State Run Afghan Broadcaster is Airing this in Afghanistan

[crankthatskunk]

This is anti Pakistan indoctrination and brainwashing of public at the highest (state) level. This is more destructive than a nuke weapon. Generation of Afghan will hate Pakistan.

They already do. This propaganda had been going on for 20 years. What do you think Indian consulates were doing apart from financing and training the terrorists against Pakistan!!

I work with Afghan, all of them are brainwashed against Pakistan; they hate Pakistan.

 

[Samurai_assassin]

20 years have gone by india has successfully implanted the seeds of hate in Afghan youth against Pakistan. Pakistanis have been slow and foolish to counter Indian propaganda.

 

[TNT]

We need to answer them properly, these scumbags are crossing all limits. The US and NATO raped them but Pakistan is their enemy. I say kick out their ambassador, our stupid govt n military are too docile and pacifist.
They are beating Pakistanis everywhere and we have 3 million of their refugees here enjoying a tax free life. They destroyed Pakistani businesses and labour. We are beghairat i guess, or else we should make videos of their refugees dragged in streets.
I am so angry these days and if i find a afghan maajar misbehave even slightly, i am going to tie him up upside down and send that video to these dumb pigs.

 

[Dalit]

20 years have gone by india has successfully implanted the seeds of hate in Afghan youth against Pakistan. Pakistanis have been slow and foolish to counter Indian propaganda.

Bro, Afghans always hated Pakistan long before India even came into the picture. Bacha Khan hated Pakistan because he simply wanted to hate Pakistan. We have to understand that both India and Afghanistan have territorial disputes with Pakistan. Much of the hatred can be attributed to territorial disputes. Pakistani support for Taliban also stems from this fact. We have been playing this Cold War and Taliban game to keep a lid on things. The unfortunate truth is that you cannot keep a lid on things forever by playing such games. Eventually the dispute reaches a boiling point. Time has come to acknowledge that we must look the Indians and Afghans straight in the eyes and fight it out. Both Afghanistan and India want to fight a war against Pakistan and capture territory.

Pakistani army, politicians and its people cannot convince both Afghanistan and India through dialogue. You have to understand how nationalistic and hateful both India and Afghanistan are against Pakistan.

We need to answer them properly, these scumbags are crossing all limits. The US and NATO raped them but Pakistan is their enemy. I say kick out their ambassador, our stupid govt n military are too docile and pacifist.
They are beating Pakistanis everywhere and we have 3 million of their refugees here enjoying a tax free life. They destroyed Pakistani businesses and labour. We are beghairat i guess, or else we should make videos of their refugees dragged in streets.
I am so angry these days and if i find a afghan maajar misbehave even slightly, i am going to tie him up upside down and send that video to these dumb pigs.

These pacifists have no courage to say enough. They will sit in talks, get humiliated and accused and still promise to make peace. The other side doesn't want peace. The other side wants land. Ultimately the conflict between Pakistan and India/Afghanistan is about territory.

 

[Dalit]

20 years have gone by india has successfully implanted the seeds of hate in Afghan youth against Pakistan. Pakistanis have been slow and foolish to counter Indian propaganda.

This is a myth in my opinion. Afghans and Indians have the support of the Western world. Western media and power structures also support Indian and Afghan narrative through thick and thin. Even if Pakistan tried to counter Indian/Afghan propaganda it won't get much coverage nor credibility. The Western world has its favorite and it isn't Pakistan.

Instead of focusing our attention on winning the propaganda war, we have done the right thing by allying with China and certain regional countries. The focus should be to strengthen regional cooperation and slowly move away from Western orbit. Even this is something which stings the Western bloc. The Western propaganda regarding CPEC and Pakistan's relationship with regional countries is known to everyone.

The Western world has a specific plan with Pakistan and that hasn't succeeded. They want to denuclearise Pakistan for a very long time. They want to balkanise Pakistan along ethnic lines. Merge certain areas with Afghanistan and India. Keep Baluchistan for themselves due to geostrategic advantages. This is absolutely no secret and many Western think tanks have floated this idea for decades. We are kidding ourselves to believe that everything will be ok if we continue with dialogue.

 

[Samurai_assassin]

Bro, Afghans always hated Pakistan long before India even came into the picture. Bacha Khan hated Pakistan because he wanted to hate Pakistan. We have to understand that both India and Afghanistan have territorial disputes with Pakistan. Much of the hatred can be attributed to territorial disputes. Pakistani support for Taliban also stems from this fact. We have been playing this Cold War and Taliban game to keep a lid on things. The unfortunate truth is that you cannot keep a lid on things forever by playing such games. Eventually the dispute reaches a boiling point. Time has come to acknowledge that we must look the Indians and Afghans straight in the eyes and fight it out. Both Afghanistan and India want to fight a war against Pakistan and capture territory.

