What's new

Tensions as Paris suburb tries to stop Muslim street prayers

Shahzaz ud din

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 12, 2017
Messages
7,877
Reaction score
14
Country
Pakistan
Location
Canada
Tensions as Paris suburb tries to stop Muslim street prayers
JEFFREY SCHAEFFER and NICOLAS GARRIGA | AP | Published — Friday 10 November 2017

CLICHY-LA-GARENNE, France: Tensions erupted Friday as French officials and residents of a Paris suburb tried to block Muslims from praying in the street — a dispute that reflects nationwide problems with mosque shortages.
No one was hurt in the skirmishes in Clichy-la-Garenne, but both sides appeared to be digging in their heels in the dispute over prayer space in the town.
Carrying a large banner reading “Stop Illegal Street Prayers,” Mayor Remi Muzeau led more than 100 demonstrators Friday in a show of force to dissuade Muslims from praying on the town’s market square. Worshippers have been praying there every Friday for months to protest the closure of a prayer room.
A few dozen worshippers tried to pray anyway but sought to avoid confrontation with the protesters and retreated to a less visible spot. But the demonstrators squeezed them toward a wooden wall.
As worshippers chanted “Allahu akbar,” or “God is great” in Arabic, the larger group of demonstrators loudly sang the French national anthem. Some held French flags and a crucifix aloft.
Amid pushing and shoving, a banner the worshippers were carrying reading “United for a Grand Mosque of Clichy” was torn down.
Police with shields then formed a human barricade between the groups and Muslims eventually unrolled their rugs on the pavement, took off their shoes and held their prayers.
When the incident was over, the worshippers clapped, and the mayor pledged to come back again next week — as did the Muslim worshippers.
“We’ll do it every Friday if necessary,” said Muzeau.
“I must assure the tranquility and freedom of the people in my city,” he said. “We must not allow this to happen in our country. Our country, the French Republic is tarnished.”
Hamid Kazed, president of the Union of Muslim Associations of Clichy, who led the prayers, said, “We are going to continue until there’s a dialogue for a definitive venue.”
“That’s what they want. To divide the citizens,” he said. “We are not fundamentalists. We are for Islam of France.”
The demonstrators were joined by the president of the Paris region, Valerie Pecresse, and officials and residents of other Paris suburbs
While Islam has long been France’s No. 2 religion, the country has a chronic shortage of mosques for its estimated 5 million Muslims. Muslims in several towns have resorted to praying in the streets, fueling the anti-immigrant sentiment of far-right National Front leader Marine Le Pen.
Clichy Muslims had been renting a prayer hall from City Hall. But the town’s mayor decided to turn that space into a library for the town’s 60,000 residents, and the prayer hall was shut down in March following a court battle.
City Hall says Muslims can worship at a new Islamic cultural and prayer center, already used by hundreds, that the town inaugurated last year. However some Muslims say the new facility is too small, remote and doesn’t meet safety standards.
 
. .
I hate these kinds of muslims this why we have masjids and plus france is a Christian country respect the law of the land .

Excuse me?!! What's wrong with what they did?!! France is a SECULAR country, it recognizes no religion. The town's mayor shouldn't be harassing a religious minority. That type of behavior spits in the face of secularism and the French constitution.

Constitution of France 1958 (rev. 2008) Article 1

"France shall be an indivisible, secular, democratic and social Republic. It shall ensure the equality of all citizens before the law, without distinction of origin, race or religion. It shall respect all beliefs. It shall be organised on a decentralized basis."
 
. . .
Excuse me?!! What's wrong with what they did?!! France is a SECULAR country, it recognizes no religion. The town's mayor shouldn't be harassing a religious minority. That type of behavior spits in the face of secularism and the French constitution.

Constitution of France 1958 (rev. 2008) Article 1

"France shall be an indivisible, secular, democratic and social Republic. It shall ensure the equality of all citizens before the law, without distinction of origin, race or religion. It shall respect all beliefs. It shall be organised on a decentralized basis."

Respecting all religions doesn't mean that someone should practise their religion in a way that gets in the face of other folks.

People clogging the streets to offer prayer is exactly that.
 
. . . .
It's the only way to get people's attention. If you don't want them praying in a building then what the town mayor is essentially saying that they have to pray in the streets. So they did that.

I think they should focus their energies on acquiring a new place of prayer, but let that be. We agree to disagree on this one.
 
.
The french authorities always have and had a negative attitude towards French Muslims when it comes to the point of acquiring a place to be used as mosque by Muslims or to construct a mosque within french boundaries. French are demolishing old churches to convert them into parking lots, bars or night clubs but don't sell them to Muslims for prayers putting forward the logic that such action will tarnish the sanctity of the church :rolleyes:. Yes, the french constitution is secular but the attitude of french authorities isn't. French Muslims have acquired houses to be used as prayer places but such temporary measures are becoming inadequate to accommodate an increasing number of Muslims which come to offer prayers.
 
Last edited:
.
I hate these kinds of muslims this why we have masjids and plus france is a Christian country respect the law of the land .
France is not a Christian country. It used to be many years ago. It is secular now.
 
.
I wonder if a bunch of Chinese are doing tai chi in public... would this still be an issue? We see this here in North America


Having said that... it is their country... so their rules. These guys need to leave france alone in peace. You don't belong there.
 
.
I hate these kinds of muslims this why we have masjids and plus france is a Christian country respect the law of the land .

Read the article.

a dispute that reflects nationwide problems with mosque shortages.Worshippers have been praying there every Friday for months to protest the closure of a prayer room.
A few dozen worshippers tried to pray anyway but sought to avoid confrontation with the protesters and retreated to a less visible spot. But the demonstrators squeezed them toward a wooden wall.
 
. .

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom