Should Sharia be Established in Bangladesh?

[Cheetah786]

1) Arabic should be the National Language of Bangladesh.

2) Sharia Law should be the National Course of Justice for Bangladeshis.

3) Burkha and Beards must be Compulsory for Bangladeshis.

4) Hands should be Cut off for Robbery of Muslims.(That's True Sharia!)

According to Bangladeshis:



http://www.defence.pk/forums/bangla...-soon-cease-islamic-nation-4.html#post3437541

Bombay dude please share with us all whats your obsession with Bangladesh hey wait a minute its called Bangladesh not India so if bangalis wants sharia who the hell are you to tell them otherwise.

2) do u even understand what sharia is

3) Beards must be Compulsory for Most Sikhs in India i take it you also object to that or you only have a problem with Bangladesh.

4) you obviously don't have understanding of sharia law other wise you would have known that for first offense of stealing and proven in court without a shadow of doubt fingers are to be cut first then for prove able second offense hand to be cut off.(if you didn't learn the first time you sure will this time).

I am sure in India and around the world thieves learn from their mistakes after going to jail for few days and never ever re offend again or murderers for that matter give it a rest.

Wanna discuss about Islam then lets do it in civilized way following or reading propaganda published against Muslims by people who are trying to create hatred towards Muslims don't makes you and qualified to discuss Islam.

I highly doubt you no your own religion enough to carry out a conversation on it but here you are discussing Islams laws get a life.

 

[kobiraaz]

Muhammad (saw) was a Prophet before he became a ruler. He spread the message of Islam as a Prophet. But, after his win over the infidels of Mecca, he became also a RULER of his country where he enforced peace by introducing laws that he found suitable in his time and for that particular society of Arabia.

But, during this period he carried out two functions, one as a Prophet and the other as a Ruler. As a Ruler he enacted a few severe punishments for his subjects.

But, how can these severe laws be universal and eternal? Every ruler enacts laws that he finds suitable for his countrty. So did Muhammad (saw) in his time. All the subsequent rulers in Arabia and in all the muslim countries of the past, the rulers enacted their own laws, not necessarily these were Sharia laws.

Laws always evolve and laws enacted by one Muslim monarch in old days were certainly not compatible with laws of other Muslim countries. It is same also today. The rulers (Parliament/govt) of one Muslim country enacts one set of laws that may be quite different from the laws of other Muslim countries.

So, Sharia common laws must not be introduced in BD because these are certainly not eternal. BD already has been bestowed with British laws that are not based on Christianity. We better leave the laws as they are now and also try to improve on these SECULAR laws.

I will make it easy for you! Quran is for all people of all time, not only Muhammad(pbuh)! You can't change it. Removing hand of a thief is written in Quran, not in muhammad's constitution. You talk like Mutazila, a muslim sub sect! Unfortunately people rejected them and followed imam Hanifa Hanbal Shafi! Mu'tazila - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[eastwatch]

I will make it easy for you! Quran is for all people of all time, not only Muhammad(pbuh)! You can't change it. Removing hand of a thief is written in Quran, not in muhammad's constitution. You talk like Mutazila, a muslim sub sect! Unfortunately people rejected them and followed imam Hanifa Hanbal Shafi! Mu'tazila - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

You have put yourself at a rung lower than even an idolator by denoting and cursing others. What right do you have to do so? Have you been empowered by God (Nauzubillah)? What you say about Sharia laws is not Islam. These were only social laws which ignorants try to wrap with Islam. Religion deals with inner mind. Learn the basics of a religion. I wonder why some stupid Christians also do not start preachings like, 'An eye for an eye.' This is what Bible preached.

However, I found your brand of Sharia is also different from the brand preached by Mufti Amin (in the case of Hena-Billal). So, are you yourself not a Mu'tazil? Whatever it may be, Bangladesh will never seek Sharia laws, which are old and obsolate. Because, there will be many brands of Sharias. This is what you have proved in Hena-Billal case.

You also supported the burning of Budhist temples, isn't it? If you say no, you will become a Muta'zila because the Book also said about destroying idols. So, let us hear from you. Do not say something that will take to Jahannam.

We will not allow the last hundred years of efforts by the enlightened Muslims of the sub-continent to be thrown away with the introduction of an old set of laws that no one any more cares about. So, go away to Afghanistan and preach your brand of Islam. Ignorants there may accept you as a born-again Bin Laden.

 

[Major Shaheb]

1) Arabic should be the National Language of Bangladesh.

2) Sharia Law should be the National Course of Justice for Bangladeshis.

3) Burkha and Beards must be Compulsory for Bangladeshis.

4) Hands should be Cut off for Robbery of Muslims.(That's True Sharia!)

According to Bangladeshis:



http://www.defence.pk/forums/bangla...-soon-cease-islamic-nation-4.html#post3437541

You know nothing about Sharia Law. My response to you is as we always say: "Pagole ki na bole aar Sagole ki naa khay".

 

[mb444]

In a democracy people should have the right to freely choose any form of government they want, why is this controversial.

Sharia or secularism in extreme form in the hand of half educated idiots can cause massive damage.

In my opinion a middle ground should be found with the administration and the judiciary to be run by level headed individuals.

We are still following British colonial model, we should seek to form model of governance that best fits our people and complements our history and best serves our future development.