Pakistani army, politicians and its people cannot convince both Afghanistan and India through dialogue. You have to understand how nationalistic and hateful both India and Afghanistan are against Pakistan.


These pacifists have no courage to say enough. They will sit in talks, get humiliated and accused and still promise to make peace. The other side doesn't want peace. The other side wants land. Ultimately the conflict between Pakistan and India/Afghanistan is about territory.

I have interacted with Gujurati Hindus, Sikhs and Bangladeshis. We have got on despite the cricket rivalry and occasional banter. Afghans have been different, they have come with his hard cold venomous hatred for Pakistanis. I only came across Afghans after the US invasion of their nation. Prior to this I never once had any interaction with them.
Despite their hatred i fully support the implementation of a border manned with observation towers, trenches.

 

[Dalit]

I have interacted with Gujurati Hindus, Sikhs and Bangladeshis. We have got on despite the cricket rivalry and occasional banter. Afghans have been different, they have come with his hard cold venomous hatred for Pakistanis. I only came across Afghans after the US invasion of their nation. Prior to this I never once had any interaction with them.
Despite their hatred i fully support the implementation of a border manned with observation towers, trenches.

Afghans are indeed a very different breed opposed to Subcontinental types. Ethnically different. Even we the Pakistani Pashtun cannot relate to the Afghans. We are just different in every sense. I have already explained to you that territorial dispute lies at the heart of our conflict between India and Afghanistan. Unless we don't address this problem from its root cause problems will persist.

Normally nations hold dialogue and try to find a resolution. The other sole alternative is war. The Indians and Afghans seek war. Their actions speak volume.

Short term solution is fencing, manning the border etc. Long term solution is to prepare for war.

 

[CrazyZ]

Bro, Afghans always hated Pakistan long before India even came into the picture. Bacha Khan hated Pakistan because he wanted to hate Pakistan. We have to understand that both India and Afghanistan have territorial disputes with Pakistan. Much of the hatred can be attributed to territorial disputes.

Agreed, this hate has always existed....but it has been amplified the last 20 years. More venomous and more persuasive.

New Kabul regime has been aggressively pushing this animosity for last 20 years. I recall an incident when the USA accidentally bombed Afghan civilians, but Kabul news agencies reported it was Pakistani artillery.

Kabul regime only complains about the Durand line but all there borders were established by outside powers. Even the ones with central Asia and Iran. This is why Afghanistan has so much ethnic overlap with its neighbors. No one in Kabul will speak about that. I suspect that some of this is remnant thinking from the old communist government.

In the end....its very very foolish for the Kabul regime to push a fight with Pakistan. They can't win and will be ruined if Pakistan counters. Cooperation and integration with Pakistan is in Afghanistan's benefit as the well as the regions. Mind sets must change in Kabul or they are doomed to disaster, IMO.

 

[Samurai_assassin]

Afghans are indeed a very different breed opposed to Subcontinental types. Ethnically different. Even we the Pakistani Pashtun cannot relate to the Afghans. We are just different in every sense. I have already explained to you that territorial dispute lies at the heart of our conflict between India and Afghanistan. Unless we don't address this problem from its root cause problems will persist.

Normally nations hold dialogue and try to find a resolution. The other sole alternative is war. The Indians and Afghans seek war. Their actions speak volume.

Short term solution is fencing, manning the border etc. Long term solution is to prepare for war.

Pakistan should have pushed for the Sikh separatists to keep Modi on edge and occupied. Gujuratis are not fighters, Very good business people but very weak. The direct threat posed to Pak is from the western front. Afghans have been hired mercenaries for india.

Afghans are indeed a very different breed opposed to Subcontinental types. Ethnically different. Even we the Pakistani Pashtun cannot relate to the Afghans. We are just different in every sense. I have already explained to you that territorial dispute lies at the heart of our conflict between India and Afghanistan. Unless we don't address this problem from its root cause problems will persist.

Normally nations hold dialogue and try to find a resolution. The other sole alternative is war. The Indians and Afghans seek war. Their actions speak volume.

Short term solution is fencing, manning the border etc. Long term solution is to prepare for war.

By the way what is the lady singing in the video? Do not understand the language.

 

[Dalit]

Agreed, this hate has always existed....but it has been amplified the last 20 years. More venomous and more persuasive.

