Should Pakistan Allow Afghan Professional Refugees to Live & Work?

[MultaniGuy]

-3 to 4 Million Afghan Refugees are already in our country for the past 40 years. More WILL COME!
-Mostly DONT WORKING or have Informal businesses.
-Instead of (NA kaa ke na kaaj ke, DUSHMAN anaj kE), we can ask them to work & pay taxes!
-In the past 20 years, there were some improvements Afghanistan's higher education.
-What if we allow these professional (Doctors, engineers etc) and other educated people to work in Pakistan's NEGLECTED SOCIAL & other sectors working in the private sectors.
-Mind you, MOST AFGHANS are ALREADY ALLOWED TO WORK IN PAKISTAN IF THEY HAVE ALIEN (NARA) CARD FROM NADRA.
-State can also use to them to settle some in Balochistan to DILUTE Baloch majority/separatism and demographics.
-Females can be given citizenship once married to local men as per Pakistan allow (Foreign females are given citizenship once married to Pakistani Men/Foreign Men not allowed to be citizen even if married to Pakistani Ladies)
-All above to be done after extensive & rigorous security/background check by Intelligence agencies.

What do you guys think?

Absolutely yes we should allow them in.

We cannot lose our influence over Afghanistanis.

I hope Insh'Allah that Pakistan and Afghanistan becomes one country so we can be a stronger force.

 

[StormBreaker]

That’s exactly what happened during the Khilafat movement - Afghanistan let the march goers sit in the cold and die.
However, just like all balanced societies Pakistan needs to differentiate between those that do want to be supportive of Pakistan and those that want to basically hate the hands that feeds them. Bear in mind they did face a lot of hatred and racism when they first came and mostly from their cousins in NWFP. As they started moving out usually with criminal elements then the problems multipled.

IEA is going to be costly for Pakistan. The day IEA got hold of Kabul, I knew that they got teeth now, No more political support, A group too powerful to be ignored in the international political arena that nations would eventually have to accept them as successors of Afghanistan.

They got the teeth first time, Such people usually are too ambitious and they would go to any lengths. Pakistan is not much needed to them now, GHQ isn’t portraying itself as it is supposed to be and this is why I think Pakistan is a banana nuclear state with all sorts of stupids sitting in big chairs

 

[GumNaam]

Until there is no poverty in Pakistan, until not a single child sleeps hungry at night and nobody has to just work for food and gas.

for that to truly take place you have to kill the global interest based financial system of fiat currencies.

 

[Musalman]

-3 to 4 Million Afghan Refugees are already in our country for the past 40 years. More WILL COME!
-Mostly DONT WORKING or have Informal businesses.
-Instead of (NA kaa ke na kaaj ke, DUSHMAN anaj kE), we can ask them to work & pay taxes!
-In the past 20 years, there were some improvements Afghanistan's higher education.
-What if we allow these professional (Doctors, engineers etc) and other educated people to work in Pakistan's NEGLECTED SOCIAL & other sectors working in the private sectors.
-Mind you, MOST AFGHANS are ALREADY ALLOWED TO WORK IN PAKISTAN IF THEY HAVE ALIEN (NARA) CARD FROM NADRA.
-State can also use to them to settle some in Balochistan to DILUTE Baloch majority/separatism and demographics.
-Females can be given citizenship once married to local men as per Pakistan allow (Foreign females are given citizenship once married to Pakistani Men/Foreign Men not allowed to be citizen even if married to Pakistani Ladies)
-All above to be done after extensive & rigorous security/background check by Intelligence agencies.

What do you guys think?

In my view, there should not be any border between Afghanistan and Pakistan. Market should be one. People on both sides should be allowed to move without documents. Kind a like European common market. This market should then expand. This is the best time to do it.

 

[Maula Jatt]

In my view, there should not be any border between Afghanistan and Pakistan. Market should be one. People on both sides should be allowed to move without documents. Kind a like European common market. This market should then expand. This is the best time to do it.

TTP say hi..

 

[Musalman]

TTP say hi..

Do u think they will not say "hi" with sealed border. Joint operations with Afghans will rid them of them. If we fence the border, they will still be on the west side of the border. However, if we jointly move we can eliminate them. Make whole region peace, expand CPEC to Russia, Central Asia and Iran.

 

[Mr.Green]

It is a good idea and will increase the tax base.

 

[Goritoes]

Kick Afghans out before they play football with your kids heads...

 

[Mirzali Khan]

it already happened
I am not sure if it happened because of state "policy" or just a numbers game as population in Baluchistan is insanely low (more than half of Baloch tribes are settled in Sindh (Zaradari etc) and Punjab (Seraiki tribes like our current CM Punjab, I think most tribes speak both Saraiki and Balochi)

Yea it has already happened, there's a reason why BNP isn't as strong as it was and the likes of Akbar Bugti and Ataullah Mengal aren't that powerful anymore.

Baloch were good majority before 80s, but with Afghan refugees in Quetta (Pashtun and Hazara) it boosted Pashtun population as well as the Hazara population. Hazaras are still a minority, but now Pashtuns are either neck and neck or more than Baloch. I believe we are majority of Balochistan.

Same thing they are attempting in Sindh, but it is tough. There's a reason why Karachi became the biggest Pashtun city in the entire world. Thats why despite BLA support in Afghanistan, Baloch and Sindhi ethnonats believe Afghan refugees are an ISI ploy to displace them and do a demographic change. @faani83

All our southern provinces are pretty mixed up tbh (this demographics issue is causing ethno-centrism in the first place or demographics is the solution?) - this I do not know

Around 55% of Sindhis are sindhis demographic wise (cause Seraikis are considered Sindhis or a sindhi dialect in Sindh if you get rid of them than its even lower)
If Seraikis are a separate group than only 70-65% of people in Punjab are Punjabis rest Seraiki, around 8-9% Urdu speaking and 2% Pashtun (which means Punjabis itself become minority in the country although still a big one)

All in all demographics "games" is mind numbingly complicated as its too mixed up everywhere
and it definitely shouldn't become a "state" policy or tool as ramifications can be deadly- although natural migrations shouldn't be stopped as our Indus people have migrated everywhere that's why you'll see our demographics scattered everywhere

Migration within Pakistan would be accepted if there were more cities.

 

[PakSarZameen47]

Had the tables been turned, They wouldn’t give a sh*t about us

Read about the hijrat movement where our "muslim brother country" left muslims from sindh, punjab, kpk to starve and freeze to death on the border...

 

[fisher1]

Yes. If non-Muslim Chinese can work in Pakistan with freedom and given our tax dollars then why not Muslim Afghanis?

 

[Pak_Sher]

No. Let’s get our people employed first. Afghans can come later

View attachment 822746
r/afghan saw it on my Facebook- going rounds
at least non-Muslim Chinese don't ask for our genocides (besides lol at "midgets" such a big fat lie- probably other way around with starving afghans)
enjoy

@Sainthood 101 , please be mindful lots of Hindu Raw agents posing as Afghanis. Do not fall for the 3 faced snake natured Indians. Snake will always bite

 

[Cash GK]

She must be allowed to live n work where ever she wants. Let these young people to act for the betterment of both nations

 

[Maula Jatt]

No. Let’s get our people employed first. Afghans can come later


@Sainthood 101 , please be mindful lots of Hindu Raw agents posing as Afghanis. Do not fall for the 3 faced snake natured Indians. Snake will always bite

deleted it as its probably inappropriate but I highly doubt they were "Indians"

 

[Pomegranate]

We should put all the afghans in a big truck and throw them outside of the Durand Line, that is it.