What's new

Singapore is richer by over S$200B thanks to COVID-19, as Temasek announces record returns

Mista

SENIOR MEMBER
Joined
Jun 9, 2016
Messages
4,567
Reaction score
10
Country
Singapore
Location
Singapore

My admiration for Singapore mostly stems from how smartly and sustainably the entire country is financed.

In particular, how the government — by laws it has imposed on itself — is not permitted deficit spending and has to accumulate surpluses, which are profitably invested through Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS), GIC, and Temasek Holdings.

The last one of the three has just reported record returns of 24.5 per cent for the year ending 31 March 2021, buoyed by stock market rallies fuelled in no small part by global stimulus packages released into economies stricken by the COVID-19 crisis.

This has lifted the total portfolio value up from S$306 billion to S$381 billion — and the increase is likely to continue for as long as governments around the world are releasing fiscal and monetary measures to stave off deeper economic woes, with much of the funds pushing stock markets higher and higher.

In other words, after decades of prudent financial planning and state investment, Singapore is making money while others are desperately trying to save themselves from sinking.

Temasek’s shareholder return of S$75 billion alone is higher than the entire amount of S$53.7 billion in local relief spending packages passed in 2020 and 2021, propping up the economy, staving off retrenchments, helping Singaporean businesses weather the storm of the pandemic.

S’pore has gained S$235B in reserves in MAS, Temasek
That’s not all. While COVID-19 shook the world, Singapore’s foreign reserves under management of MAS have grown by another S$160 billion.

1626319778014.png



At the end of 2019, total official foreign reserves amounted to S$375 billion, growing to S$478 billion by end 2020 and S$535 billion by June 2021.

In total, Singapore has gained S$235 billion in reserves in these two entities (MAS and Temasek Holdings).

Even if we subtract the ca. S$54 billion it had to earmark for support packages in 2020 and 2021, it is still S$181 billion up — and this is even without GIC posting its results (due by the end of this month), which are bound to be similarly strong, as they are boosted by the same underlying causes.

While we don’t know the exact amount under GIC’s management, the net impact on reserves is bound to be in at least tens of billions of dollars as well.

As a result, even if we account for all the economic pains incurred by the pandemic and massive spending the government had to use to support the country, the city-state is easily over S$200 billion richer than it was before COVID-19 ravaged the world.

Of course, there’s a caveat. These gains are not necessarily permanent and may still fluctuate depending on the international situation and the demand for Singapore dollar.

However, this also highlights the simple genius of Singapore’s reserve system. It is designed in a way that not only yields healthy and steady returns over long-term, but its diversified investments act as shock-absorbers, balancing the impact of negative external events.

S’pore will not be disadvantaged regardless of economy conditions

Due to a robust combination of equities (for high growth) and government-issued securities like bonds (for security and stability), coupled with a strong currency, a global net creditor status (i.e. Singapore is a creditor to other countries and doesn’t have external, public debts to worry about), there’s hardly a situation in which the city-state would be bad off.

If the global economy is good, it’s obviously good for Singapore too.

If the global economy is bad but countries are using fiscal and monetary measures to stimulate their economies (like it is happening today), Singapore still benefits thanks to its foreign investments, even if domestic GDP is taking a temporary hit.

The cherry on top of it all is the fact that Singapore has no external public debt to speak of (since it can’t borrow to finance budgetary deficits), and it has now added another tool to make the most of its financial might.

Under the recently-passed SINGA, the government can borrow up to S$90 billion to finance long-term infrastructure investments, which is actually cheaper than if it wanted to unwind a portion of its reserves to do so. It would lose more in lost returns on investments than it has to pay to lenders.

In other words, even when it’s borrowing, Singapore is actually making more money than if it didn’t.

Unlike other countries, which are now taking on humongous levels of debt, pushing the burden on its repayment to future, ageing generations, Singapore is actually using debt to optimise the returns from its various investments and be even more resilient in the face of global crises.

In this particular Covid-19 pandemic, it has not made the country weaker, but wealthier than ever before.
 
.
Singapore seems to be imitating HK where govts follow ultra conservative hoarding style approach to finances whereas population have much lower quality of lives. The prime job of a govt is welfare of people not hoarding money. Debt is not dirty word - european, american, japanese, chinese take humongous debt and their citizens enjoy pretty good lifestyles.
 