New Kabul regime has been aggressively pushing this animosity for last 20 years. I recall an incident when the USA accidentally bombed Afghan civilians, but Kabul news agencies reported it was Pakistani artillery.

Kabul regime only complains about the Durand line but all there borders were established by outside powers. Even the ones with central Asia and Iran. This is why Afghanistan has so much ethnic overlap with its neighbors. No one in Kabul will speak about that. I suspect that some of this is remnant thinking from the old communist government.

In the end....its very very foolish for the Kabul to push a fight with Pakistan. They can't win and will be ruined if Pakistan counter. Cooperation and integration with Pakistan is in Afghanistan's benefit as the well as the regions. Mind sets must change in Kabul or they are doomed to disaster, IMO.

Indian involvement in Afghanistan is obviously a big factor. India has misused the opportunity to fan more anti-Pakistan hatred. Although Afghans have always been avid Pakistan haters. Afghans have never needed any additional cheerleading by their Indian compatriots.

Our leaders need to look the Afghans in the eyes and tell them that Durand Line is the internationally recognized de facto border. If our leaders had the courage they would remind Afghan leaders during summits and international events. PM Imran Khan recently rebuffed Ghani during the Tashkent summit. Having reminded Ghani about the Durand Line border would have been a nice addition.

 

[ziaulislam]

Agreed, this hate has always existed....but it has been amplified the last 20 years. More venomous and more persuasive.

New Kabul regime has been aggressively pushing this animosity for last 20 years. I recall an incident when the USA accidentally bombed Afghan civilians, but Kabul news agencies reported it was Pakistani artillery.

Kabul regime only complains about the Durand line but all there borders were established by outside powers. Even the ones with central Asia and Iran. This is why Afghanistan has so much ethnic overlap with its neighbors. No one in Kabul will speak about that. I suspect that some of this is remnant thinking from the old communist government.

In the end....its very very foolish for the Kabul to push a fight with Pakistan. They can't win and will be ruined if Pakistan counter. Cooperation and integration with Pakistan is in Afghanistan's benefit as the well as the regions. Mind sets must change in Kabul or they are doomed to disaster, IMO.

Afghanistan like india uses pakistan for itd unity
Afghanistan as biden pointed out is not a country but an accident as a rrsult of three powers brokages..iran USSR and british empire

 

[Vapnope]

Did they conquer Pakistan or not?

For 20 years their trainers ensured them that Pakistan will be taken over and Durand line will end and everyone is running away. Their desperation is understandable.

 

[ziaulislam]

20 years have gone by india has successfully implanted the seeds of hate in Afghan youth against Pakistan. Pakistanis have been slow and foolish to counter Indian propaganda.

Liberalsalways hated pakistan
Minorities dont want pkistan terroities as it will be more porblems for them while talis support pakistan in some way hiven spritual connection with akora khattack

What pakistan need is game after..we need to spend some money to help build afghanistan
At minimum afghanistan talis would need help in governing reveunues & building a ring road that has been since destroyed..

 

[CrazyZ]

Indian involvement in Afghanistan is a big factor. India has obviously misused the opportunity to fan more anti-Pakistan hatred. Although Afghans have always by default been avid Pakistan haters.

Partially. The NA and survivors of the old communist government helped construct the new regime in Kabul. They already had deep animosities with Pakistan and used American funding to push it more broadly. TOLO and various other Afghan news agencies were made with American funding.....not Indian.

Afghanistan like india uses pakistan for itd unity

They try to. You left out that Kabul regime uses Pakistan to cover its own mistakes and stupidity.

 

[CrazyZ]

Did they conquer Pakistan or not?

For 20 years their trainers ensured them that Pakistan will be taken over and Durand line will end and everyone is running away. Their desperation is understandable.

My sense is that this thinking in the Kabul regime is hold over from the 1960's onward. In 1960's Kabul couldn't mess with USSR or Iran....so they settled on picking a fight with Pakistan. Can't say I understand their lunacy. Pakistan today is much more powerful then it was in the 60's....both in conventual and un-conventual military terms....plus it has nuclear weapons.

The new Kabul regime was better off picking Iran as the enemy to rally Afghans around, IMO. It would have made more sense for the USA and Kabul, IMO. USA could have taken Iraq and kept the Iranians busy with the Afghans to their east. Instead it choose to put Iranian plants in power in both Kabul and Baghdad. It never made any sense to me, since at the same time USA was pushing Iran as the enemy . Only way I could rationalize this was the Neocon-Zionist plan to simultaneously use Iran to mess up the Arabs but abuse Iran with sanctions so they could not get too powerful. Worked great for Israel.....but it was a disaster for the USA in the ME and Afghanistan.