What's new

Rohingya crisis: Bangladesh, Myanmar agree on joint panel to repatriate refugees

https://bdnews24.com/bangladesh/201...r-agree-on-joint-panel-to-repatriate-refugees


Rohingya crisis: Bangladesh, Myanmar agree on joint panel to repatriate refugees
Staff Correspondent, bdnews24.com

Published: 2017-10-02 14:30:33.0 BdST Updated: 2017-10-02 14:30:33.0 BdST


Bangladesh and Myanmar have agreed on forming a joint panel for repatriation of Rohingya refugees.

lg.php


Related Stories


Officials of the two countries met in Bangladesh's capital of Dhaka on Monday to discuss the crisis amid mounting international pressure.

The Myanmar delegation was led by Minister for the Office of the State Counsellor of Myanmar Kyaw Tint Swe. The Bangladeshi delegation included Foreign Minister AH Mahmood Ali and Home Minister Asaduzzaman Kamal.

"Myanmar has proposed taking back the Rohingya refugees. We have agreed on forming a joint working group to oversee the repatriation process," Minister Ali told the media in Dhaka after the talks.



Kyaw-Tint-Swe-Dhaka--%281%29.jpg



Nearly half a million Rohingyas have fled to Bangladesh since the start of a military crackdown in the Myanmar border state of Rakhine.
The refugees have claimed the Myanmar security forces are shooting at civilians, setting fire to their homes and raping Rohingya women.

Myanmar’s de-facto leader Aung San Suu Kyi, who won the Nobel Peace Prize for her contribution to restoring democracy to the country, sent the minister of her office to Bangladesh amid international pressure over the crisis, which the UN has called an ‘ethnic cleansing’.

Despite her party's win in 2015's elections, the Myanmar Army controls the majority of the government, including the defence authorities.


We can't trust Myanmar. We need multiple partner aggrement and firm commitment by Myanmar govt. That Rohingya people will be given appropriate citizens right and security . Unless proper international monitoring and pressure it will be useless . They will take back some du to international outcry and them stop and force more to flee to Bangladesh.
 
.
Myanmar have officially stated that Rohingya are not Burmese citizens, they are considered foreign invaders. Myanmar refuses to even acknowledge the word "Rohingya", they call them Bengalis.

And since they are not Burmese citizens, but rather foreign invaders occupying Burmese land (in their view), the use of military force becomes not only justified, but correct.

Hasina knows this, and she knows by sending them back she is signing their death warrants.


It really does not matter what the Burmese thinks and how they view the Rohingya.

This issue will take decades to resolve.

I would not repatriate the rohingyas without safe guards such as a demelitarised zone within Burma.

The world is no longer a place where you can carry out genocide without implication. Burma can never join world community fully without resolution of this issue.

burma is being ostracised again by civilised nations of the world and its elites will be facing sanctions, EU has already began discussing this.

Bangladesh has humanitarian responsibility towards rohingyas but the Burmese can not shift responsibity for their own population.

Burmese nation is weak, artificial and immature. The world is not fooled. Justice unfortunately is often very slow but rarely one escapes it. Burma in the west has returned to standard pariah state. BD and others needs to ensure this is solidified.
 
.
Myanmar have officially stated that Rohingya are not Burmese citizens, they are considered foreign invaders. Myanmar refuses to even acknowledge the word "Rohingya", they call them Bengalis.

And since they are not Burmese citizens, but rather foreign invaders occupying Burmese land (in their view), the use of military force becomes not only justified, but correct.

Hasina knows this, and she knows by sending them back she is signing their death warrants.

Ah, that is completely incorrect.
If what you say is true, any country can declare an ethnic group non-citizens and then kill them.
What Myanmar has done to Ronhingyas is actually illegal even under Myanmarese monkey laws.
 
.
Myanmar have officially stated that Rohingya are not Burmese citizens, they are considered foreign invaders. Myanmar refuses to even acknowledge the word "Rohingya", they call them Bengalis.

And since they are not Burmese citizens, but rather foreign invaders occupying Burmese land (in their view), the use of military force becomes not only justified, but correct.

Hasina knows this, and she knows by sending them back she is signing their death warrants.

"Myanmar junta" empowered by buddhist terrorist mantra, that is recognized fact in all over the world. Rohingya people has more than 1000 years of history in Rakhine and in Myanmar. Rohigya and Muslims were in forefront in Myanmar independence.

So what ever Myanmar junta and their Chinese backers says oppose to the historic truth, are null and void on arrival. If you are eager to learn then look at following picture and historic context and place of Rohingya in Myanmar.

336653_1.jpg

A historical picture taken in 1936. Places - then Rangoon World School, Burma. In the middle of the picture, sitting on a chair, is a Rohingya, his name is Abdur Rashid. He was the President of the All Burma Student Union and the person sitting on the right side of Aung San (Suu Kyi father) is the general secretary of the organization.

Who is sitting on the left side is Abdur Razzak, President of Burma Muslim League Originally Burma's independence came from their hands. And this Rohingya president Abdur Razzaq drafted the draft constitution of Myanmar today.

http://www.newsofbd.net/newsdetail/detail/200/336653

PS: I let you go easy this time, I will not be so kind next time though.
 
.
"Myanmar junta" empowered by buddhist terrorist mantra, that is recognized fact in all over the world. Rohingya people has more than 1000 years of history in Rakhine and in Myanmar. Rohigya and Muslims were in forefront in Myanmar independence.

So what ever Myanmar junta and their Chinese backers says oppose to the historic truth, are null and void on arrival. If you are eager to learn then look at following picture and historic context and place of Rohingya in Myanmar.

336653_1.jpg

A historical picture taken in 1936. Places - then Rangoon World School, Burma. In the middle of the picture, sitting on a chair, is a Rohingya, his name is Abdur Rashid. He was the President of the All Burma Student Union and the person sitting on the right side of Aung San (Suu Kyi father) is the general secretary of the organization.

Who is sitting on the left side is Abdur Razzak, President of Burma Muslim League Originally Burma's independence came from their hands. And this Rohingya president Abdur Razzaq drafted the draft constitution of Myanmar today.

http://www.newsofbd.net/newsdetail/detail/200/336653

PS: I let you go easy this time, I will not be so kind next time though.

Unfortunately BD is not making a good enough effort to counter the Myanmar propaganda that Rohingyas are illegal immigrants from BD.
 
.
So Bangladesh is sending the Rohingya back to Myanmar where they will be killed.

It isn't just a matter of Rohingya lives, its a matter of their rights too. Why should their homes and lands (often ancestral) be taken from them? And for fear of their lives they should let it all go?
 
.
Unfortunately BD is not making a good enough effort to counter the Myanmar propaganda that Rohingyas are illegal immigrants from BD.
You mean current "BD regime". Bangladesh and current "BD regime" are two different things. Knowing that difference one can not expect regime to do anything other than listen to its master dictate.
 
.
Unfortunately BD is not making a good enough effort to counter the Myanmar propaganda that Rohingyas are illegal immigrants from BD.


Fortunately for the rohingyas no one in international media is fooled by Burmese version of event. When the whore of Bangkok stated she did not know why the rohingyas are leaving their homes.... it was meet with unconcealed contempt by the world community and media.

Thank god for small mercies like the internet, social media, personalities like Mohammed Yunus and world media like Al Jazeera who have kept the news in absolute forefront of world consciousness.
 
.
Fortunately for the rohingyas no one in international media is fooled by Burmese version of event. When the whore of Bangkok stated she did not know why the rohingyas are leaving their homes.... it was meet with unconcealed contempt by the world community and media.

Thank god for small mercies like the internet, social media, personalities like Mohammed Yunus and world media like Al Jazeera who have kept the news in absolute forefront of world consciousness.

I would like to see that bitch spend the rest of her life in a solitary cell.
 
.
PS: I let you go easy this time, I will not be so kind next time though.


Wow, thanks for letting me off easy. Much appreciated.

You mean current "BD regime". Bangladesh and current "BD regime" are two different things. Knowing that difference one can not expect regime to do anything other than listen to its master dictate.

Your "regime" is about to send hundreds of thousands of Rohingya back to Myanmar where they will be killed.

It's no different to killing them yourself.
 
.
"Myanmar junta" empowered by buddhist terrorist mantra, that is recognized fact in all over the world. Rohingya people has more than 1000 years of history in Rakhine and in Myanmar. Rohigya and Muslims were in forefront in Myanmar independence.

So what ever Myanmar junta and their Chinese backers says oppose to the historic truth, are null and void on arrival. If you are eager to learn then look at following picture and historic context and place of Rohingya in Myanmar.

336653_1.jpg

A historical picture taken in 1936. Places - then Rangoon World School, Burma. In the middle of the picture, sitting on a chair, is a Rohingya, his name is Abdur Rashid. He was the President of the All Burma Student Union and the person sitting on the right side of Aung San (Suu Kyi father) is the general secretary of the organization.

Who is sitting on the left side is Abdur Razzak, President of Burma Muslim League Originally Burma's independence came from their hands. And this Rohingya president Abdur Razzaq drafted the draft constitution of Myanmar today.

http://www.newsofbd.net/newsdetail/detail/200/336653

PS: I let you go easy this time, I will not be so kind next time though.

Is it even relevant ? Majority of Rohaniyas live outside Myanmar. It is not like the refugees are looking to go back to their homes. 50 years from now Arakan would be Muslim free. May be a few Muslim villages to show how tolerant Myanmar is
 
.
Rohingya refugees doubt Myanmar's assurances on going home
October 03, 2017 Reuters Agency
resized_6e21c-1259_tur_picture_20171002_13230186_13230181.jpg

Rohingya refugees
Rohingya Muslims in Bangladesh were sceptical on Tuesday about their chances of ever going home to Myanmar, even though the government there has given an assurance it would accept people verified as refugees.

More than half a million Rohingya have fled from a Myanmar military crackdown in Rakhine State launched in late August that has been denounced by the United Nations as ethnic cleansing and placed a huge burden on Bangladesh.

Myanmar denies ethnic cleansing, saying it is only fighting Rohingya terrorists who have claimed attacks on the security forces. The government has said anyone verified as a refugee from Myanmar will be allowed to return under a process agreed with Bangladesh in 1993.

Bangladesh and Myanmar agreed on Monday to work on a repatriation plan, and a Myanmar government spokesman confirmed it would go along with process, provided people could verify their status with paperwork.

But many refugees are scornful.

"Everything was burned, even people were burned," said a refugee who identified himself as Abdullah, dismissing the chances that people would have documents to prove a right to stay in Myanmar.

At the root of the problem is the refusal by Buddhist-majority Myanmar to grant citizenship to members of a Muslim minority seen by a mostly unsympathetic, if not hostile, society as interlopers from Bangladesh.

Though Myanmar has not granted Rohingya citizenship, under the 1993 procedure, it agreed to take back people who could prove they had been Myanmar residents.

But a day after Bangladesh and Myanmar announced apparent progress, a Bangladeshi foreign ministry official appeared resigned to a difficult process.

"This is still a long procedure," said the official, who declined to be identified as he was not authorised to speak to media.

There were already about 300,000 Rohingya refugees in Bangladesh before the latest exodus, but Myanmar had said it would only take back those who arrived after October 2016 - when a military offensive in response to Rohingya insurgent attacks sent 87,000 Rohingya fleeing to Bangladesh - "subject to verification", the official said.

"We said that many Rohingya refugees have no documents, so this process should be flexible. Myanmar said they will decide who will get involved in the verification," the official said, adding Bangladesh wanted international agencies to be involved.

Myanmar's government spokesman said under the 1993 pact, even a hospital record was enough to prove residency, but it was only Myanmar, and not Bangladesh, that could verify citizenship.

"We have a policy for the repatriation process and we will go along with that policy," the spokesman, Zaw Htay, told Reuters.
'BREAK THEIR PROMISE'
But even if refugees had documents, many are wary about returning without an assurance of full citizenship, which they fear could leave them vulnerable to the persecution and curbs they have endured for years.

Amina Katu, 60, laughed at the thought of returning.

"If we go there, we'll just have to come back here," she said. "If they give us our rights, we will go, but people did this before and they had to return."

Last month, Anwar Begum told Reuters she had now fled from Myanmar three times. The first time was to escape a 1978 crackdown, and she returned the following year. She fled again in 1991 and returned in 1994.

"I don't want to go back," the 55-year-old added. "I don't believe the government. Every time the government agrees we can go back, then we're there and they break their promise."

Investigators appointed by Suu Kyi and led by former U.N. secretary-general Kofi Annan recommended in August that Myanmar review a 1982 law that links citizenship and ethnicity and leaves most Rohingya stateless.

Statelessness was at the root of the problem, U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees Filippo Grandi told a meeting in Geneva on Monday.

"Nowhere is the link between statelessness and displacement more evident than with the Rohingya community of Myanmar, for whom denial of citizenship is a key aspect of the discrimination and exclusion that have shaped their plight," he said.

Grandi also called for a two-track approach to tackle issues of citizenship and rights and inclusive development to stamp out poverty in Rakhine State.
resized_c108c-2017-10-02t093223z_943544023_rc1dee824300_rtrmadp_3_myanmar-rohingya-bangladesh.jpg

UNICEF appeals for $76.1M for Rohingya children
UNICEF on Monday requested $76.1 million from donor countries to assist children affected by the Rohingya refugee crisis in southern Bangladesh.

The UNICEF appeal for $7 million for Rohingya refugees has been expanded over tenfold to $76.1 million due to "the fast-growing scale of the crisis," the UN agency said in a statement."The appeal will cover the immediate needs of newly arrived Rohingya children, as well as those who arrived before the recent influx, and children from vulnerable host communities."According to UNICEF, up to 60 percent of the more than half-million Rohingya refugees who have fled Myanmar since Aug. 25 are children.

"Desperate, traumatized children and their families are fleeing the violence in Myanmar every day. We are scaling up our response as fast as we can, but the magnitude of need is immense and we must be able do more to help them.

These children are being denied a childhood,quot; Anthony Lake, UNICEF’s executive director, said in a statement.The majority of Rohingya children are not fully immunized against diseases such as polio, Lake warned.Since Aug. 25, more than 500,000 Rohingya have crossed from Myanmar's western state of Rakhine into Bangladesh.

The refugees are fleeing a fresh military operation in which security forces and Buddhist mobs have killed men, women and children, looted homes, and torched Rohingya villages. According to Bangladeshi Foreign Minister Abul Hasan Mahmood Ali, around 3,000 Rohingya have been killed in the crackdown.

Turkey has been at the forefront of providing aid to Rohingya refugees, and President Recep Tayyip Erdogan has raised the issue at the UN.

The Rohingya, described by the UN as the world's most persecuted people, have faced heightened fears of attack since dozens were killed in communal violence in 2012.

Last October, following attacks on border posts in Rakhine's Maungdaw district, security forces launched a five-month crackdown in which, according to Rohingya groups, around 400 people were killed.The UN documented mass gang rapes, killings -- including of infants and young children -- brutal beatings, and disappearances committed by security personnel. In a report, UN investigators said such violations may have constituted crimes against humanity.http://www.yenisafak.com/en/dunya/rohingya-refugees-doubt-myanmars-assurances-on-going-home-2794923
 
.
Back
Top Bottom