

[saiyan0321]

It really does not matter now, but for those stuck in the past it is still a huge issue.

Those that are stuck into the past need to come to the present and work on the future.. The past is gone. The present is here and the future is coming.

 

[VCheng]

Those that are stuck into the past need to come to the present and work on the future.. The past is gone. The present is here and the future is coming.

Very true, but please keep in mind the role the past still plays in creating, and maintaining the preferred national narrative.

 

[saiyan0321]

Very true, but please keep in mind the role the past still plays in creating, and maintaining the preferred national narrative.

Indeed but nations evolve and states evolve.. Slowly we are also evolving....

 

[VCheng]

Indeed but nations evolve and states evolve.. Slowly we are also evolving....

So goes the claim, but frankly, evidence to support such an evolution is pretty thin at the moment.

 

[saiyan0321]

So goes the claim, but frankly, evidence to support such an evolution is pretty thin at the moment.

Things can look bleak but there are positives.

 

[Buddhistforlife]

Tipu Sultan was a Pakistani. Ideological and spiritual Pakistani

Why should Muslims be considered as a hero in India? Tipu Sultan may be a hero in Pakistan but not in hindu India.

 

[Asian.Century]

And Tipu Sultan being having ancestors Pakistani, also were Shias.

 

[VCheng]

Things can look bleak but there are positives.

Yes, I can accept that as a hope. But reality will force changes whether willingly or unwillingly.

 

[El Sidd]

Why should Muslims be considered as a hero in India? Tipu Sultan may be a hero in Pakistan but not in hindu India.

But India is secular

 

[Joe Shearer]

India will be having a Muslim majority soon.
Don't be fooled by the 78pc hindus statistics.

IMO, the hindu population is about 60 to 65 pc. But this includes atheists and non practising hindus which should be at least half of the whole.

Well, that is not, I think, a very reasonable estimate; perhaps about 15 to 20% would be better. But you are right in other ways: the Hindu bloc covers many who have been co-opted, totally without their own wishes being consulted, such as the Dalit and the tribals.

 

[Jackdaws]

Because Bengalis, by in large, refused to integrate. The ones that did were treated well, e.g Bogra.



Then prove to me you can read it lol.





It's our national language veggie-boy, and has been the lingua franca of Muslims from the sub-continent for centuries.



You don't, you use squiggles based on Sanskrit.



Agreed.



Don't care.



When you say "actual" you mean Kuffar and Munafiqeen, since Muslims can never be real freedom fighters in your eyes, as you've already barked multiple times.

Of course they can be. Like Bharat Ratna Khan Abdul Gaffar Khan. Whom if I am not mistaken was jailed not just by the British but also by the Pakistanis.
Maulana Azad. Asfaqulla Khan. Major General Shah Nawaz Khan.

People who actually fought the British rather than accept British rule. But again, if you haven't read history, it's not my fault.

Lol. You do realize we are using the Latin alphabet here.

You should speak some language which is Pakistani and be proud of it like Brahui. It's fine if you are using an Indian language too - you are welcome.

 

[Joe Shearer]

I like how this thread developed. One can feel the Tipu ripping through the Indians

Just go and sit on the pot. It will help your digestion and your temper.

 

[El Sidd]

Just go and sit on the pot. It will help your digestion and your temper.

You guys just cannot think past fecal matter?
Or is it a go to reaction everytime Tiger of Mysore in mentioned in your ranks?