The most vulnerable fault line of Pakistan is interior Sindh

[proud.pakistani]

I think the most vulnerable fault line in Pakistan is Sindh. All thanks to PPP and Zardari extreme corruption, interior Sindh literally falls into stone age era. The situation is really bad in rural areas and I am sure Indian's can exploit local youth for a few thousand dollars.

The situation is very alarming so we must kick out PPP in Sindh immediately and invest in creating more jobs, SEZs etc to empower youth.

 

[Death Professor]

hard task, the issue is they are kept illiterate and to them:

Ajj bhi bhutto zinda hai....

 

[valkyr_96]

I think the most vulnerable fault line in Pakistan is Sindh. All thanks to PPP and Zardari extreme corruption, interior Sindh literally falls into stone age era. The situation is really bad in rural areas and I am sure Indian's can exploit local youth for a few thousand dollars.

The situation is very alarming so we must kick out PPP in Sindh immediately and invest in creating more jobs, SEZs etc to empower youth.

The Army i believe had an outreach program and now also recruits from those regions (apart for the obvious centers). I have been told that it does wonders for their morale as it only take a call to have a truck full of jawans.

 

[proud.pakistani]

The Army i believe had an outreach program and now also recruits from those regions (apart for the obvious centers). I have been told that it does wonders for their morale as it only take a call to have a truck full of jawans.

I don't think it's enough. Picking a handful of people out of millions of population won't have any effect on the issue I am highlighting.

 

[Respect4Respect01]

nothing much will change in Pakistan until we get rid of 18th amendment.

 

[AsifIjaz]

After the coal plants in thar, there need to be new industries set up in central eastern and western side of sindh.
Best solution is to divide sindh in 2 provinces (north and south) and let kashmore join south punjab. The central and northern sindh is an impoverished area where bhutto is alive... And this area require the most attention in terms of social uplift

 

[TheNoob]

Interior sindh needs education on nationalism.

But that is going to be hard because of not just bhutto, but also of ethnic divisions.
You should understand that there are people who do not like a certain ethnic group up north, and much less the molvis.

There are many factors, they aren't all just blind for no reason.
its been an issue for decades and will remain to be an issue unless we find a common unity factor among all four provinces.

 

[proud.pakistani]

Interior sindh needs education on nationalism.

But that is going to be hard because of not just bhutto, but also of ethnic divisions.
You should understand that there are people who do not like a certain ethnic group up north, and much less the molvis.

There are many factors, they aren't all just blind for no reason.
its been an issue for decades and will remain to be an issue unless we find a common unity factor among all four provinces.

And that common unity factor is Islam and Islam only!

 

[Village life]

Interior Sindh is worse than Moenjo daro,and urban sindh is filled with garbage and filth no where to go , dear these mfs have ruined Sindh,

 

[TheNoob]

And that common unity factor is Islam and Islam only!

Keep telling yourself that.
Islam is that one little string out of the thick broken rope that is keeping us together.

It is not the entire thing that is supposed to keep us together.

 

[proud.pakistani]

Keep telling yourself that.
Islam is that one little string out of the thick broken rope that is keeping us together.

It is not the entire thing that is supposed to keep us together.

Probably you need to learn why Pakistan was created and what was the main idea behind it. Moving away from core ideas will make us only weaker.

 

[Jaanbaz]

Went to interior Sindh a long time ago, it really is like going back in time and yes its true Bhutto is pretty much a demi god there but in larger towns there is thirst for change.

 

[CriticalThinker02]

If we can take out Altaf Hussain and his goons, we certainly can take out the raj of bhutto.

 

[TheNoob]

Probably you need to learn why Pakistan was created and what was the main idea behind it. Moving away from core ideas will make us only weaker.

Just chest thumping this one ideal isn't going to make us progress any further.
But khair, keep living with that mindset.


I also never said Islam is the fault here.
All I said is just keeping the chains together using peoples religion isn't the only thing thats needed.


Islam is natural in this region.
We could of been many things. That is out of the question when it comes to the state.

 

[Indus Pakistan]

From another thread -

Sindh has some serious issues and PPP, Murad, MQM, Altaf Bhai are the symptoms of that. The real issue is the Mohajir/Sindhi, urban/rural divide which of courses throws up the symptoms. The reality is mass migration from India into Sindh failed to integrate. That failure of integration has created deep divides in Sindhi polity which of course feeds the politics that you see played out in that province. And Murad/Altaf Bhai are the symptoms of that structural malaise at the heart of Sindh.

I am reminded of Northern Ireland in UK which suffers from similar problems despite being part of one of the worlds most prosperous, mature, competent states in the world. I am reminded of this as my daughter who is doing masters in higher education policy has just come back from Belfast after a stint there at Queens University Belfast as part of her research into the education system there and issues revolving around the divide they have. Listening to her 'on the ground report' was interesting as it painted a picture far worse then UK media covers. But I thought perhaps the same sociological issues are playing out in Sindh as well.

Perhaps a ethnic Sindhi can give some input. Sindh for me is the least understood part of Pakistan. Sindh has probably one of the most glorious history in South Asia but today it seems to be struggling. The Sindhi's fight against the British invasion in 1843 and their subsequent defeat at Battle of Miani which led them to being enslaved as part of British India is truely inspiring.

Yet today Sindhi people seem to be a dormant quantity. That puzzles me.