.
Singapore seems to be imitating HK where govts follow ultra conservative hoarding style approach to finances whereas population have much lower quality of lives. The prime job of a govt is welfare of people not hoarding money. Debt is not dirty word - european, american, japanese, chinese take humongous debt and their citizens enjoy pretty good lifestyles.

the music stops eventually, thats when the US uses its military to wipe out its debt.
 
.
Singapore seems to be imitating HK where govts follow ultra conservative hoarding style approach to finances whereas population have much lower quality of lives.

Not comparable. Our housing is much more spacious and affordable than HK.

About two-thirds of the city’s (HK's) 800,000 public housing rental flats are smaller than 430 sq ft. For comparison, the average flat size in the greater Tokyo area was estimated at 643 sq ft last year. The average size of a Singapore flat was 1,100 sq ft.


Our undergraduates can start buying a flat even when they are studying and have no income, because of the subsidies which can offset the down payment.

Where's the money coming from?


Debt is not dirty word - european, american, japanese, chinese take humongous debt and their citizens enjoy pretty good lifestyles.

Spending more doesn't mean better outcomes.


1626323828719.png


1626323844244.png


The returns (we can spend up to half of the real returns) are supplementing our budget, while the countries you spoke off are using taxpayer's money to pay off their debt.

1626323777245.png


In fact, the returns on our reserves are already the largest source of our revenue, more than the GST or income tax.

1626323968792.png
 
.
Not comparable. Our housing is much more spacious and affordable than HK.




Our undergraduates can start buying a flat even when they are studying and have no income, because of the subsidies which can offset the down payment.

Where's the money coming from?




Spending more doesn't mean better outcomes.


View attachment 762382

View attachment 762383

The returns (we can spend up to half of the real returns) are supplementing our budget, while the countries you spoke off are using taxpayer's money to pay off their debt.

View attachment 762381

In fact, the returns on our reserves are already the largest source of our revenue, more than the GST or income tax.

View attachment 762384
Ok the oil sheik of Asia. Singapore makes money out of money in very smart way. Good investment capital stocks in Vietnam, China and other countries. You probably have lots of US stocks, haven’t much chinese stocks. Otherwise the returns would be less.
 
.
smart intelligent clean people
good Morales
puts most loud mouth Asians to shame

Singapore is how you run s country for the benefit of its citizens.

must be pride to say I'm from.singpore
 
.
smart intelligent clean people
good Morales
puts most loud mouth Asians to shame

Singapore is how you run s country for the benefit of its citizens.

must be pride to say I'm from.singpore
Good job Singapore. Trust in Singapore dollar than US dollar.
 
.
In the past, all central banks hoard gold. They are now forced by US imperialism to re-invest in US assets. And BTW, a large part of forex does not belongs to GoS or even citizen of Singapore. This is just hot monies, finding refuge and once they pull out, it could result to monetary disaster.

I have always doubt if many economists really understand international monetary system.

I suspect ALL western economic textbook deliberately arcanized monetary theory. Textbook writers simply do not want people to understand. Ask any students in Singapore who studied economics, they have a muddled mind on monetary theory, especially central banking and forex system. They cannot explain properly and they do not understand.

Not sure if Singapore increase in forex is bad event interpreted into good things.

丧事喜办
 
.
.
Singapore seems to be imitating HK where govts follow ultra conservative hoarding style approach to finances whereas population have much lower quality of lives. The prime job of a govt is welfare of people not hoarding money. Debt is not dirty word - european, american, japanese, chinese take humongous debt and their citizens enjoy pretty good lifestyles.
Singapore is a pretty good place to live. I know a friend of a friend that got a job transfer from Singapore to Kentucky....and requested to go back after a year....because of higher cost but lower quality life style.

I have always doubt if many economists really understand international monetary system.
Agreed. These are all gains on paper. They can disappear in the blink of an eye during the next financial crisis.
 
.
Not comparable. Our housing is much more spacious and affordable than HK.




Our undergraduates can start buying a flat even when they are studying and have no income, because of the subsidies which can offset the down payment.

Where's the money coming from?




Spending more doesn't mean better outcomes.


View attachment 762382

View attachment 762383

The returns (we can spend up to half of the real returns) are supplementing our budget, while the countries you spoke off are using taxpayer's money to pay off their debt.

