The Naxal Threat to India

[Steakhouse]

As if none of those Indian insurgencies have multi-year histories? None of these insurgencies are recent in India either.
And when did I downplay problems? I mentioned China has problems, as does India, as does every Asian country. I gave in fact, reasons for the naxalite problem, and you read that as a threat to your jingoist ego? And what is that Chinese guy @Keel doing here then, predicting Indian civil wars?

India not a nation before British left the subcontinent, India as a nation have a very young history, the formation of India consist of many small kingdoms join together and form a new nation India, many part of the northeast annex by India after British left, south Tibet invaded by British and was never grand independent to south Tibet but British allow India to take control of south Tibet. Of course India insurgent don't have a long history of independent movement.

 

[Nihil]

India not a nation before British left the subcontinent, India as a nation have a very young history, the formation of India consist of many small kingdoms join together and form a new nation India, many part of the northeast annex by India after British left, south Tibet invaded by British and was never grand independent to south Tibet but British allow India to take control of south Tibet. Of course India insurgent don't have a long history of independent movement.

Tibet has a sixty year history of insurgency. Same as Kashmir, or even the Naxals.
And newsflash, the vast majority of modern India was actually united under the Mughals, the Delhi Sultanate, the Marathas, the Gupta empire and so on. Megasthenes named his book Indica, not countries of south asia two thousand years back. Know history before making wrong claims.

 

[Winchester]

I am sure you will find many supporters here

Surely not more than you...
You are the darling of the whole saffron brigade here

 

[krishnathealien]

We Indians lucky to have such well wishing neighbors around us. So much money and time is spend on researching India's problems by them, making our Governments job easy to find solutions. Thank you Sabina and Riaz. Keep it up.

 

[DIRECT ACTION]

Precisely
Shining India should compare itself with Japan

Much thanks to the OP for this article
A good account of the present day gloomy situation of the uprisings across India which should provoke many thoughts which are rather ignorant on evaluating India as an emerging country and its growing influence in geopolitics of the world as a result

ofcource, we are comparing india with japan, and we are inspired by them. that is why we are one of the fastest developing nations.

we are living in india and we understand better than a pakistani writer who never visited in the Maoist affected areas. many points in her article is not true.

 

[Nihil]

ofcource, we are comparing india with japan, and we are inspired by them. that is why we are one of the fastest developing nations.

we are living in india and we understand better than a pakistani writer who never visited in the Maoist affected areas. many points in her article is not true.

Neither @Keel or @sabena siddiqi are interested in facts. I tried giving them the real picture, but they are more interested in propaganda than reality.

 

[DIRECT ACTION]

Neither @Keel or @sabena siddiqi are interested in facts. I tried giving them the real picture, but they are more interested in propaganda than reality.

they are pakistanis.. they are programmed to believe their military propaganda..

 

[Keel]

ofcource, we are comparing india with japan, and we are inspired by them. that is why we are one of the fastest developing nations.

then you have a very very very long way to go

we are living in india and we understand better than a pakistani writer who never visited in the Maoist affected areas. many points in her article is not true.

what are these points?

 

[Nihil]

what are these points?

I had mentioned the points before in this thread too:
Let me judge your claims - Naxals are CPI(ML) not CPI(M). CPI(M) is in power in Tripura, and the two parties have no single member in common.
UAVs are specifically not used in Naxal operations. There has been a lot of debate in India bout it, with the Air Force refusing, and the CRPF demanding drone usage.
Which past two years were more lethal? The most lethal years were 2009 and 2010, and since the death of Kishenji in 2011, their power has actually waned. You could have also mentioned that the TMC government in West Bengal came to power using Naxals, especially in Lalgarh, and then went against them as soon as they were in power. Again, all of this is common knowledge. No super-secret sources!
Their grass root support is also highly exaggerated, as they often physically prevent villagers from voting, threatening them with death. Fear, rather than support is a better term.

 

[Keel]

Neither @Keel or @sabena siddiqi are interested in facts. I tried giving them the real picture, but they are more interested in propaganda than reality.

