What's new

South China Sea Forum

Philippines says Vietnam promotes peace in region by taking sea dispute with China to UN

Monday, 15 December, 2014


china_south_china_sea_xaw801_47145315.jpg

A new officially approved map of China includes the islands and maritime area that Beijing claims in the South China Sea. Photo: AP

Vietnam has helped ensure peace in the South China Sea dispute with Beijing by following the Philippines in seeking UN arbitration, Manila said, despite the fact that Beijing has refused to take part.

Beijing claims almost the entire energy-rich South China Sea, but Brunei, Malaysia, the Philippines, Vietnam and Taiwan also have claims. Only Brunei has not occupied and garrisoned territory in the potential flashpoint in the region.

Vietnam on Thursday submitted its position to a UN arbitration tribunal initiated by the Philippines over the festering dispute. China called on Vietnam to respect its sovereignty and has refused UN arbitration saying it has "indisputable" sovereignty over the Spratly Islands.

"The Vietnamese position is helpful in terms of promoting the rule of law and in finding peaceful and nonviolent solutions to the South China Sea claims based on international law…," the Philippine Foreign Ministry said.

"This promotes peace and stability in our region."

China, Vietnam and the Philippines are signatories to the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, which grants the right to explore and exploit resources within 200 nautical miles of a state's shore. Both Hanoi and Manila say Beijing is extending beyond the limit.

In May, China placed its largest mobile oil rig close to Vietnam's coast in the Paracel Islands that prompted angry protests in Hanoi against Chinese business interests. China calls them the Xisha Islands, and Vietnam the Hoang Sa Islands.

At the same time, Beijing began reclamation in the Spratly Islands and appeared to be building airstrips in the area.

Beijing has also seized control of Scarborough Shoal near the Philippines' main island of Luzon and chased civilian ships delivering supplies to Philippine-held Second Thomas Shoal in the Spratlys. The Philippines and Vietnam appear to be ending decades of distrust.

Last year, the two sides held a first-ever navy-to-navy talks and last month, Hanoi displayed its two most powerful missile-guided stealth frigates in Manila during a port call.

The two states will hold the first strategic defence dialogue early next year.

"Vietnam's legal opinion puts political weight on the Philippine legal case," Professor Rommel Banlaoi, a security analyst, said on television.


Philippines says Vietnam promotes peace in region by taking sea dispute with China to UN | South China Morning Post
 
Vietnam always shows China claims but never ever show their own claims. The fact is because their claim is not much different from China's.



wrong. vietnam claim is much smaller than china. check again the map: china claim virtually reaches our and other nations beaches.

we have a strong basis for our claim:
- international recognised eez waters and intercontinental shelfs
- sovereignty taken over from champa kingdom (15 century)
- sovereinty exercised during the nguyen dynasty
- sovereinty taken over from the french

in the last 2,000 years, until recently china has never exercised control and administration the south china sea in part or on the whole. besides, we have successfully settled sea demarcations with malaysia and indonesia. while china not. we only have a small overlap with the philippines. china took our islands in paracels and spratlys by force. we will never accept that.
 
Last edited:
There are NO good players. Every country is just grabbing anything that sticks out of the water.

Its free for all !!!
 
Vietnam always shows China claims but never ever show their own claims. The fact is because their claim is not much different from China's.




Look at those two maps and we know your words are no value ... :meeting:
 
amigo eastsea you know we have lost the islands and will lose more, take a sigar like me and chill
 
Earlier this year, the Philippines offered VietNam to share and discuss the Filipino's legal case and analysis (which is still not made public to anyone else).

A few days ago, VN sent a position note supporting the Philippines position that the tribunal do have jurisdiction over the dispute.

These are two clear signs that both VN and the Philippines are not planning to fight each other in court and will negotiate their overlapping claims. If they were planning to fight each other in court in the future, they wouldn't have shared their legal case with each other.
 
Oh really? :rofl: It looks nothing like it. China can't teach lessons in 'peaceful behavior' to anyone seeing its 'unpeaceful behavior' towards nations such as :

Vietnam
Taiwan
Japan
Indonesia
Philippines
India
Australia
USA
Malaysia
Brunei


Practice what you preach! :P :toast_sign:
Taiwan is not a nation.
 
Earlier this year, the Philippines offered VietNam to share and discuss the Filipino's legal case and analysis (which is still not made public to anyone else).

A few days ago, VN sent a position note supporting the Philippines position that the tribunal do have jurisdiction over the dispute.

These are two clear signs that both VN and the Philippines are not planning to fight each other in court and will negotiate their overlapping claims. If they were planning to fight each other in court in the future, they wouldn't have shared their legal case with each other.
Those islands r not important to VN, we dont need to argue wt a friend like Phil in the court. We may share the isls wt all ASEAN friends, but not China :pop:
 
Back
Top Bottom