View attachment 762381

In fact, the returns on our reserves are already the largest source of our revenue, more than the GST or income tax.

View attachment 762384
When a govt runs a surprlus - what does it mean ? it is collecting more money from people than it needs. And then it is managing this money by investing. This is definitely problematic - both morally and practically. How and when can this be justified?. Maybe in first few decades of singapore when most of its population was poor and uneducated the govt can justify saying it can manage people's money better than themselves.

But now how can singapore govt justify sitting on hundreds of billions instead of passing it over for the welfare of singapore people - either payouts or infrastructure ? It is quiet possible that the people can manage their own money even better than govt and can unleash innovation in society. if there is a specific purpose for which govt needs to hold the money - like say global warming or water issue then a specific institution must be set up to manage that and fund it. Singapore govt cannot simply hold on to singapore citizens money like that.

infact govts always had ability to raise debt at much lower rates than public. Thats a power they should use (within limits) to create more welfare for people.
 
.
Singapore seems to be imitating HK where govts follow ultra conservative hoarding style approach to finances whereas population have much lower quality of lives. The prime job of a govt is welfare of people not hoarding money. Debt is not dirty word - european, american, japanese, chinese take humongous debt and their citizens enjoy pretty good lifestyles.
When a government borrows tons of money in debt, it is doing that either because of some desperate situation or wanting to do some risky investments. The former may be justified. The latter should really be left for the citizens to do with their private money. Personally, I like what Singapore and HK are doing. Governments should be conservative so their citizens can be aggressive.
 
.
When a govt runs a surprlus - what does it mean ? it is collecting more money from people than it needs.

And how do you know that SG is running a surplus because "it is collecting more money from people than it needs"?

1626362903813.png


Before Covid, we're spending more than our tax revenue. The sole reason why we're having a surplus is because up to half of long-term real returns on our reserves can be used to supplement our budget.

But now how can singapore govt justify sitting on hundreds of billions instead of passing it over for the welfare of singapore people - either payouts or infrastructure ?


By spending a part of the long term returns on the people. As indicated above, we are already spending more than what we collect. The NIRC is already our largest source of revenue, and it is still growing faster than our tax revenue.

You can say that the performance of fund managers in our SWFs have greater implications on our budget than a tweak in tax policy lol.

BOOST FROM NET INVESTMENT RETURNS

The Net Investment Returns Contribution (NIRC) continues to be the largest contributor to government coffers, and is expected to bring in some $19.6 billion this year - a 7.8 per cent increase over last year.

The returns from Singapore's invested reserves have been the single largest source of government revenue since 2016, outweighing tax revenue sources such as corporate and personal income taxes and the goods and services tax.

The NIRC comprises up to 50 per cent of the net investment returns on net assets invested by the Monetary Authority of Singapore, GIC and Temasek, the three entities which manage and invest Singapore's reserves, and up to 50 per cent of the net investment income derived from past reserves from the remaining assets.


This is definitely problematic - both morally and practically. How and when can this be justified?

Lololol. So having returns worth 3% and still growing of our GDP to supplement our budget is problematic and not justified, but paying 3% of your GDP on interest and leaving snowballing debt for future generations is justified and not problematic - both morally and practically?

1626364249439.png
 
Last edited:
.
I am worry about sudden hike in forex. Not a good thing. This is not unlike Thailand 1997. There is a conspiracy of governments and economists to present forex as something 100% belongs to government or people. This is complete BS.

International monetary system is an extremely simple and common sense concept yet I bet 99% of Singapore citizen who took A level economics dont understand what they studied. The teacher dont understand what they are teaching.

This is a deliberate attempt of elites in fooling people. I am really surprise so many educated idiots in Singapore.

1626399750583.png
 
.
Singapreans are a bunch of selfish and arrogant educated idiots, but was fed lies and mis-informations in education.

In economics domain, not even Singapore institutional bankers who are doing forex trading knows what is going on completely. Those who really understand the system are central bankers and those working in IMF.

They will not reveal anything to people.

USA is only holding gold reserve, not forex. All countries of significant international standings hold gold.

Only pathetic nations hold forex.

This is a tragedy of titanic proportion for Singapore.

And one PDF economic statistician cheers in Bull crap. Something is wrong with Singapore education.

I suggestion he go read Marxism as I did many years ago. He wont regret it.


1626400333995.png
 
Last edited:
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom