Ravi Kishan-If Muslim countries can have a state religion then so can India.

[hussain0216]

This is what Jinnah was saying

Let everyone separate

Basically what these people are saying is Jinnah was right but because Indians are idiots they pushed this disastrous one united India policy that has gotten 1.4 billion Indians stuck in a communal shithole

So rather then separate during Partition, they convinced millions to remain part of a united secular India

Now that they want a hindutva state but they have hundreds of millions in minorities

Partition India PROPERLY then have a hindutva extremist state

 

[HalfMoon]

That will make a Hindu Rashtra an even easier certainty.

Either way there is nothing Muslims can do.

The decision will be for Hindus to make.

Sanghis and secular liberals alike.

Hindus can make whatever decisions in their A/C rooms. We will enforce our will on the streets.

 

[Naofumi]

Rich from a country that is rife with literacy, a country where having a burger puts your life at risk, a country that that has more beggars than the whole of Africa. You see before throwing stones remember you live in a glass house - and a brick will do more damage.
I frankly don’t care what they think or make India. Modi and his goons are well on the way to destroying it and perhaps having it carved into bits. Vile cauldron of vile anger and hatred

I didn't said India is perfect, India too had/have decades of religion based politics but I think we still did better than pure theocracies given our low base at independence.

 

[padamchen]

No Indian will accept another partition.

We crushed Khalistan 4 decades ago.

Hindus can make whatever decisions in their A/C rooms. We will enforce our will on the streets.

Like you tried in Delhi.

 

[HAIDER]

No problem. India can have Hindu as state religion. But respect the minorities and don't do forced conversion.

 

[Nilu Pule]

No problem. India can have Hindu as state religion. But respect the minorities and don't do forced conversion.

Indian Muslims will immigrate to Pakistan and Bangladesh eventually as they were supposed to.

 

[masterchief_mirza]

"India" has no right, historically, sociologically or anthropologically to call itself a Hindu state. Substantial contributions to the composition of the secular republic came from Muslims, mughals, "invaders", whatever you call them. Moreover, "Hinduism" as a religion and "Indians" from the north of the secular republic are substantively foreign constructs. The true gangadeshis have an argument, but the geographic boundaries of their gangadesh would be different to the artificial conglomerate known as the "secular republic". If the nation that calls itself "India" wishes to remain unified in its present format, it must acknowledge its mughal history and refrain from sidelining this reality.

 

[Buddhistforlife]

India was not created bcz of Hinduism. It was created bcz of Secularism. Muslims, Hindus, Sikhs all fought for the Independance unlike Pakistan.

So according to your logic a Islamic state is fine but making a Hindu state, Christian state, Jewish state and Buddhist state is a problem? Lolz.

 

[HAIDER]

Indian Muslims will immigrate to Pakistan and Bangladesh eventually as they were supposed to.

But, this hardly happened. Beside Muslim, there are Sikh and Christian too.

 

[padamchen]

"India" has no right, historically, sociologically or anthropologically to call itself a Hindu state. Substantial contributions to the composition of the secular republic came from Muslims, mughals, "invaders", whatever you call them. Moreover, "Hinduism" as a religion and "Indians" from the north of the secular republic are substantively foreign constructs. The true gangadeshis have an argument, but the geographic boundaries of their gangadesh would be different to the artificial conglomerate known as the "secular republic". If the nation that calls itself "India" wishes to remain unified in its present format, it must acknowledge its mughal history and refrain from sidelining this reality.

Personally I can find zero evidence of anything positive to have come out of Muslim rule in India.

The Brits in comparison pulled us kicking snd screaming into the industrial age.

Im willing to debate you on this if you can get beyond standard Islamophobia rants.

 

[GumNaam]

fundamental difference between Islam and hinduism, Islam UNITES humanity by eliminating the class/cast hierarchical social structure & discrimination while hinduism enforces the class/cast hierarchical social structure & discrimination. anyone with 2 braincells can decide that hinduism must NEVER be allowed as a national religion.

 

[hussain0216]

Indian Muslims will immigrate to Pakistan and Bangladesh eventually as they were supposed to.

Pakistan is only for Pakistani citizens

If Indians hate each other then partition India

 

[masterchief_mirza]

Personally I can find zero evidence of anything positive to have come out of Muslim rule in India.

The Brits in comparison pulled us kicking snd screaming into the industrial age.

Im willing to debate you on this if you can get beyond standard Islamophobia rants.

You've already made your mind up due to your parsi loyalties. Stick with 'em.

 

[padamchen]

You've already made your mind up due to your parsi loyalties. Stick with 'em.

So standard Islamophobia.

Ok.

At least I offered you the chance to show us how Muslims helped the subcontinent.

 

[PAKISTANFOREVER]

@Zarvan @Imran Khan @waz @fisher1 @Yaseen1 @PAKISTANFOREVER

Many muslim countries have Islam as state religion so what is wrong with India having Hinduism as a state religion?

I don't have a problem with that whatsoever and I have NEVER suggested otherwise. Nor have I ever criticized or insulted ANY religion. Have no idea why you have tagged me.