Reality of 2-Nation Theory

[Chanakyaa]

The Success of Indian Secularism :

- Modi having a Muslim Man in UN as INDIAN REPRESENTATIVE : Syed Akbaruddin
- Right wing BJP Making a Muslim President : APJ Kalam
- India having MUSLIM Chiefs of INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES : Asif Ibrahim
- India winning WARS under : JACOBs and MANEKSHAWS
- Backward Caste Modi and Dalit, Kovind the PM/President of Current INDIA.

This sums up nicely :

- A Christian Woman, paves way fr a SIKH PM, who takes Oath from a MUSLIM PRESIDENT in a country with 80% HINDUS ! > True INDIAN SECULARISM.

& The Success of SEPARATE Bangladesh :

- 8% GDP Growth - fastest in the world.
- $300 Billion Economy

IS A CLEAR FAILURE of "TWO NATION" Theory :

- Hindus & Muslims COULD EXIST TOGETHER > As in Case of INDIA
- ALL MUSLIMS - CANNOT STAY TOGETHER > As in Case of PAK-BD

For Those who CRY that BD was BOUND To happen due to Distance between EAST & WEST - PAK :

- Go and Read How UK defended Falklands 6000 KM AWAY !! ( WITH NO 6th Fleet from US )

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falklands_War

For Those Muslims in Pakistan - who wanna cry about Muslims in INDIA :
Watch what an INDIAN Muslim ( who abuses modi daily says this ) :

​

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

The Success of Indian Secularism :

- Modi having a Muslim Man in UN as INDIAN REPRESENTATIVE : Syed Akbaruddin
- Right wing BJP Making a Muslim President : APJ Kalam
- India having MUSLIM Chiefs of INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES : Asif Ibrahim
- India winning WARS under : JACOBs and MANEKSHAWS
- Backward Caste Modi and Dalit, Kovind the PM/President of Current INDIA.

This sums up nicely :

- A Christian Woman, paves way fr a SIKH PM, who takes Oath from a MUSLIM PRESIDENT in a country with 80% HINDUS ! > True INDIAN SECULARISM.

& The Success of SEPARATE Bangladesh :

- 8% GDP Growth - fastest in the world.
- $300 Billion Economy

IS A CLEAR FAILURE of "TWO NATION" Theory :

- Hindus & Muslims COULD EXIST TOGETHER > As in Case of INDIA
- ALL MUSLIMS - CANNOT STAY TOGETHER > As in Case of PAK-BD

For Those who CRY that BD was BOUND To happen due to Distance between EAST & WEST - PAK :

- Go and Read How UK defended Falklands 6000 KM AWAY !! ( WITH NO 6th Fleet from US )

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falklands_War

For Those Muslims in Pakistan - who wanna cry about Muslims in INDIA :
Watch what an INDIAN Muslim ( who abuses modi daily says this ) :

​

If the 2-nation theory was not successful, then bangladesh would have become a part of india again. 1971 in fact validated and strengthened the 2-nation theory into the 3 nation theory. If the 2 nation theory EVER fails, then both bangladesh and Pakistan would be merged into india. NEVER HAPPENING!

 

[Chanakyaa]

If the 2-nation theory was not successful, then bangladesh would have become a part of india again. 1971 in fact validated and strengthened the 2-nation theory into the 3 nation theory. If the 2 nation theory EVER fails, then both bangladesh and Pakistan would be merged into india. NEVER HAPPENING!

Can you give an irrefutable , unbiased and valid proof ( Pakistani , Bangladeshi and INDIAN sources dont count ) of your statement above ?

 

[Ahmad Saleem]

The Success of Indian Secularism :

- Modi having a Muslim Man in UN as INDIAN REPRESENTATIVE : Syed Akbaruddin
- Right wing BJP Making a Muslim President : APJ Kalam
- India having MUSLIM Chiefs of INTELLIGENCE AGENCIES : Asif Ibrahim
- India winning WARS under : JACOBs and MANEKSHAWS
- Backward Caste Modi and Dalit, Kovind the PM/President of Current INDIA.

