Sairbeen: Amritpal Singh: Is the movement for Khalistan gathering strength in India again? -BBC URDU

[JackTheRipper]

 

[INS_Vikrant]

No

 

[hussain0216]

The more hindutva poison spreads the more other communities will respond

Sikhs are becoming agitated, Indian Muslims are already partitioning inside India


Even the Delhi riots the one sided SC has targeted Indian Muslims only with no justice for Indian Muslims who were attacked or killed


Hindu rashtra will break India into multiple portions

 

[SaadH]

Not in India, but the way Sepoys have been acting lately there's more likelihood of that happening in Pakistan

 

[Sam6536]

It's not a popular movement. Guy has the handful support of his small cult and the vocal minority who like to demand Khalistan by breaking stuff in UK, Canada and the US.
In the past few days action was taken against his entire group.

 

[hussain0216]

It's not a popular movement. Guy has the handful support of his small cult and the vocal minority who like to demand Khalistan by breaking stuff in UK, Canada and the US.
In the past few days action was taken against his entire group.

What do you mean it's not a popular movement,

Indians hate each other,, Hindus want a Hindu extremist rashtra and now Sikhs are calling for khalistan and even Indian Ulema have been open about a Muslim state if Hindu extremists don't stop calling for a rashtra

 

[Sam6536]

What do you mean it's not a popular movement,

Indians hate each other,, Hindus want a Hindu extremist rashtra and now Sikhs are calling for khalistan and even Indian Ulema have been open about a Muslim state if Hindu extremists don't stop calling for a rashtra

Eh it's not a popular movement I meant what I said. Handful of guys actually support that extremist. India has seen worse and still remained a union, it will continue being so.
It's more likely Pakistan will crumble before India does given by your constant erratic desire to see India break.

 

[hussain0216]

Eh it's not a popular movement I meant what I said. Handful of guys actually support that extremist. India has seen worse and still remained a union, it will continue being so.
It's more likely Pakistan will crumble before India does given by your constant erratic desire to see India break.

Pakistani have corrupt politicians and we have ethnic chauvinism but no one wants to commit genocide or destroy the other


In India you have mass communal hatred


Calls for a Hindu extremist rashtra are on the back of this mass communal hatred, calls for a khalistan and Muslim state are increasing because of the communal hatred being ramped up

 

[Sam6536]

Pakistani have corrupt politicians and we have ethnic chauvinism but no one wants to commit genocide or destroy the other


In India you have mass communal hatred


Calls for a Hindu extremist rashtra are on the back of this mass communal hatred, calls for a khalistan and Muslim state are increasing because of the communal hatred being ramped up

so Pakistan not closer to a socio-economic breakdown? the army was like your most revered asset but that's shat on like day in out now. The country is heading to an economic meltdown and you have to do western bidding to get loans.
this statement fits everywhere - Nationalism, supremacy all these concepts take a backseat when a populace goes a day without three meals.
India has had communal tensions but it never went out of hand due to strong central govt.
The only known pogram was in Gujrat riots after which there was a strong belief that india will fully slide to become a Hindu state with but it still remains secular.
I've read a book where a author said that " the majority of Hindus are too accommodating" and don't actually want tensions.
RSS+BJP like every right movement in the world is playing the religion supremacy card.

 

[hussain0216]

so Pakistan not closer to a socio-economic breakdown? the army was like your most revered asset but that's shat on like day in out now. The country is heading to an economic meltdown and you have to do western bidding to get loans.
this statement fits everywhere - Nationalism, supremacy all these concepts take a backseat when a populace goes a day without three meals.
India has had communal tensions but it never went out of hand due to strong central govt.
The only known pogram was in Gujrat riots after which there was a strong belief that india will fully slide to become a Hindu state with but it still remains secular.
I've read a book where a author said that " the majority of Hindus are too accommodating" and don't actually want tensions.
RSS+BJP like every right movement in the world is playing the religion supremacy card.

We have economic and political problems,, no one wants to commit mass genocide against each other


What are you not understanding?

We hate indians and Hindus ,but do you know who hates indians more then us? It's other indians

There is mass communal hatred inside India at the moment at extreme levels


Partition is happening as we speak inside India with communities on the move and economically boycotting each other

The calls for independent states is just a result of the communal hatred rampant inside India at the moment

Banning Gandhi or denying Indian Muslims justice for Delhi riots is just the latest example of how far things have gone

 

[El Sidd]

Indian stubbornness in addressing concerns of minorities is a regional problem. Punjab and Bengal both threaten to be the South Asian question of Kurdistan.