Shiv Sena wants 'Secular' word to be removed from Indian Constitution

[Spring Onion]

Majority will follow their Hindu religion, India is a majority Hindu Nation.
There is not much difference between Hindu Rastra and a state where Hinduism is practiced by Majority of its citizens. No GOD in Hinduism said if a Hindu do not practice his religion in Hindu rastra he will get benifits.

Only issue is how many of them actually know the core philosophy and teachings. First thing to do is make people know about these things.

That is not the responsibility of the government.

 

[ranjeet]

And it is bad?

you tell me?

 

[Dalit]

Wah wah Shiv bhayya! Good going.

 

[Guynextdoor2]

you tell me?

How does becoming 'secular' be a bad thing? It says governments must treat all equally irrespective of their religion- are you suggesting that we should treat certain relegions as inferior? Surely you are not like that?

 

[Srinivas]

That is not the responsibility of the government.

Yes the phrase is not related to Govt. But Hindu organizations.

 

[Spring Onion]

Utter nonsense..This will never come to be India is and will always remain secular.

Pakistanis dearly hope, India would become Hindu Rashtra some day, Because that will just bring us down their level.

the word Pakistanis represents a vast majority of people and 99% does not care what is going on in India.


The remaining 1% is consisted of people among whom hardly few might had thought about the bold part in your comments but that too ambiguous while major part of this 1% Pakistanis one way or the other belongs to Media/writers who in FACT always had been advocating that if India becomes a Hindu rashtra in true sense (including constitutionally) it will be bad for Muslims and Pakistan in general SO my deaar NO Pakistanis do not hope at all that India would become a Hindu rashtra.

But i am really amused that You Indians are in constant FEAR in oth the cases if Pakistanis oppose an Indian Hindu State or even if support an Indian Hindu State .and i am loving this confusion of yours

 

[ranjeet]

How does becoming 'secular' be a bad thing? It says governments must treat all equally irrespective of their religion- are you suggesting that we should treat certain relegions as inferior? Surely you are not like that?

So are you trying to say that the people who wrote the Constitution were Sanghis and Hindutvadis? or that for the greater good all rules and regulations must be kicked out? Would you extend same understanding towards Modi?

 

[Guynextdoor2]

So are you trying to say that the people who wrote the Constitution were Sanghis and Hindutvadis? or that for the greater good all rules and regulations must be kicked out? Would you extend same understanding towards Modi?

I have no idea what you're saying here

 

[doppelganger]

the word Pakistanis represents a vast majority of people and 99% does not care what is going on in India.


The remaining 1% is consisted of people among whom hardly few might had thought about the bold part in your comments but that too ambiguous while major part of this 1% Pakistanis one way or the other belongs to Media/writers who in FACT always had been advocating that if India becomes a Hindu rashtra in true sense (including constitutionally) it will be bad for Muslims and Pakistan in general SO my deaar NO Pakistanis do not hope at all that India would become a Hindu rashtra.

But i am really amused that You Indians are in constant FEAR in oth the cases if Pakistanis oppose an Indian Hindu State or even if support an Indian Hindu State .and i am loving this confusion of yours

It is because we understand why you want us to be a Hindu state.

I personally believe that all Indians are Hindu, and it is Hindutva that binds us together.

But yes, we do enjoy playing along, just as you do. As long as its on the net. Real life is very different.

 

[Spring Onion]

Your futile ateempt to justify the creation of Pakistan is still astonishing,.Get over it.. You created a nation in the name of religion and India followed the secular way.. You just cannot find solitude declaring my country a Hindu nation..

oh my GOD from where your tired head thought of that lolzzzzz creation of Pakistan is a reality we do not need to remind you of the justification or otherwise.

you only selected the word 'secularism' nothing else this has just burdened the majority Hindus with cosmetic painting which is irritating to many of them.

as a Pakistani secular or without this word , India remains untrustable neighbor for us.

 

[ranjeet]

I have no idea what you're saying here

Secular word was added to Indian Constitution during emergency imposed by Indira Gandhi. So people who wrote the original Constitution were Sanghis and hindutavadis?

 

[Spring Onion]

It is because we understand why you want us to be a Hindu state.

I personally believe that all Indians are Hindu, and it is Hindutva that binds us together.

But yes, we do enjoy playing along, just as you do. As long as its on the net. Real life is very different.

again if you are counting my view as that of entire Pakistan well you are mistaken as well as living in your own confusion

 

[doppelganger]

as a Pakistani secular or without this word , India remains untrustable neighbor for us.

Then what's in it for you for us ceasing to be secular and becoming a frank Hindu state?

Chaos? Mayhem? Civil strife?

200 million honorary Pakistani soldiers implanted in India maybe?

 

[Spring Onion]

It is because we understand why you want us to be a Hindu state.

I personally believe that all Indians are Hindu, and it is Hindutva that binds us together.

But yes, we do enjoy playing along, just as you do. As long as its on the net. Real life is very different.

again if you are counting my view as that of entire Pakistan well you are mistaken as well as living in your own confusion

 

[ares]

the word Pakistanis represents a vast majority of people and 99% does not care what is going on in India.


The remaining 1% is consisted of people among whom hardly few might had thought about the bold part in your comments but that too ambiguous while major part of this 1% Pakistanis one way or the other belongs to Media/writers who in FACT always had been advocating that if India becomes a Hindu rashtra in true sense (including constitutionally) it will be bad for Muslims and Pakistan in general SO my deaar NO Pakistanis do not hope at all that India would become a Hindu rashtra.

But i am really amused that You Indians are in constant FEAR in oth the cases if Pakistanis oppose an Indian Hindu State or even if support an Indian Hindu State .and i am loving this confusion of yours

Actually If India became a Hindu state, most Pakistanis will be very glad..for it would have justified the existence of your state and would have proved the two nation theory correct.

The fact that hundred of millions of Hindus coexist relatively peacefully will with hundred of million minorities in a secular nation, does pose a big question mark as to the purpose of Pakistani nation.