Ms Siddiqi's article contains many details
Her content is adding values to what other articles have published on the subject around the world

India's Naxalites Remain a Force to be Reckoned With | Daniel Wagner
http://csis.org/publication/modern-insurgency-india’s-evolving-naxalite-problem-0
Flaws in India's Strategy to Counter the Maoist Insurgency / ISN

Maoists in India: The Naxalite Insurgency | EM Burlingame - Academia.edu

 

[Nihil]

Ms Siddiqi's article contains many details
Her content is adding values to what other articles have published on the subject around the world

India's Naxalites Remain a Force to be Reckoned With | Daniel Wagner
http://csis.org/publication/modern-insurgency-india’s-evolving-naxalite-problem-0
Flaws in India's Strategy to Counter the Maoist Insurgency / ISN

Maoists in India: The Naxalite Insurgency | EM Burlingame - Academia.edu

Two of those articles I have read before, and are good. I have specifically pointed out the mistakes in her article, and I fail to understand how a wrong article adds value.
The only value it adds is to lies and propaganda.

 

[Keel]

I had mentioned the points before in this thread too:
Let me judge your claims - Naxals are CPI(ML) not CPI(M). CPI(M) is in power in Tripura, and the two parties have no single member in common.

I didnt make the claim
You are confused in this very basic point so I wonder if you can make anything rational

UAVs are specifically not used in Naxal operations. There has been a lot of debate in India bout it, with the Air Force refusing, and the CRPF demanding drone usage.
Which past two years were more lethal? The most lethal years were 2009 and 2010, and since the death of Kishenji in 2011, their power has actually waned. You could have also mentioned that the TMC government in West Bengal came to power using Naxals, especially in Lalgarh, and then went against them as soon as they were in power. Again, all of this is common knowledge. No super-secret sources!
Their grass root support is also highly exaggerated, as they often physically prevent villagers from voting, threatening them with death. Fear, rather than support is a better term.

How do you know if your government and media are censoring the news on the insurgency movemens which however have been leaked out to other reports that I've quoted above

Two of those articles I have read before, and are good. I have specifically pointed out the mistakes in her article, and I fail to understand how a wrong article adds value.
The only value it adds is to lies and propaganda.

1. her article is an update
2. her article gives specific numbers
3. her article gives an evaluation of the seriousness of the naxalite movement over others like what is happening in Kashmir
4. her article contains solemn comments by some prominent figures of India which add credibilty to the article
5. value is added as a result of all of the above and may be more

 

[aazar]

There are hundreds of anti-nuclear movements currently active in India. Those anti-nuclear activists have genuine reason behind their protests. 1st of all nuclear plants are lethal when it comes to nuclear radiations which frequently release from nuclear plants. 2ndly waste disposal is yet another issue where even more developed states are failed in order to develop reliable mechanism for waste disposal. Unfortunately, India has neither waste disposal plan nor proper mechanism for radiation exposure. We have witnessed many birth defects among the people living near Indian nuclear plants. In addition to that Nexal and Maoist separatists can carry terror attacks on nuclear plants, Yet Modi government is unable to address such issues of great concern.

 

[Keel]

There are hundreds of anti-nuclear movements currently active in India. Those anti-nuclear activists have genuine reason behind their protests. 1st of all nuclear plants are lethal when it comes to nuclear radiations which frequently release from nuclear plants. 2ndly waste disposal is yet another issue where even more developed states are failed in order to develop reliable mechanism for waste disposal. Unfortunately, India has neither waste disposal plan nor proper mechanism for radiation exposure. We have witnessed many birth defects among the people living near Indian nuclear plants. In addition to that Nexal and Maoist separatists can carry terror attacks on nuclear plants, Yet Modi government is unable to address such issues of great concern.

The cases of nuclear tragedies really open up a new dimension to the many causes of the severe and widespread uprisings
I have not seen such uproars crying in the Indian community in the media, well at least not on PDF

 

[Phenomenal]

Everything is "okay", but it all depends on what you write. I look forward to your published links when you are able to post them here.

==================

Edit: Just reading the titles of your articles is informative

https://pk.linkedin.com/pub/sabena-siddiqi/22/3b8/b16

Hi
You go by a fake Muslim name, so sweet
You are Amritva Sarkar

AMRITAVA SARKAR
Studied at Haldia Institute of Technology
LinkedIn | LinkedIn

Hahahaha
Now it explains it ...
Lol

Hi
You go by a fake Muslim name, so sweet
You are Amritva Sarkar

AMRITAVA SARKAR
Studied at Haldia Institute of Technology
LinkedIn | LinkedIn

Hahahaha
Now it explains it ...
Lol

Seriously, we Pakistanis never have so much time to spare to make fake ids ...calling yourself 'Yahudoqadiani' and trolling our posts
ROFL