This sums up nicely :

- A Christian Woman, paves way fr a SIKH PM, who takes Oath from a MUSLIM PRESIDENT in a country with 80% HINDUS ! > True INDIAN SECULARISM.

& The Success of SEPARATE Bangladesh :

- 8% GDP Growth - fastest in the world.
- $300 Billion Economy

IS A CLEAR FAILURE of "TWO NATION" Theory :

- Hindus & Muslims COULD EXIST TOGETHER > As in Case of INDIA
- ALL MUSLIMS - CANNOT STAY TOGETHER > As in Case of PAK-BD

For Those who CRY that BD was BOUND To happen due to Distance between EAST & WEST - PAK :

- Go and Read How UK defended Falklands 6000 KM AWAY !! ( WITH NO 6th Fleet from US )

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Falklands_War

For Those Muslims in Pakistan - who wanna cry about Muslims in INDIA :
Watch what an INDIAN Muslim ( who abuses modi daily says this ) :

​

There was an india like that which no more exists. Secondly we do have our on examples of minorities rising to high ranks despite having a much smaller minority

 

[Chanakyaa]

There was an india like that which no more exists. Secondly we do have our on examples of minorities rising to high ranks despite having a much smaller minority

The much smaller minority was not so small.
It was reduced to be small, while exact opposite happened in India.

Proof :

https://tribune.com.pk/story/1121936/our-vanishing-hindus/?amp=1

https://blogs.tribune.com.pk/tag/minorities-in-pakistan/


Muslums Increased in India, Hindus Vanished in Pakistan.

Besides, When you get a Hindu PM/President, Hindu Intelligence Chief come n talk.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Can you give an irrefutable , unbiased and valid proof ( Pakistani , Bangladeshi and INDIAN sources dont count ) of your statement above ?

The existence of Pakistan, the Pakistan people, our unique racial and cultural heritage are living proof of this. Last time I checked, Pakistan and bangladesh are both independent nations not under indian occupation. Forget 2-nation theory, that's 3 nation theory for you.

 

[Chanakyaa]

The existence of Pakistan, the Pakistan people, our unique racial and cultural heritage are living proof of this. Last time I checked, Pakistan and bangladesh are both independent nations not under indian occupation. Forget 2-nation theory, that's 3 nation theory for you.

Well Said. Yes its 3 Nation Theory.

3 Nation Theory, which you coined proves Disintegration of Pakistan. Not its Existance.

3 Nation Theory ( Muslim - Muslim - Hindu ). Which stands on the dead corpse of Two Nation ( Hindi - Muslim ) Theory.

3 Nation Theory, proves Muslims cant stay together.

Pakistanis could not save BD with United States, 6thfleet on their side.
UK with defended Falklands 6000 km away.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

Well Said. Yes its 3 Nation Theory.

3 Nation Theory, which you coined proves Disintegration of Pakistan. Not its Existance.

3 Nation Theory ( Muslim - Muslim - Hindu ). Which stands on the dead corpse of Two Nation ( Hindi - Muslim ) Theory.

3 Nation Theory, proves Muslims cant stay together.

Pakistanis could not save BD with United States, 6thfleet on their side.
UK with just 25 jets defended Falklands 6000 km away.

By that definition, india also disintegrated and is dead when it lost over 35% of it's former territory in the creation of Pakistan. Whereas bangladesh is barely 17% the size of Pakistan. All 1947 and 1971 proved was that you can't form a single nation with people Who are completely different to you in terms of race and DNA. Especially if they are 2750 kms away from you. Nothing else.

 

[Chanakyaa]

By that definition, india also disintegrated and is dead when it lost over 35% of it's former territory in the creation of Pakistan. Whereas bangladesh is barely 17% the size of Pakistan. All 1947 and 1971 proved was that you can't form a single nation with people Who are completely different to you in terms of race and DNA. Especially if they are 2750 kms away from you. Nothing else.

We are discussing Two Nation Theory, not the Partition of India.

Partition of India happened because some people thought Hindus and Muslims cant stay Togther ( wrong as They are existing together in India after 70 years ) and that Muslims separately from Hindus Can exist Peacefully ( wrong again, since BD got away ).

Focus on Two Nation Theory and its Validity.

 

[Ahmad Saleem]

O

The much smaller minority was not so small.
It was reduced to be small, while exact opposite happened in India.

Proof :

https://tribune.com.pk/story/1121936/our-vanishing-hindus/?amp=1

https://blogs.tribune.com.pk/tag/minorities-in-pakistan/


Muslums Increased in India, Hindus Vanished in Pakistan.

Besides, When you get a Hindu PM/President, Hindu Intelligence Chief come n talk.

oh please dont let me make a post on how shabana azmi failed to get a flat in mumbai
Secondly the migration of Pakistani hindus was because of rise of terrorist outfits supported by india which is no longer an issue and the same terrorist outfits forced punjabi population to migrate out of balochistan. There are discrepancies in Pakistan too but as an state we treat minorities much better. We had hindu and christian chief justices. In Pakistan we gave death sentence for killing a christian couple over alleged blasphemy. Can you tell me how many hindus have been given death penalties over killing muslims for communal differences?
In Pakistan minorities are not above 5% including hindus, Christians and other groups however in india only muslims are up to 14%.
Indian muslims are currently living in conditions worse than dalits

 

[hussain0216]

Good that you admitted it. India is a secular country and most of us are very proud of it.

Saying this today, you are insulting everyone's intelligence

 

[Chanakyaa]

O

oh please dont let me make a post on how shabana azmi failed to get a flat in mumbai
Secondly the migration of Pakistani hindus was because of rise of terrorist outfits supported by india which is no longer an issue and the same terrorist outfits forced punjabi population to migrate out of balochistan. There are discrepancies in Pakistan too but as an state we treat minorities much better. We had hindu and christian chief justices. In Pakistan we gave death sentence for killing a christian couple over alleged blasphemy. Can you tell me how many hindus have been given death penalties over killing muslims for communal differences?
In Pakistan minorities are not above 5% including hindus, Christians and other groups however in india they are up to 14%.
Indian muslims are currently living in conditions worse than dalits

Shia Sunni, Bangla vs Non Bangla, Black White difference exist. For somereason, Muslims in China are not even talked about in Pakistan.

Shabana getting flat or not Kalam did become President in India. Compare that to your consitiution whre BY RULE no hindu willever become President/PM.

Do you want meto post what is happeing to Christians and Hindus in Pakistan?

Check this and open eyes :

https://blogs.tribune.com.pk/tag/minorities-in-pakistan/

And btw, A DALIT is our President NOW. RIGHT NOW.

 

[hussain0216]

India is a communal shithole

It is a communal disaster

The hatred poison toxicity amongst Indians is incredible

2 nation theory is validated but superceded by multi nation theory
India needs to be divided into multiple states

You cannot trap 1.4 billion people in such a hateful state

 

[Ahmad Saleem]

We are discussing Two Nation Theory, not the Partition of India.

Partition of India happened because some people thought Hindus and Muslims cant stay Togther ( wrong as They are existing together in India after 70 years ) and that Muslims separately from Hindus Can exist Peacefully ( wrong again, since BD got away ).

Focus on Two Nation Theory and its Validity.

Well the topic has been discussed to ad nauseam and bhakts are unable to find anything out of it. The fallacy that opposition try to make is that they assert that nation is only formed on racial basis which is flawed. Nations can be formed even out of race and even india is not a single race

 

[Chanakyaa]

India is a communal shithole

It is a communal disaster

The hatred poison toxicity amongst Indians is incredible

2 nation theory is validated but superceded by multi nation theory
India needs to be divided into multiple states

You cannot trap 1.4 billion people in such a hateful state

Well, thats your wish. But first you need to worry for the extra $14 billion you are takiing as deb t while India will join G7 next month.

Sadly, Thats the difference in India ( Being forcibley added to G7 ) And Pakistan ( looking fr another loan) in 2020

Well the topic has been discussed to ad nauseam and bhakts are unable to find anything out of it. The fallacy that opposition try to make is that they assert that nation is only formed on racial basis which is flawed. Nations can be formed even out of race and even india is not a single race

See, if you had vision we wud take example frmUS which has nothing in common yet it RULES the world.