Should Pakistan Allow Afghan Professional Refugees to Live & Work?

[faani83]

-3 to 4 Million Afghan Refugees are already in our country for the past 40 years. More WILL COME!
-Mostly DONT WORKING or have Informal businesses.
-Instead of (NA kaa ke na kaaj ke, DUSHMAN anaj kE), we can ask them to work & pay taxes!
-In the past 20 years, there were some improvements Afghanistan's higher education.
-What if we allow these professional (Doctors, engineers etc) and other educated people to work in Pakistan's NEGLECTED SOCIAL & other sectors working in the private sectors.
-Mind you, MOST AFGHANS are ALREADY ALLOWED TO WORK IN PAKISTAN IF THEY HAVE ALIEN (NARA) CARD FROM NADRA.
-State can also use to them to settle some in Balochistan to DILUTE Baloch majority/separatism and demographics.
-Females can be given citizenship once married to local men as per Pakistan allow (Foreign females are given citizenship once married to Pakistani Men/Foreign Men not allowed to be citizen even if married to Pakistani Ladies)
-All above to be done after extensive & rigorous security/background check by Intelligence agencies.

What do you guys think?

 

[Bouncer]

we can ask them to work & pay taxes!

Interesting idea you got there. Maybe wait 20-30 years before we implement it. In the meanwhile lets first ask our own citizens like traders, doctors, lawyers to pay their due taxes while keeping the border sealed. Like airtight sealed for the next few decades.

I am all for helping our brethren across the border. But not at the cost of our own. Lets seal the border and let them solve their own problems.

 

[faani83]

 

[Bouncer]

-All above to be done after extensive & rigorous security/background check by Intelligence agencies.

Hate to break it to you but we don't do that here. NADRA issued millions of genuine ID cards to anyone and everyone who could pay for them.

 

[TNT]

There needs to be a proper plan. Offer business and stay visas for businessmen and talented people and kick out the rest. Provide visit visas for medical treatment and relative visits. Its a huge opportunity for Pakistan to earn from them. Also there will be a huge reconstruction in Afghanistan and we should get a big share in that. They dont have sea, so we should work towards that and provide better facilities than iran so we get most of the business.
We need to shore up our industries and make export friendly policies and agreements with Afghanistan. Literally everything is needed in Afghanistan as they have zero industry. We need to make inroads before others do.

 

[faani83]

 

[313ghazi]

Seal the border.

 

[faani83]

 

[jupiter2007]

Most Afghan drug and arm dealers are already Pakistani citizen. They bought their citizenship.
Only poor and educated Afghans are struggling to find jobs in Pakistan.
Afghan refugees in Pakistan are not going back, especially 2nd and 3rd generation who grew up in Pakistan.
I had presented the idea of giving them special status, give them domicile for interior Sindh but due to corruption and shortsightedness of our government it’s not possible.

 

[faani83]

Pakistan Born Afghan refugee doctor!

 

[hussain0216]

NO

NEVER

Seal the border
Enforce the law
Refugees can't work
Own businesses
Own homes
Or cars or anything

It's because we go so easy that they take advantage of us


Afghans are our enemies and first in line to support fassad and PTM


Start getting ready to come down on them hard, ensure they can't use state resources and all access to education or work are immediately ended


any illegal or anti Pakistan activity is a immediate removal from Pakistan for them and their families

 

[khansaheeb]

NO

NEVER

Seal the border
Enforce the law
Refugees can't work
Own businesses
Own homes
Or cars or anything

It's because we go so easy that they take advantage of us


Afghans are our enemies and first in line to support fassad and PTM


Start getting ready to come down on them hard, ensure they can't use state resources and all access to education or work are immediately ended


any illegal or anti Pakistan activity is a immediate removal from Pakistan for them and their families

How about removing anyone who is illegal or anti-Pakistan for immediate removal from Pakistan and not just Afghans?

 

[jupiter2007]

How about removing anyone who is illegal or anti-Pakistan for immediate removal from Pakistan and not just Afghans?

khooni liberals and corrupt media should be top of the list.

 

[Mandalorian_CA]

arey jaao bhai , jaan choro , enough already . It is because these refugees that Pakistanis become refugees.

 

[Enigma SIG]

Hate to break it to you but we don't do that here. NADRA issued millions of genuine ID cards to anyone and everyone who could pay for them.

This is what happens when you fill them with PPP and PML-N cadre.
They'll literally sell their mother for a few rupees.