Telangana: India new state protest enters 18th day

[jha]

I am not saying that this is a lingual problem. But my friend, born & raised in Andhra Pradesh told me that the people of Telangana see themselves as different from the rest of the people in Andhra Pradesh, & feel they have been neglected in the past. I also remember listening to this Muslim speak (I believe he belonged to Telangana) who mentioned Hyderabad Deccan's history pre-1947, & how they had been neglected afterwards in every way, as well as their religion:

KCR is not Muslim..He was speaking to Muslims...Another power hungry fellow..

 

[CorporateAffairs]

I want to get an opinion from Indian members on this. My friend is from Andhra Pradesh, she says that the people from Telangana speak a different kind of Telugu (it has Urdu mixed in it) compared to what is spoken else where

Wrong. Only people in the city of Hyd mix urdu and speak hindi. Telugu is never mixed with urdu. having said that there is a pronounciation difference between different parts of AndhraPradesh.

This happens in all states of India. Tamil spoken in Chennai is different from Tamil spoken in Mudarai or Trichy.

So, not an issue at all.

That makes me think it is pretty much a communal issue.

No. Muslim is still a small number and a minority in Telangana districts as well.
Infact the muslim political parties are aganist formation on seperate Telangana state.

But then, there have been elements of, & linkages made to the Maoists as well to Telangana. Will the Maoists get stronger or weaker when Telangana is created? We all know that Jharkhand was created from Bihar, & Maoism has increased in that state.

Good Q bro.

Yes, naxals (read as maoists) may get some foothold in Telangana. However, there are no proofs or evedance that it will happen.


Telangana demand is a political demand. People are being mislead and taken to the path of demonstrations and bandhs. Telangana demand is a cause and effect of mis-rule by earlier chief ministers.


Should wait and see how Center responds.

 

[53fd]

Let me ask u ..u inturn can ask ur friend...if and when Telangana is created..what will be the population %age of Muslims in Telanaga??

I know that Andhra Pradesh has a Hindu majority. I know that Hyderabad Deccan had, prior to 1947, a Hindu majority. I never denied any of these things. My point is that there might be a lot more to Telangana than what is being put, & I just wanted to explore another angle. I might be wrong though about any aspect of communalism, I'm reiterating what my friend said about Telangana. On the other hand, a few Maoists were arrested in Andhra Pradesh a few days ago as well. I am interested in finding out whether Telangana will fare differently from Chhattisgarh & Jharkhand, or follow their lead.

 

[CorporateAffairs]

I am interested in finding out whether Telangana will fare differently from Chhattisgarh & Jharkhand, or follow their lead.

Yes, it will. Becoz they will have Hyd, a cosmopolitian city and the other two states u mentioned doesnt have a city like Hyd.

---------- Post added at 02:39 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:36 PM ----------

I know that Hyderabad Deccan had, prior to 1947, a Hindu majority. I never denied any of these things.

Till 3 decades Hyderabad is a Muslim majority (only city of Hyd). Now, the scenario has changed. Hyd has a hindu majority now. Its like 45%, 30% share hindus and muslims.

 

[shuridh khan]

Yes, it will. Becoz they will have Hyd, a cosmopolitian city and the other two states u mentioned doesnt have a city like Hyd.

---------- Post added at 02:39 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:36 PM ----------



Till 3 decades Hyderabad is a Muslim majority (only city of Hyd). Now, the scenario has changed. Hyd has a hindu majority now. Its like 45%, 30% share hindus and muslims.

brother you are right hydrabad city has now hindu majority.but your numbers are wrong according to 2001 cencus hindus are 55.40% not 45% & muslims are 40.20%not 30%.others are 4.40%.i agree with you totally telengana issue is a regional issue.it is not a commnual issue.

 

[Vasily Zaytsev]

In fact, the muslims are against the formation of the state of Telangana. The Mp from hyderabad, Oyesi who is a congress boot licker opposed the formation of telangan. The muslims fear that after the formation of the state they will loose the most because in telangan TRS and BJP are strong.

 

[CorporateAffairs]

brother you are right hydrabad city has now hindu majority.but your numbers are wrong according to 2001 cencus hindus are 55.40% not 45% & muslims are 40.20%not 30%.others are 4.40%.i agree with you totally telengana issue is a regional issue.it is not a commnual issue.

The % given are only for his idea and not as per population sensus

 

[jha]

brother you are right hydrabad city has now hindu majority.but your numbers are wrong according to 2001 cencus hindus are 55.40% not 45% & muslims are 40.20%not 30%.others are 4.40%.i agree with you totally telengana issue is a regional issue.it is not a commnual issue.

If the issue was a communal one than it had absolutely no chance to even get considered...States can not be created om communal grounds...

 

[shuridh khan]

If the issue was a communal one than it had absolutely no chance to even get considered...States can not be created om communal grounds...

bro it is not a commnual issue.the minority population of the whole total talengana region(including hyderabad) won't be more than 15%.its a issue betwen two regions of andhra state.actually its a issue of rivaly betwen costal region of andhra & telengana region of andhra.it is not a commnual issue

 

[Kazhugu]

I want to get an opinion from Indian members on this. My friend is from Andhra Pradesh, & she says that the people from Telangana speak a different kind of Telugu (it has Urdu mixed in it) compared to what is spoken else where. That makes me think it is pretty much a communal issue. But then, there have been elements of, & linkages made to the Maoists as well to Telangana. Will the Maoists get stronger or weaker when Telangana is created? We all know that Jharkhand was created from Bihar, & Maoism has increased in that state.

i cant tell about the others...but labguage is the same...maybe ur friend is from the "old city" and thinks they speak telugu with urdu admixture..nope...they were actually the ones who fought violently against the tyrant nizam...the problem is a pure economic one between coastal andhra and telengana...

 

[Leader]

Tension at Telangana student's funeral procession

Hyderabad, March 25:
The suicide of a student for separate statehood to Telangana has brought the issue back into focus with a shutdown being observed Sunday in Warangal district amid tension and some groups calling for a two-day protest.

Tension prevailed in Warangal town Sunday during the funeral procession of MBA student Bhojya Naik, who immolated himself Saturday to protest the delay in carving out Telangana state.

Hundreds attended the funeral procession during which the protesters attacked the houses of Congress leaders and an office of the party. They also stoned the statue of former prime minister Rajiv Gandhi.

more

Tension at Telangana student's funeral procession | Siasat

poor chap... RIP

 

[Neuro]

Perennial droughts in southern Telangana region is root of all evils. Govt. should propose the plan to connect all south Indian rivers ,built new dams , irrigate all possible drought regions and declare rivers as national property. This move will facilitate to alleviate enmity among states and it will avoid Telangana type issues in future . In addition rivers nationalisation is gud for our economic growth. But wat our govt. thinks regarding tis issue nobody knws.....