Some results for PLAAF-PAF Shahee exercise

[aliaselin]

http://tv.cctv.com/2017/11/28/VIDECNHKfVBDidVTysZ0e2SB171128.shtml
Results are from CCTV documentary，so quite reliable.
1. In 2015 exercise, four J-8DH/F vs two JF-17, J-8DH/F were quickly shot down and the pilots are not even concerned about it;
2. In 2017 exercise, 1 J-8DH/F vs 2 Mirage 5, 2 Mirage 5 were shot down
3. In 2017 exercise, the leading character of the documentary had shot down 4 fighters from PAF in the whole exercise

 

[CriticalThought]

http://tv.cctv.com/2017/11/28/VIDECNHKfVBDidVTysZ0e2SB171128.shtml
Results are from CCTV documentary，so quite reliable.
1. In 2015 exercise, four J-8DH/F vs two JF-17, J-8DH/F were quickly shot down and the pilots are not even concerned about it;
2. In 2017 exercise, 1 J-8DH/F vs 2 Mirage 5, 2 Mirage 5 were shot down
3. In 2017 exercise, the leading character of the documentary had shot down 4 fighters from PAF in the whole exercise

Any info about JF-17 and J-11 in 2017?

 

[aliaselin]

Any info about JF-17 and J-11 in 2017?

In another report, two JF17 were shot down by one J11B

 

[CriticalThought]

In another report, two JF17 were shot down by one J11B

I think we have been through that one already. It was a non-representative outlier. What was the overall result for the two fighters?

 

[The_magnificent]

In another report, two JF17 were shot down by one J11B

Can you share that report ?

 

[Windjammer]

 

[Safriz]

So PAF turned put to be پھسڈّی?

 

[Windjammer]

After this it is highly expected that the Chinese Air Force will induct the Jf-17 in large numbers. India on the other hand is doomed now. It has no aircraft matching the JF-17. With the next block thunder around the corner the Rafales will also be out numbered and out matched!

We are actually fearing the day when Tejas ditches it's trailer.

 

[araz]

After this it is highly expected that the Chinese Air Force will induct the Jf-17 in large numbers. India on the other hand is doomed now. It has no aircraft matching the JF-17. With the next block thunder around the corner the Rafales will also be out numbered and out matched!

I have reported your post for flame baiting. We do not need people who cannot contribute positively.
Regards

 

[Hell hound]

3. In 2017 exercise, the leading character of the documentary had shot down 4 fighters from PAF in the whole exercise

Can you shed more light on this part.

 

[Maxpane]

paf was not good
?

 

[Imran Khan]

interesting results .

 

[aliaselin]

"Chinese Su-27" is a vague word because there are four kinds of Chinese Su-27 series, Su-27SK/J-11A，Su-30MK/MK2，J-11B/J-15A，J-16.

Can you shed more light on this part.

No detailed explanation from the video

What we can learn from the exercise results are:1. there are indeed big gap between 2nd generation fighters and 3rd generation fighters thus JF-17 can easily defeat J-8DH/F
2. The French fighters are boasted too much by the west. In the same generation combat, two Mirage V can not even match 1 J-8DH/F. Thus we can confer that there may be plentiful of brag about Mirage 2000 and Rafale.

 

[MastanKhan]

"Chinese Su-27" is a vague word because there are four kinds of Chinese Su-27 series, Su-27SK/J-11A，Su-30MK/MK2，J-11B/J-15A，J-16.


No detailed explanation from the video

What we can learn from the exercise results are:1. there are indeed big gap between 2nd generation fighters and 3rd generation fighters thus JF-17 can easily defeat J-8DH/F
2. The French fighters are boasted too much by the west. In the same generation combat, two Mirage V can not even match 1 J-8DH/F. Thus we can confer that there may be plentiful of brag about Mirage 2000 and Rafale.

Hi,

Mirage 3/5 are obsolete aircraft---.

 

[GriffinsRule]

Were those Mirage IIIs or Vs in the exercise?