What's new

The Word "Hindu" Is Not Indian, Claims Kamal Haasan

manlion

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Mar 22, 2013
Messages
7,568
Reaction score
-3
There has been no mention of ''Hindu'' by the 12 Alwars or Nayanmars. We were christened Hindu by Mughals or those (foreign) rulers who predated them," Kamal Haasan said.

CHENNAI: Facing
severe backlash over his recent Hindu extremist remarks, Makkal Needhi Maiam (MNM) founder Kamal Haasan Friday claimed that the very term ''Hindu'' was not a native description, but only a foreign coinage.

Neither the Alwars nor the Nayanmars, the famed Vaishnavite and Shaivite saints, had made any note on ''Hindu,'' he said in a Tamil statement uploaded on Twitter.

The citizens were identified only as ''Indians'' and confining it to religion was "erroneous," he said.

"There has been no mention of ''Hindu'' by the 12 Alwars or Nayanmars. We were christened Hindu by Mughals or those (foreign) rulers who predated them," he said.

The British, who ruled the nation, "endorsed" that coinage, he said.

"While we have so many of our own identities, it is ignorant to have something given to us by non-native as name and faith," he added.

While the identity "Indian is recent," it was "eternal", the MNM chief said.

"It is erroneous, in terms of commerce, politics and spirituality, for us to try to confine our vast country into religion," Mr Haasan said.

"To put it in layman's terms, living in harmony has a million benefits," he said referring to a Tamil saying.

Earlier, stoking a controversy, Mr Haasan had said "free India's first extremist was a Hindu," referring to Nathuram Godse, who shot dead Mahatma Gandhi.

"I am not saying this because this is a Muslim dominated area, but I am saying this before a statue of Gandhi. Free India's first extremist was a Hindu, his name is Nathuram Godse. There it (extremism) starts," he had said in bypoll bound Aravakurichi.

The remarks had resulted in a major row, with the BJP and AIADMK tearing into Mr Haasan, even as cases were filed against him in Tamil Nadu and Delhi.

However, the Congress's state unit and rationalist outfit Dravidar Kazhagam backed him.

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/lok...ndu-is-not-indian-claims-kamal-haasan-2039258

Note : 12 Alvars and 63 Nayanmar were Tamil vaisnavite and saivite saints (5th - 7th AD) .
Pioneers of the bhakti tradition (similar to sufism). They were responsible for saving the Tamils ancient religion ( or the so called "Hinduism") from extinction. (more follow up later)
 
Last edited:
. . . .
He is spot on. Bhangees are getting their dhotis in a twist.

Out of 5000 year recorded subcontintal history they only have guptas/mauryas for a couple of hundred years everything else is foreign. Hindu is derived from river indus, everything about these gangas is fake
 
.
He is spot on. Bhangees are getting their dhotis in a twist.

Out of 5000 year recorded subcontintal history they only have guptas/mauryas for a couple of hundred years everything else is foreign. Hindu is derived from river indus, everything about these gangas is fake

How do you know Mauryas and Guptas are also not foreign. Our Indian friends are too potent and proud of making up some non existent stuff. The Chola dynasty seems more like Indian.
 
Last edited:
. .
Basic premises of Hinduism is derived from Sanatan Dharma...
 
.
12 alvars

12_azhwars.jpg


63 Nayanmars

6892706138_80fa058238.jpg


no mention of Hindu in their religious works (used as reference by Kamal Haasan , Madurai Pontiff, Tamil scholars and nationalists)
 
.
There has been no mention of ''Hindu'' by the 12 Alwars or Nayanmars. We were christened Hindu by Mughals or those (foreign) rulers who predated them," Kamal Haasan said.

CHENNAI: Facing
severe backlash over his recent Hindu extremist remarks, Makkal Needhi Maiam (MNM) founder Kamal Haasan Friday claimed that the very term ''Hindu'' was not a native description, but only a foreign coinage.

Neither the Alwars nor the Nayanmars, the famed Vaishnavite and Shaivite saints, had made any note on ''Hindu,'' he said in a Tamil statement uploaded on Twitter.

The citizens were identified only as ''Indians'' and confining it to religion was "erroneous," he said.

"There has been no mention of ''Hindu'' by the 12 Alwars or Nayanmars. We were christened Hindu by Mughals or those (foreign) rulers who predated them," he said.

The British, who ruled the nation, "endorsed" that coinage, he said.

"While we have so many of our own identities, it is ignorant to have something given to us by non-native as name and faith," he added.

While the identity "Indian is recent," it was "eternal", the MNM chief said.

"It is erroneous, in terms of commerce, politics and spirituality, for us to try to confine our vast country into religion," Mr Haasan said.

"To put it in layman's terms, living in harmony has a million benefits," he said referring to a Tamil saying.

Earlier, stoking a controversy, Mr Haasan had said "free India's first extremist was a Hindu," referring to Nathuram Godse, who shot dead Mahatma Gandhi.

"I am not saying this because this is a Muslim dominated area, but I am saying this before a statue of Gandhi. Free India's first extremist was a Hindu, his name is Nathuram Godse. There it (extremism) starts," he had said in bypoll bound Aravakurichi.

The remarks had resulted in a major row, with the BJP and AIADMK tearing into Mr Haasan, even as cases were filed against him in Tamil Nadu and Delhi.

However, the Congress's state unit and rationalist outfit Dravidar Kazhagam backed him.

https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/lok...ndu-is-not-indian-claims-kamal-haasan-2039258

Note : 12 Alvars and 63 Nayanmar were Tamil vaisnavite and saivite saints (7th/8th AD) .
Pioneers of the bhakti tradition (similar to sufism). They were responsible for saving the Tamils ancient religion ( or the so called "Hinduism") from extinction. (more follow up later)
Even India is not "Indian". Made by British and Mughals.
 
. .
good to see Tamils demolishing the Indian / Hindu myth

Mean while ins an "All Muslim" Pakistan... 1 USD = 200 PKR.
How Comforting...

Ironic is the fact that A "Tamil" & "Muslim" built our Agni Missiles... to Annilate Pakistan !
 
.
Mean while ins an "All Muslim" Pakistan... 1 USD = 200 PKR.
How Comforting...

Ironic is the fact that A "Tamil" & "Muslim" built our Agni Missiles... to Annilate Pakistan !

without Tamilnadu (and other south states) contribution Indian rupee will be 1 USD = 300 Rupees and the irony the same Tamils will destroy India ...... last but not the least - no Tamils no Hinduism
 
. . .

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom